A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Art History

  • The Stages of Human Life–Illustrated

    JF PTtak Science Books      Post 1796    [Part of the History of the Future series.]

    I came across this fantastic representation of the stages of human life in the beautifully-named book by Bartholomaeus Anglicus, All the Properytees of Thyings, which was published in Westminster in 1495 (and also known as De proprietatibus rerum, also translated as On the nature of things, or On the properties of things), and which was originally written around 1225).  The book was a bestiary, a marvelous encyclopedia, a collection of all things as known in the 13th century–it would be interesting to represent all that is know today and compact it into a workable, logical, usable (printed !) book of a thousand pages.  One of those many images was this:

     File:Stages of Life by Bartholomeus Anglicus 1486.jpga simple, compact reminder to the book’s readers about the progression of life.  Infant, toddler (in a Renaissance walker), child (at games), teen (adopting some of the trappings of adulthood), prime-of-life, middle aged and then the leaning elder. 

    It strikes me that the idea of “stages” is what most of what experience might be–the ideas of “stages” and “progression” are everywhere, even perhaps in the places they shouldn’t be.  There are simple things like rockets that keep releasing smaller and smaller stages of itself until it gets down to the (satellite etc.) nub; sleep has its five stages resulting in the final resting state of r.e.m.,; there are recognized stages of  development for psychology (Erikson), and cognition (Piaget) and need (Maslkow) and  moral (Kohlberg), and spiritual (Fowler), and  economic (lots) and on and on into the progressive stages of the sunset. Progression and series belong in arithmetic and geometry (and etc.) and in the scientific method, as well as music (succession of chords) and disease (more so than health).  Examples are limitless.  But for right now, I just wanted to post a few images of these antique reminders of progression and mortality…

    The Stages of Life, broadside published by James Catnach, London c. 1830. British Museum.

    File:The Stages of Life BM 1992 0125 31.jpg


  • Unusual Antiquarian Perspective–Directly Above and Oblique. J.J. Grandville, 1844

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    This is the fourth installment in as many days (starting here) on the artwork of the great proto-Surrealist, J.J. Grandville.  Today’s quick post (again from his Un Autre Monde, 1844) isn’t so much fantastical as the other work pictured here, but it is subtly unusual.  It is my experience in looking at prints and other artwork for the last 30 years or so that antiquarian images looking straight and directly down froma  height are very unusual–so too for the next thing closest to it, looking down from a slightly oblique angle.  Grandville does this often in his work, and I think gives another insight into a brain that was just seeing (most) things differently.  [Here’s a link for some posts on looking straight down, here and here, for example.]

    photo

    photo
    photo
    photo
    photo
    photo

     


  • Proto-Surrealist Flying Machines

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1790

    In what he gives to thee, this Paradise
    And thy faire Eve; Heav’n is for thee too high
    To know what passes there; be lowlie wise:
    Think onely what concernes thee and thy being;
    Dream not of other Worlds, what Creatures there [ 175 ]
    Live, in what state, condition or degree,
    Contented that thus farr hath been reveal’d
    Not of Earth onely but of highest Heav’n.

               –J Milton, Paradise Lost, Book 8 (The Argument), line 175 ff

    This is another in a series of posts (starting here with an introduction) on the great J.J. Grandville, a visionary artist of high imagination with good strong claims to being an 1840’s proto-Surealist.  This small collection of flying machines appears in his Un Autre Monde, published 1844. 

    photo
    photo

  • The Artist Having the Last Word…and from a Height

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    I’ve been writing and thinking about J.J. Grandville (see the opening post in this series here  on his proto-Surrealist work) and then took another look at the ending illustration (the last of over 200) of the great proto-Surrealist’s Un Autre Monde (1844).  Initially I thought that the word was “Ici” (“Here”), meaning that the end had been reached, Here, and that the arts (represented by the writing instruments)  were giving thanks for a job well done and completed.  On closer inspection, there’s more to it than I thought. (This may be already very well-trod ground, but its new to me–my apologies if this is elementary to any art history folks.)

