A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Art History

  • Ultra Realism in Anatomical Illustration, 18th Century.

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1477

    [In case there are younger readers here, this is a notice that some may consider the following images disturbing.]

    Anatomy john brown dancing In the antiquarian world of anatomy books dissection and presentation take place on many different levels–there are very straightforward, unadorned displays of various body parts on blank backgrounds and with no attention paid whatsoever to anything beyond the dissection; there are others that place the dissections and cadavers and whatever the subject of dissection might be in prosaic fields, or against a distant cityscape, or in a well-appointed room, or against a generic table, or within some sort of Baroque ornamentation, and so on.  (We’ll be seeing more of these presentations in the next few posts.)  In general though the work of the anatomist is presented in  a basically “finished” state–that is, the dissection is presented in an artistic manner, with a sense of design for the subject material. (Here’s one example of hundreds of possibilities: John Browne’s A Compleat Treatise of the Muscles, as they appear in the Human Body...1681.)

    There are not many examples (before, say 1850) in the history of anatomical display that show the specimens in the stage of display that was almost entirely unadorned, as though we are looking directly at the anatomist’s table.  Such is the case in the extraordinary work of the anatomist Govard Bidloo (1649-1713) and (artist) Gerard de Lairesse (1640-1711) called Ontleding des menschelyken lichaams…, published in Amsterdam in 1690, which is an unremitting attack on realism in the art of anatomy.  There is absolutely no favoritism paid to anything in these images except for truthful display, right down to the nails and pins used to give messy stuff a more-recognizable (to the layman) form. 

    Ontleding des menschelyken lichaams by Govard Bidloo and Gerard de Lairesse
    Ontleding des menschelyken lichaams... by Govard Bidloo and Gérard de Lairesse
    Engravings of the bones, muscles, and joints by John Bell

    Another, later, uncommon example of this realism is found in the 1804 work of John Bell’s Engravings of the Bones, Muscles, and Joints, Illustrating the First Volume of the Anatomy of the Human Body

    Illustrations of dissections by Ellis and Ford

    These images are a world away from the overwhelming majority of works of anatomy produced from the 16th to the 19th centuries; and that Bidloo’s work was so early makes it that much more remarkable. 

    Source note:  all images courtesy of the National Institutes of Health National Library of Medicine, here.


  • Blank and Missing Things Series–Antiquarian Anatomical Skin (Appended)

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1476  -part of the Blank, Missing and Empty Things series.

    Carl Ernst Bock (1809-1874) was a physician and anatomist (and son of the anatomist August Carl Bock of Leipzig, 1782-1833), whose many publications include the very popular  Hand-Atlas der Anatomie des Menschen  nebst einem tabellarischen Handbuche der Anatomie.(first printed in 1841).  This is a good example of his reaching out across the social strata to publish something that was accessible to the public-at-large, making him a pioneer in the distribution of medical information.

    I’m sorry to say that in all of this man’s beautiful work I  focused on this superior full-body anatomical–the odd thing here is that the only skin remaining on the body is on the head, where we see a  face and full head of hair.  To my experience this is a very highly unusual visualization.

    Anatomy bock482

    In an almost-the-opposite approach (which is much more common) Albert Adamkiewwicz (in his Taflen zir Orientierung an der Gehirnoberflaeche des lebenden Menschen...(printed in 1894, in Vienna) offers the following:

    Anatomy adamkiewicz484

    As with the other image above I only have a second generation image of this, and only in black and white–the color original is truly remarkable. 

    Another excellent example of an anatomical dissection leaving the face intact occurs several times in the massively interesting work of Jacques Gauthier Dagoty, whose work I remembered but whose name I forgot, making it fairly difficult to find the illustrations.  But here they are, from Anatomie des parties de la generation de l’homme et de le femme, published in Paris, in 1773, with Dagoty (1717-1785)  acting in multiple roles of author/designer/anatomist/painter, who produced these magnificent painterly dissection studies of great detail and warmth.

    Anatomie des parties by Gautier D’Agoty and Duverney

    And this:

    Missing skin b
    There are many other studies in the volume, but few retain the face.