    Grandville IGI
    The word isn’t “Ici”–its not even a word.  The letters are the initials of the pseudonymous Grandville, whose true name was Jean Ignace Isidore Gérard, and so wrote the “I” “I” as columns with the “G”erard as the central bit.  And perhaps the little fellow at the top is a pencil, which would have been the tool of choice for Grandville–and so Grandville, the artist, would be on top of the “G”: of his name celebrating his achievement above the other implements of book production (the quill, followed by the pen, the wax stamp (?) and a pocket knife/cutting tool), the artist standing tall above them all.   Or perhaps not. 


  • On a Quality of Being Indistinct–Melville and Turner

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1778

    For a painter to make a point of looking for poetry in the conception of a picture is the surest way for him not to find it.–C. Baudelaire.

    The qualities of being indistinct certain have their places, though those places are relatively rare in areas like the engineering of dam or bridge building, or in the rules of a game like chess.  Over time these qualities have certainly changed and manifested in different fields, say, for example, in literature and art–particularly in art.

    This brings us to Melville and Turner. It is a curious thing to see Herman Melville’s collection of J.M.W. Turner engravings, to see what the man collected and what might have drawn him to those particular pieces. After all, Melville was a necessary collector–he needed things, sometimes needing them more than his family needed things, like food–and so to see the visual items that were “necessaries” is very interesting.

    And when you look at the engravings of the Turner paintings in most cases they bear little resemblance to the original.  As a famous and respected, highly admired artist for more than 40 years, Turner’s early works can also be considered famously ‘indistinct”.  As a matter of fact,  that was a major concern of some of the great artists and critics of the time,  viewing some of Turner’s beautiful pre-pre-Impressionist works. (His very highly Impressionist works reaching back to just before 1800, very well in advance of Boudin and Manet, Corot and Millet, Daubigny and Courbet, and the rest.) People didn’t quite know what to do with the “indistinct” shorelines in his naval/maritime works, or the suggestions of people, or the fantastic mystical skies of deep foreboding and threat communicated with emphasis on color and suggestion more so than accurate physical representation. 

    Robert K. Wallace takes on the issue of this relationship between the literary and artistic giants in Melville and Turner, Sphere of Love and Fright (University of Georgia Press, 1992) and discusses it very fully over 635 pages.  I was interested to see the list of the Turner engravings collected by Melville and of course everything else that went along with that.  Wallace notes John Landseer’s reaction to one of Turner’s earlier and not tremendously impressionist works (Sheerness as Seen from the Nore, which is a great title in and of itself)  was very guarded, saying that the shorelines “are little more than threads in the distance”, and writing in 1808 of The Confluence of the Thames and the Medway of the painting’s “indefinity”, and of his doubtfulness of the “indistinctness” of Richmond Hill and the Bridge“. After all, even the pre-impressionists really wouldn’t begin to make a full appearance for a few more decades, and the subject of suggestion of form in painting rather than their depiction was a very major issue.

    Turner would move more deeply into his expressive creativity as he grew older, producing work after work of high impressionist qualities, such as, for example, Death on a Pale Horse (1825-1830), Staffa, Fingal’s Cave (1832) and

     

    [Staffa, Fingal’s Cave.]

    Death on a Pale Horse by J.M.W. Turner

    [Death on a Pale Horse.]

    Rain, Steam and Speed (1859).  Wallace relates a great story of the first Turner painting making its way to the United States, coming by way of a purchase by James Lenox of the Staffa painting, arriving here in 1845, already very deep into the career and life of Turner (1775-1851). When it arrived and unboxed, the new owner Lenox was extremely surprised by the suggestive qualities of the painting, which to him “appeared so indistinct throughout” (Wallace, page 74).  Lenox wrote Turner with his observations, when he wondered if the trip by sea had actually done something to the paint of the picture, rendering its detail obsolete.  Turner replied that the “indistinctness is my fault”.  Lenox was certainly seeing something new–it was something revolutionary in art and vision, and not a spoilation by salt and sea.

    So I wondered about Melville’s collection of Turner, and how the engravings might differ from the paintings, and how in general the work would be more tailored for a general audience, with the great “indistinctness” of the works lost in incised lines on copper and steel.  Did Melville know the of the differences between the mass produced item and the original painting?  Or did that matter, at all, particularly if Melville was looking at the ships and other parts of the images that reminded him of his own experiences real or imagined, and that his brain would fill in the detail as necessary?  (And there are certainly differences, as we can see below:)

    An engraving of Turner’s Burial at Sea as it would have existed in Melville’s collection:
    Melville turner burial at sea
    And Burial at Sea, as a painting:
     
    Turner--burial at sea
     
    Source; http://www.tate.org.uk/art/artworks/turner-peace-burial-at-sea-n00528

    Another question is whether or not Melville would have known the difference, or if he was even aware of the great idea of indistinctness existing in Turner’s originals, and what this new way of painting would come to represent.  At this point, I’m not sure, and I’m not sure that I need to be sure, at all.  Perhaps the issue is best left to question, being left to its own indistinctness, left for interpretation and imagination.  I think that is good enough for me, right now. 

    Other examples of Melville’s collection of Turner images compared to the originals:


  • Visualizing the Normally-Unseen: Roentgen, Marey, Malevich

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1775

    Pleasant_1bertha The 1895/1896 issues of Nature magazine are compliantly normal until the first weeks of 1896 when the first of a flood of articles is published about the astonishing discovery of 50-year-old Wilhelm Conrad Röntgen. The English-language popular science journal announcement of his December 28, 1895  “Ueber eine neue Art von Strahlen” (“On a New Type of Ray”), appearing 16 January 1896, began the introduction of a new state of human experience.  His experiments—built upon the work of J. Plucker (1801-1868), J. W. Hittorf (1824-1914), C. F. Varley (1828-1883), E. Goldstein (1850-1931), Sir William Crookes (1832-1919), H. Hertz (1857-1894) and the odious Phil Lenard (1862-1947 and who didn’t die soon enough)—revealed as much to humans as did the experiments and inventions of Hooke and Leeuwenhoek on the invisible worlds revealed by the microscope.  There are more than 150 articles on the Roentgen (and soon to be “X-“) Ray, all published within 12 months of the original announcement, almost all excitedly, trying to comprehend, elucidate, expand, verify, this new world. 

    Blogxraybigads_2 [The news of the discovery is first and most popularly reported in the January 6, 1896 London Standard:  “The noise of war’s alarm should not distract attention from the marvelous triumph of science which is reported from Vienna. It is announced that Professor Routgen (sic) of the Wurzburg University has discovered a light which for the purposeBlogxrayad of photography will penetrate wood, flesh, cloth, and most other organic substances. The Professor has succeeded in photographing metal weights which were in a closed wooden case, also a man’s hand which showed only the bones, the flesh being invisible”. By the end of the month the news was completely absorbed, worldwide.]

    I looked at the advertising in these issues (my copies of Nature for these decades generally have the original paper wrappers for the weeklies, complete with ad copy), looking for the first time that a Roentgen machine was offered for sale to the general public.  As it turns out, they popped up 12 March 1896 (once), 19 March (twice), and then about once a week for the rest of the year.  A little surprising, I think, a little light to my Monday-morning quarterback’s eye—I expected more; bigger, more, splashier.  But the ads are small and sedate, hardly similar to the discovery they represent. 