    Then there’s this, the other end of the spectrum, where we see the flayed anatomical specimen and its skin though not in contact with one another, which is a special category indeedy:

    Missing skin c

    This copperplate engraving comes from Juan Valverde de Amusco (Valverde) (1525-1588 or thereabouts), Anatomia del corpo humano… (printed in Rome in 1559), and stands quite apart (though not alone) from the rest of the anatomical oeuvre of the 1550-1750 period.  

     And let’s not forget Thomas Bartholin’s frontspiece for his Anatomoa, published by F. Hackis in Leyden in 1651, which is similar to the Valverde:

    Anatomy skin bartholoiin

     


  • A High Achievement in Obstetric Art, 1781

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1473

    Anatomy bauldeqocue483

    One of the great thinkers in the history of gynecology was Jean Louis Baudeloque, whose 1781 book L’Art des Accouchemens was perhaps one of the most significant works in the history of obstetrics. This work was important not only for its great clarity and ease of explantion and control of its subject, but also for the exceptional illustrations.  I find them incredible not only for their spectacular detail but also for their control of blank space, a feat not easily accomplished…and I think a somewhat courageous approach to illustration during this era.

      Baudelocque

    For example, in the accompanying engravings (all of which are second generation and so are not nearly as sharp as the originals), we are left with a detailed image of only what was necessary for the explanation in the text, a terribly modern approach to illustration and clarity, so much so that it seems almost impossible that the image was made more than 230 years ago. 

    Baudelocque 2

    Obviously the representation and the subject matter give away the age of the image, but certainly not the design or placement.

    Note:  It should also be pointed out that chief among Baudeloque’s contributions was his teaching career, during which he would instruct upwards of 150 pupils per year (mainly at the Ecole de Sante) in clear and precise terms on his approach to obstetrics, not the least of which was in the use of instruments such as the foreceps and pelvimeter, a distribution of a very useful information base which seemed to have spread exponentially as his students went out into the midwifery field. 


  • Black Soils of the Renaissance (from the Things-out-of-Place Department)

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1471

    It is interesting to see things as they aren’t, particularly when the time things were being what they weren’t was a long time ago.  An example of this appears in an earlier post here about the use of red skies in Renaissance painting, which was something completely unexpected to me, a spectacular use of beauty found in an alternatively beautiful place, a reminder of why it looks so odd to us to see a clock running backwards.

    Why does a clock run clockwise, anyway?  It seems to me that most other things that go ’round seem to do so “counter clockwise”, and seeing a clockface with the hands sweeping themselves backwards ticking off the minutes and hours seems antithetcal, even though the same function is being performed–its just happening in a slightly different manner. 

    And so to the question of the ground.  If skies can be red, why not the ground black?  Especially in wood engravings that are 500 years old?  No reason for it not to be so, especially when you’re working in black ink and nothing else but the suggestion of open, unused white spaces, with no midtones.  And once you think about it a little, the use of black as a ground color makes perfect sense, differentiating it from the sky. Its just that we don’t think of the ground in that way, and so when it appears it seems quite out of place its a bit of a shock–but then we get over it, nearly instantly. And so the fortress of normalcy fails.

    Here’s a few examples of Black Soils of the Renaissance.

    “The Sick Vulture and his Mother”, from Aesop,  Vita Esopi, printed in Florence, 1508:

    Black soil 1471
    “Christ entering Jerusalem”, from Bonaventura, Meditazioni sopra la Passione, printed in Florence, about 1494.

    Black soil 2472
    Detail of the frontispiece to Epistolo e Evangelii, printed in Florence in 1495:

    Black soil 3473
    Frontispiece to Frederico  Frezzi, Il Quadriregio, printed in Florence, 1508:

    Black soil 4474
    Christophoro Landinus, Formulario di Epistole, “The Visitation”, Bologna, 1485:

    Black soil 5475

    “Damisella Trivulzia”, image from Giacomo Filippo Foresti, De Claris Mulieribus, printed in Ferrara, 1497

    Black soil 5476 Black soil
    Ludolphus de Saxonus, Levenons Heeren, “Disciples Plucking the Ears of Corn”, printed in Delft, 1488.

    Black soil 5477

    The Danse Macbre des Hommes, printed in Paris by Couteau and Menard, showing Death visiting the astrologer and the bourgeoise, 1492. 

    Black soil 5478
    There are no doubt many more, but these willl do for now.

    Did anyone mention the Solids in Uccello?