    Blogfeb_22marey The rest of the world, the rest of the advertising world, stayed the same–the Roentgen discovery and the enormous possibilities and promises of his “new photography” lived in their own unique sphere, unencumbered by their sassy new brother.   This mild response seems dimmer still when you compare it to that which greeted other (relatively) simple but still major advancements in the world of photography.  Take for example Etienne Marey, who was a technoid and physician who was able to capture motion of all sorts–he was able to develop a picture so to speak of the movement of blood in the body via his instrument to calculate blood pressure, and he also created a shotgun-style camera that made the Blog_feb_22_nude world’s first high-speed photographs of movement.  And so it cane to pass that in the late 1870’s and early 1880’s people were instantly able to see what a horse looked like when it galloped or what the body did *exactly* when jumping over a chair.  When you couple this with fourth-dimension material one wonders why it took several more decades to bump into these images in the art of 1907+. 

    (Duchamp Nude Descending series, 1915; above, Marey, 1881)

    And what indeed was normal in these pages?  Magic lanterns
    and magi lantern slides appearMagiclantern at all levels; the gorgeous Wimshurst machine gets heavily advertised; the redoubtable Negretti & Zambra advertised all manner of excellent scientific instruments (biographs, thermogrphs.  Nadeer Bros. advertised a pretty standard cell, and the ancient Crossley displayed their “new” oil engines, “suitable for all classes of agricultural work”.  J.H. Stewart was selling their semi-automatic electric arc lamp, while across the page was Newton & Company’s “Newtonian” arc lamps for lanterns (“self feeding and focus keeping”).  Microscopes and prepared slides abound, and Thomas Bolton advertises discretely and effectively for their “living specimens for the microscope”. 

    The Physical Review, the American upstart in the science world advertises that its third volume was available, while its distant cousin, the Psychological Review, advertised its own third volume.  Booksellers seem to take the most space, thank goodness. 

    Blogxrayepps There are a few medical throwbacks:  Epp’s Cocaine takes out occasional tenth-page ads for their “cocoa-nib extract, tea-like” selling its ‘gentile nerve stimulant”.  Right underneath is “Holloway’s Pills”, promising to cure biliousness, sick headache, indigestion, and all (?!) internal complaints.   These are brilliant simple samples of the skeleton of science in world-dominant Great Britain, in a world dominated at that time by H.A, Lorentz, Ernst Mach , Roentgen, Korteweg, de Vries, Bateson, Jean-Baptiste Perrin, Pierre Curie, Zeeman, Becquerel, Joseph Thomson,  Ernest Rutherford, Marconi, Ramsay, Fitzgerald.  And so on. 

    Nothing offered for sale here offered any significant clue to the pregnant world of modernity that was nearlyBlogxray3 there—the world would become ‘modern” almost immediately following Roentgen, with revolutionary, epochal changes in art (in non-representational form more so than Impressionism), theater, literature, music.  Just about everything changed (except politics).  But there is no hint to paradigm shift hidden in the ads, just as they were with the machines selling the promise of Roentgen’s “new photography.  There’s something about the fine glass, superb turning of the screw, and a perfectly oiled gear though that makes this sort of perfection seem so lonely in the world of larger change.  Bertha, Roentgen’s wife, sat for 15 minutes while her husband passed his rays through her hand; she ran from the room once she saw the results, revealing her very bones and no doubt a strong sense of the Blog_feb_22_malevich

    fragility of life, and the strong presence of death.  Many had the same reaction to the Kandinsky’sBlogxrayad2 shapes and Malevich’s white circles and red rectangles and Ibsen’s drama and Einstein’s dancing dust and the rogue syncopation of jazz.  It is probably a very natural reaction to try and protect established memory—but memory should be more flexible than that, I think, to keep a healthy mind.