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • Backwards Atlas?

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

      Atlas470
    I found a rather unusual image in this sniffy but no doubt very useful book on heraldry.  On the reverse side of a medal shown below (“Augustus II D.G. Rex Pol M. D Lit. D. Sax. I.C.M.A.”, or declouded it is August II, D.G., King of Poland, Grand Duke of Lithuania, Duke of Saxony, Julich, Cleves, Berg, Angria, and Westphalia) we see a compromised image of Hercules, the only time that I can remember seeing him balancing the sphere on his chest.  It looks very uncomfortable. 

    Atlas469

    Originally Atlas was supporting a sphere representing the sky, a punishment that he stand on the Earth and support the Heavens so that the two did not meet.  Over modern time Atlas has been given a new burden to bear, and generally it is that of the Earth rather than all creation. 

    Of course if we went looking a little further to see what else Atlas might be doing with his burden, there is the following:

    Atlas
    where for ten cents it would have been possible to see the outcome of this epic battle; but since I can’t spend the ten cents here, we’ll never know.  It is interesting to see the representations of the mountains on the globe–given their bumpiness I’d say that their scale would relate to those peaks being 50 miles high.

    And just for the sake of it “Atlas” became associated with a colletion of maps bound in a volume in  Antonio Lafreri’s  Tavole Moderne Di Geografia De La Maggior Parte Del Mondo Di Diversi Autori (1572) not because he employed the word first, but rather because he used an image of Atlas on the book’s title page–the first use of he word comes a little later in the work of Gerald Mercator. 



  • Fantastic Composition & Design: Frozen Anatomy of a Hanged Man

     JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1494

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune03.jpg

    Source [National Library of Medicine]:  Braune, Wilhelm. Topographisch-anatomischer Atlas : nach Durchschnitten an gefrornen Cadavern. (Leipzig: Verlag von Veit & Comp., 1867-1872).  And Supplement: Braune, Wilhelm. Die Lage des Uterus und Foetus am Ende der Schwangerschaft. (Leipzig: Verlag von Viet & Comp. , 1872).

    This extraordinary work is part of an anatomical flap book by Wilhelm Braune (1831-1892), a professor of anatomy at the University of Leipzig.  The image above is a cross-section of the cadaver that was frozen and thinly cut in the similar vein (sorry!) as the more modern Adam & Eve of the Visible Human Project

    Visible human and which  consists of over 30 color lithographs of frozen cross sections of human anatomy.  The male images from the series are described by Braune:

    “[they are] taken from the body of a powerful, well-built, perfectly normal man, aged 21, who had hanged himself. The organs exhibited no pathological abnormalities. The body, which was brought unfrozen, was placed on a horizontal board … In this position, the subject lay untouched in the open air, and at the temperature of about 50 degrees F., for fourteen days. At the end of this time the process of freezing was commenced and completed …”

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune04.jpg

    The National Library of Medicine then continues with the description for preparation of the specimens:

    “After sections were cut, thin paper was placed over them and tracings were made of the anatomical features. Similar techniques were used to create the supplement, Die Lage des Uterus und Foetus am Ende der Schwangerschaft, which features large folded plates.  Tables B and C of the Supplement include large flaps showing different views of the lower half of the body, and scans were made of each flap along with the shared upper half (i.e. Table B (view 1), Table B (view 2), etc.).”

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune19.jpg

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune08.jpg

    Notes:

    Thw work was published in English as: Braune, W. An atlas of topographical anatomy after plane sections of frozen bodies. Trans. by Edward Bellamy. (Philadelphia: Lindsay and Blakiston, 1877)

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune01a.jpg

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune01b.jpg

    http://www.nlm.nih.gov/exhibition/historicalanatomies/Images/1200_pixels/braune2_B1.jpg

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • An Image Addition to a Series of Posts on the Antiquarian Publication of Artwork by Children

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    Part of this blog’s series on The Antiquarian Publication of Children’s Artwork

    Continuing an earlier post on the Great Rarity and Sublimity of Antiquarian Artwork by Children

    I have found another small bit to add to the few posts I’ve made on this blog concerning the wide, vacant spaces of antiquarian publications of children’s artwork.  Its a small bit, but every bit is very difficult to come by:

    Childrens art507   Childrens art508

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    I think that I can safely say that artwork by children does not make very many appearances in Western art prior to the 20th century–published images just don’t appear.  Nor do the originals–considering the ephemeral nature of the effort at art by children, their work just don’t seem to survive.  Some of that reason–particularly in America–was the scarcity of materials for kids to produce art with: paper was not inexpensive, and neither brushes and paints.  Crayons, invented for chubby and reachy fingers, were not invented for the mass market until 1903.  (Crayola sold eight crayons in a box for a nickel.  The colors?  Black, brown, blue, red, purple, orange, yellow, and green.)   Then of course the artwork would have to be saved, somehow, for generations.  As much as it would be fascinating to find artwork done at age four by your great-great grandparents, it would have to survive the cleansing tendencies of four generations of clean-up.  End result:  there’s just not that much antiquarian chldrens’ art floating around…

    (Continue reading here.)

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — — —

  • The Triumph of the World as Rota Fortunae

    JF Ptak Science Books    Quick Post  //  Update

    Fortune, good night, smile once more; turn thy wheel!.  King Lear, Act II Scene I

    World german410

    Not to be confused with another, earlier, engraving by Abraham Bach (the Elder, “d.A”) of the same title (published in Nuremberg in the late 17th century), this work by Joseph Uhl (published in the Illustrirte Zeitung, Leipzig, 24 October 1926) seems far more pessimistic, a scene of symmetrical futility.  The title translates roughly into the Triumph of the World, or the World Conquers All, or something along those lines, I think, and we definitely see the old orb impassively withstanding whatever it was that was happening on it–and whatever it was, it didn’t matter. 

    World german410
    The cleric at bottom left seems to be extolling the heavens in support of those who ascend the world to his favor (?), and as they reach the apex they either protect or try to repeal those who are supporting the golden calf.  At bottom right we see the ultimate disposition of the players, swept into a pile by an unconcerned sweeper. 

     My thanks to the commenter Redtarts for communicating “rota fortuna”–wheel of fortune–which I hadn’t connected to this image but which does of course make sense.  It does bear some striking similarity to the more classical wheels, which generally depict four (or more) figures of people in various stages of rising or declining in the course of life, the person on the top of course reigning supreme.  The allusion may have begun in early Roman times with the goddess Fortuna, famously depicted here in 1502 by Albrecht Durer:

    Durer, Fortune 1502

    The image of the wheel though is much earlier,, most people recognizing it so:

    Wheel of fortune

    This is the basic desin that is seen so often through the Medieval and Renaissance periods. 

    Carmina Burana:

    Fate – monstrous
    and empty,
    you whirling wheel,
    status is bad,
    well-being is vain
    always may melt away,
    shadowy
    and veiled
    you plague me too;
    now through the game
    bare backed
    I bear your villainy.
    . . . . . . . . .
    The wheel is turned by Fortuna;
    I go down, demeaned;
    another is carried to the height;
    far too high up
    sits the king at the summit –
    let him beware ruin!
    for under the axis is

    Dante’s Divine Comedy/the Inferno:

    No mortal power may stay her spinning wheel.
    The nations rise and fall by her decree.
    None may foresee where she will set her heel:
    She passes, and things pass.
    Man’s mortal reason cannot encompass her
    She rules her sphere as the other gods rule theirs.
    Season by season her changes change her changes endlessly,
    and those whose turn has come press on her so,
    she must be swift by hard necessity.

    Dante, Inferno VII 82-90


  • History of Dots in the First Pictorial Image Printed in America, 1670

    JF Ptak Science Books     Post 1463

    Ots mather414
    This installment to the thread on the History of Dots takes us to the very first print made in America–John Foster’s portrait of Richard Mather. Mather was ordained in England in 1620 but his Puritanism came to be a point of departure for him, and he sailed to America for his taste of religious freedom, arriving in 1635.  He was a pastor in Dorchester, Massachusetts, for the next 34 years until his death in 1669 at the age of 73. 

    As it turns out this portrait was made of him by John Foster just prior to his death and was not published until 1670, when Mather–who as it turns out who be the founding member of what would become a long-established and important family of clerics, including Cotton Mather–was already dead for a year. 

    He is shown holding a book, which—since this is the first print made in America–is also the first image of a book.  The book is held open by Mather’s enormous thumb–and what do we see in this book for words but dots.  Perhaps there are some dots, and perhaps there are some dashes, but its close enough for me.

    Ots mather414

    I do wonder about that horizontal line running across the image, appearing just under Mather’s whiskers. It seems like the woodblock was broken and pieced back together.  Perhaps it was just an accident.  Perhaps it was broken on purpose so that Foster could use an interchangeable body and replace the head, so that the next series of portraits would be easier for the artist, which he may not have been. He did take the care to render Mather’s spectacles, even if they are but little mites of specs. 

    In any event, Foster did a great job with very limited ability, and I think that the great blackness of Mather’s  body, which formulates the print’s large power, may have been done by mistake.  It really doesn’t matter, as the overall effect works beautifully well.

    Ots mather413


  • On Missing Antique Atlases of Imaginary Places and the Sameness of Alien Math and Music: Huygens’ 1698 ETs

    JF Ptak Science Books    Post 1458  [With thanks to Rich Lewis, Dickinson College, who found and suggested some remarkable cartographical curiosities!

    I was thinking about the history of atlases of imaginary places [in Western culture] composed before, say, 1900, and I had a hard time coming away with any.  Lowering the sites to a series of maps relating to the same idea didn’t help–its only when you get down to the single-map level that I found some results.  But even there, at the basic representational level of an imaginary place, there aren’t really that many examples, at least compared to the rich narrative life of created space.

    I wonder why that is? 

    If you widened the scope a bit you might look at the night sky as being a sort-of map locating ancient deities, but the sky is really just a picture book with dislocated images without very much to do with one another. 

    Books of the Dead1 kind of fit the bill, but how come there aren’t any surviving ancient maps of Olympus, or

    Bookofthedeadspell17
    Heaven for that matter?   The Heaven, and Hell, and Purgatory part does get mapped and mapped pretty heavily after Dante reaches the scene–there are at the very least dozens of cartographic/pictographic representations of the worlds that he surveyed in the Divine Comedy.  For example, there is this spectacular effort by Sandro Botticelli (being a drawing on parchment executed ca. 1480-1495):

    Hell_its_representation_through_the_ages

    The Botticelli is a scary accomplishment, frightening and heavy–you can almost feel the very burden of Hell coming down upon you. (Here’s a good link for a zoomifying version of this map so that you can see its elements in detail.)

    Then there are allegorical maps that show the stages and stations of life, the progress of the arts and sciences.  A fine example here is a work by B. Johnson, who in 1805 published this fantastic map of the possible paths for living one’s life:

       Maps of Imagination
    which seems to tell the reader to keep away from the southeast. Another  map, this one earlier, printed in 1777, is by J.G.I. Breitkopf, Das Reich der Liebe (The Kingdom of Love):

    Maps of the imagination--
     Another fantastic example of mapping the imagination is found in Matthaus Seutter’s Accurata Utopiae Tabula. Das ist Der Neu entdeckten Schalck Welt, oder des so oft benannten und doch nie erkannten Schlarraffenlandes, published in 1730.  It depicts a Utopia of sorts, though not the world of Thomas More–this is like a pyrite of utopias, a fool’s gold, a fools’ paradise:

    Maps of imagination  utopia

    This land is much like the land of Cockaigne, a mythical Medieval/Renaissance place of plenty, which is pictured below in an image made by Niccolop Nelli in 1564:

    Cockaigne1
    (It is interesting to picture these places of plenty and sloth in conjunction with some 20th century songs of the Great Depression and earlier, where the land of plenty is far, far simpler–as in the land of the Big Rock Candy Mountain–but that is a different story.)

     

    As long as we’re mentioning Utopia, here’s a 1516 representation of More’s hopefullness, from the first edition of his work:

    Maps imagniation More's utopia 1515

    And another represntation, two years later:

    Maps Imagination more's utopia

    There are more recent examples, but not that many, not so far, anyway.  There are editions of Pilgrims Progress (1678) that contain maps of the travels; there are also a number of charts showing the progress of Mr. Gulliver from the Swift book (1726);  Robinson Crusoe also contains a small sketch map opposite the title-page, and, more recently, R.L. Stevenson’s Treaure Island (1882) contains a map of that place.

    But given the extraordinarily rich tapestries of mythical/mystical places that have been created since the beginning of people telling stories, why weren’t there, well, tapestries (or something) illustrating what the whole of these places looked like?  Why for sample when we meet up with a map of the very pronounced extra-terrestrial wanderings of Cyrano de Bergerac (in his ancient-advanced science fiction work on traveling to other inhabited worlds)?  Taking the antiquarian thought on extra-terrestrials as a case study, why don’t we see more of that sort of thinking illustrated in some way?  The idea of extraterrestrial life is very old, stretching far back into Hindu cosmology, and even deep into the (eighteen worlds) of the Talmud.  Thales, Anaximander, Democritus, Aristole, Ptolemy all thought about and agreed on the possibilities of life being lived on places other than the Earth–infintely more life, in the case of Epicurus. Bruno, Copernicus, Fontenelle, Henry More–were all there, but without visual aids, and certainly without maps.  Except for Fontenelle–Bernard le Bovier de Fontenelle–who almost but not quite gets there in his 1682 book Entretriens sur la pluralite des mondes.

    Blog--plurality of world fontenelle :  

    It seems to me that as a representative of extraterrestrial imagination not being illustrated its hard to beat the case of the beautiful and polymathic Christian Huygens.  Huygens (1629-1685) worked across many fields, including astronomy, biology, math and physics, and was extraordinarily productive, making numerous contributions in the physical and theoretical areas, as well as being a prolific author and correspondant.  But towards the end of his relatively short life (he died at age 56) Huygens embarked down the science fiction road in pre-science fiction days, writing a wonderful and provocative book entitled Cosmotheoros, The Celestial World Discover’d: or, Conjectures Concerning the Inhabitants, Plants and Productions of the Worlds in the Planets3, where he establishes the possibilities of life being lived on worlds other than that of Earth. He developes a detailed fabric for these new heavens,m so much so that he can also establish samenesses for the ETs and humans, stating here his belief in the eternal/cosmoloigcal abilities of mathematics and music:

    “It’s the same with Musick as with Geometry, it’s every where immutably the same, and always will be so. For all Harmony consists in Concord, and Concord is all the World over fixt according to the same invariable measure and proportion. So that in all Nations the difference and distance of Notes is the same, whether they be in a continued gradual progression, or the voice makes skips over one to the next. Nay very credible Authors report, that there’s a sort of Bird in America, that can plainly sing in order six musical Notes: whence it follows that the Laws of Musick are unchangeably fix’d by Nature, and therefore the same Reason holds valid for their Musick, as we even now proposed for their Geometry”pg 86

    Huygens holds close to the immutable nature and close association of music and mathematics,m which would be the same here and everywhere (everywhere else, the ET communities, being referred to here as “other Nations”). 

    “For why, supposing other Nations and Creatures, endued with Reason and Sense as well as we, should not they reap the Pleasures arising from these Senses as well as we too? I don’t know what effect this Argument, from the immutable nature of these   Arts, may have upon the Minds of others; I think it no inconsiderable or contemptible one, but of as great Strength as that which I made use of above to prove that the Planetarians had the sense of Seeing.” pg 86/7

    Huygens is so sure of this that he is willing to tak a bet with long odds that not only do ETs enjoy the possibilities of muic but that they have also created instruments:

    “But if they take delight in Harmony, ’tis twenty to one but that they have invented musical Instruments. For, if nothing else, they could scarce help lighting upon some or other by chance; the sound of a tight String, the noise of the Winds, or the whistling of Reeds, might have given them the hint. From these small beginnings they perhaps, as well as we, have advanced by degrees to the use of the Lute, Harp, Flute, and many string’d Instruments. But altho the Tones are certain and determinate, yet we find among different Nations a quite different manner and rule for Singing; as formerly among the Dorians, Phrygians, and Lydians, and in our time among the French, Italians, and Persians” pg 87

    Huygens then continues to make a beautiful distinction between the musics of Earthling and ETs, in that it may not sound anything like any music we have on Earth, but–since the laws that govern math and music are the same, everywhere–it still might be “very good”.  And not only that, the alien music might be better than our’s:

    In like manner it may so happen, that the Musick of the Inhabitants of the Planets may widely differ  from all these, and yet be very good. But why we should look upon their Musick to be worse than ours, there’s no reason can be given; neither can we well presume that they want the use of half-notes and quarter-notes, seeing the invention of half-notes is so obvious, and the use of ’em so agreeable to nature. Nay, to go a step farther, what if they should excel us in the Theory and practick part of Musick, and outdo us in Consorts of vocal and instrumental Musick, so artificially compos’d, that they shew their Skill by the mixtures of Discords and Concords? pg 88

    And so on.  But why I wonder with all of the great images painted for us in his text is there no venturing into a visual artform?  There’s enough information in the Huygens work to allow for a map, but then there are none, not even something along the images of de Bergerac, who was perhaps among the greatest visionary of techno-anthropormorphic human flight.  Before he was the object of Edmund Rostand’s 1897 play, de Bergerac was a massively creative author, producing, among other things, the book Histoire des Etats et Empires de la Lune (History of the States and Empires of the Moon, published posthumously in 1657), followed by Histoire des Etats et Empires du Soleil (History of the States and Empires of the Sun, again, published further and deeper into his life’s surrender, 1662), both eventually collected as L’Autre Monde (Other Worlds).  Bergerac introduces us, the humble reader, to one of the most important concepts in the history of literature–namely that we humans were not only not alone in the universe, but that we were not even the dominant culture, and indeed we were actually hated by some of the other more advanced species.

    The foundations for structuring a visual habitat for the ideas of Huygens are abundant, as you can see easily in the table of contents (which is like an annotated table of contetns for a modern book) as seen in footnote #4–the signs for a road map are there, mostly–there’s just no road, but there are plenty of suggestions for one.

    So I bring this part of this open discussion to a close—I do ask forgiveness here in the likely case that I’ve left out some obvious examples, this is a Thinking-Out-Loud piece which takes place in the cultures west of the Urals–thinking about where the maps and images weren’t.  Finding almost nothing when you think there’s nothing there is easy to do, especially when you can hold yourself to a porous definition of “nothing”–the next step is harder, finding out how close people came to making these maps, or diagrams, or images.  

    And having said this about finding nothing I cannot let this piece go without mentioning The World’s Most Beautiful Map:  Lewis Carroll’s map from The Hunting of the Snark, an Agony in Eight Fits, and occurs in the Bellman’s tale, starting the second fit. It begins:

    The Bellman himself they all praised to the skies-
    Such a carriage, such ease and such grace!
    Such solemnity too! One could see he was wise,
    The moment one look in his face!
    He had bought a large map representing the sea,
    Without the least vestige of land:
    And the crew were much pleased when the found it to be
    A map they could all understand.
    “What’s the good of Mercator’s North Poles and Equators,
    Tropics, Zones, and Meridian Lines?”
    So the Bellman would cry: and the crew would reply,
    “They are merely conventional signs!
    “Other maps are such shapes, with their islands and capes!
    But we’ve got our brave Captain to thank”
    (So the crew would protest) “that he’s bought us the best-
    A perfect and absolute blank!”

    Snarkmap

    Sometimes there is nothing so fine as something that beautifully illustrates the nothing that isn’t there, and this lovely map, unencumbered of all of the elements and details that define the mapness of something,  perfectly explains the origin of its need.

    Notes:

    1.  They’re not really the Book of the Dead, but collections of papyrus that each contain a unique set of instructions and magic spells and such to assist its dead reader of getting fromthe dead place into the light, into the afterlife.  This image is a rather famous one, pictured and described in the following Wiki bit:  “The mystical Spell 17, from the Papyrus of Ani. The vignette at the top illustrates, from left to right, the god Heh as a representation of the Sea; a gateway to the realm of Osiris; the Eye of Horus; the celestial cow Mehet-weret; and a human head rising from a coffin, guarded by the four Sons of Horus.“

    2.  Here’s another version of the Dante structures placed in context to the Earth, this image by A. Ritter. 

    3. Following the edition of 1698 translations appeared in English (1698) and in Dutch (1699). In the following years, translations also appeared in French (1702), German (1703), Russian (1717) and in Swedish (1774)
     
    4.  The table of contents (with links) is extremely interesting and tells much of the story of the book:

    Book 1

    • Some have already talk’d of the Inhabitants of the Planets, but went no fartherThe Objections of ignorant Cavillers prevented
    •   This Enquiry not overcurious
    • Conjectures not useless, because not certain
    • These Studies useful to Religion
    • Copernicus’s System explain’d
    • Arguments for the truth of it
    • The Proportion of the Magnitude of the Planets, in respect of one another, and the Sun
    • The Lamell more convenient than Micrometers
    • The Earth justly liken’d to the Planets, and the Planets to it
    • Arguments from their Similitude of no small weight
    • The Planets are solid, and not without Gravity
    • Have Animals and Plants
    • Not to be imagin’d too unlike ours
    • Planets have Water
    • But not just like ours
    • Plants grow and are nourish’d there as they are here
    • The same true of their Animals
    • Great variety of Animals in this Earth
    • And no less in the Planets
    • The same in Plants
    • Rational Animals in the Planets
    • Vices of Men no hindrance to their being the Glory of the Planet they inhabit
    • Reason not different from what ’tis here
    • They have Senses
    • Sight
    • Hearing
    • A Medium to convey Sound to the Ear
    • Touch
    • Smell and Tast
    • Their Senses not very different from ours
    • They have Pleasure arising from the Senses
    • All the Planets have Fire
    • The bigness of their Creatures not rightly guest at by the bigness of the Planets
    • In the Planets are many sorts of rational Creatures as well as here
    • Men chiefly differ from Beasts in the study of Nature
    • They have Astronomy
    • And all its subservient Arts
    • Geometry and Arithmetick
    • And Writing
    • And Opticks
    • These Sciences not contrary to Nature
    • They have Hands
    • And Feet
    • That they are upright
    • It follows not therefore that they have the same shape with us
    • A rational Soul may inhabit another Shape than ours
    • The Planetarians not less than we
    • They live in Society
    • They enjoy the pleasures of Society
    •    They have Houses to secure ’em from Weather
    • They have Navigation, and all Arts subservient
    • As Geometry
    • They have Musick
    • The Advantages we reap from Herbs and Animals
    • And from Metals
    • From the discoveries of our Age
    • The Planets have, tho not these same, yet as useful Inventions 

    Book 2

    • Kircher’s Journey in Ecstacy examin’d
    • The System of the Planets in Mercury
    • In VenusIn Mars
    •  Jupiter and Saturn the most eminent of the Planets both for bigness and attendants
    • The proportion of the Diameter of Jupiter, and of the Orbs of his Satellites, to the Orbit of the Moon round the Earth
    • The periods of Jupiter’s Moons
    • And Saturn’s
    • This proportion true according to all modern Observations
    • The apparent magnitude of the Sun in Jupiter, and a way of finding what light they there enjoy
    • And in Saturn
    • Always the same length
    • They see the fixt Stars just as we do
    • The appearances of the Ring in Saturn
    • Very little to be said of the Moon
    • The Guards of Jupiter and Saturn are of the same nature with our Moon
    • The Moon hath Mountains
    • But no Sea, nor Rivers, nor Clouds, nor Air and Water
    • The Conjecture of its Plants and Animals very dubious Jupiter’s and Saturn’s Moons turn always the same side to them
    • The Astronomy of the Inhabitants of the Moon
    • This may be applied to the Moons about Jupiter and Saturn
    • The immense distance between the Sun and Planets illustrated
    • No ground for Conjecture in the Sun
    • The Faculty in the Sun not easily seen
    • By reason of its Heat no Inhabitants like ours can live in the Sun
    • The fix’d Stars so many Suns
    • They are not all in the same Sphere
    • The Stars have Planets about them like our Sun
    • A way of making a probable guess at the distance of the Stars
    • Every Sun has a vortex round it, very different from those of Cartes 
     

    See: 

    “This Is Not a Map”, by Max Byrd, The Wilson Quarterly  Vol. 33, No. 3 (Summer, 2009) (pp. 26-32).

    John Pickles, A history of spaces: cartographic reason, mapping and the geo-coded world,  (London and New York, Routledge, 2004)

    Katharine Harmon, editor, You are here: personal geographies and other maps of the imagination. (New York, Princeton Architectural Press, 2004).

    Giuliana Bruno. Atlas of Emotion: Journeys in Art, Architecture, and Film (New York, Verso, 2002).

    Denis Wood, ‘Map art’, Cartographic perspectives 53 (2006), pp. 5–14: p. 11.