  • The Rot of Modern Art–1910

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1765

    “Suddenly I had entered a new world, a universe of ugliness”.–Gelett Burgess, on entering the Salon des Independents Exhibition, 1910

    One of the earliest recognitions of the great early masterpiece of Cubism, Picasso’s Les Demoisselles d’Avignon, makes its appearance in the Architectural Record1, and by a most-unanticipated critic:  Gelett Burgess (1866-1951).  Burgess glides through an unexpectedly wide terrain of The Modern, and has quite a lot of interesting observations, including George Braque and Czobel, Friesz, Harbin, Metzinger, Derain, Chibaud, Matisse  and–perhaps most significantly–Pablo Picasso.  Burgess found his way to Les Demoisselles, and presents a photograph of what would become perhaps the great masterpiece of Cubism, the caption announcing it as a “study” rather than with any real title for the work.  As is well known Picasso worked for some years on the painting (generally the work is assigned a date of 1907 though he worked on it for some years afterwards), spending time alternatively in great loneliness and also in the midst of crowds of the interested/supporters/friends/the curious, sometimes hoping for feedback of his major work from the visitors, sometimes not. 

    Burgess was known as an accomplished illustrator with a distinctive and distinguished style, as well as a humorist-poet, a poet whose best-remembered (and longest-surviving) lines run as follows:

    “I never saw a Purple Cow,
    I never hope to see one,
    But I can tell you, anyhow,
    I’d rather see than be one!”

    And I think that it is in this style that Burgess concedes his opinion of Picasso’s work, complete with a short bit of a poem at the end:

    “And now for Picasso, of whom, here and there, one has heard so much. Picasso will not exhibit his paintings. He is too proud and too scornful of the opinions of the canaille. But he sells his work, nevertheless. That’s the astonishing thing about all of them. Who buys? God knows! Germans, I suppose.”


    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • The Ouroboros and Infinity

    JF Ptak Science Books    Post 1762

    Ouroboros390
    The ouroboros–and in this particular case, the double, over-and-under ouroboros–is an interesting and ancient symbol.  In my experience, the single unit is to be expected, but the double seems uncommon. The symbol (“oura” or tail and “boros”, eating, in Greek, one who eats one’s tail) stretches back into the dim and dusty past, at least to the Egyptian Book of the Dead, and is Plato’s first living thing–its is the primordial unity, the rebirth of forever, death/life/birth/rebirth, continuing into infinity, the great world soul…a kind of Western equivalent of the Taoist Yin Yang.

    There’s much more to be said about this symbol, especially by such people as Erich Neumann and Carl Jung, but I’ll resist, mainly because it is just too complicated for me to make an intelligent statement. (I’ve tried to read the Great Mother as well as The Origins of the History of Consciousness by Neumann, but only made my way around the edges of the first, and picked through the interesting bits of the later.  Jung is someone I’ve never had much luck with.)

    The first symbol, and a gorgeous one it is, comes from the Theatrum chemicum (1659-1661, and published in six volumes by Lazarus Zetzner in Strasbourg), and shows the combination of what was supposed to be an alchemical highpoint:  the spiritual coming together of sulfur and mercury, elements of what the practioners believed were the basic constituents of all metals and minerals.  And of such stuff miracles were understood to be made, except that of course, they weren’t–the fact that this stuff never worked to produce something more substantial than mercuric sulfide wasn’t due to the theory or practice or thought but to the “fact” that the mercury and sulfur used in the process weren’t “pure” enough.  That said, the Theatrum was a very important work, the largest collection of alchemical works ever gathered and published together–it was also evidently much appreciated by Isaac Newton, who was said to consult it often and who owned the set in his library.

    A more classical appearance of the ouroboros (De Lapide PhilosophicoTriga Chemicum (Prague 1599) compiled by Nicolas Barnaud), depicting a dragon seizing the polarities of its soul, ultimately uniting them: 

    File:Ouroboros 1.jpg

    And in the discussion of the ouroboros and philosophical aspects of infinity it should be mentioned that there is some connection between it and the mathematical symbol for infinity, which seems to arise from (the remarkable and original) John Wallis’ De Sectionibus Conicibus, which was published in 1655.  Wallis employed the old Roman symbol for 1,000 to use for the mathematical infinity, which of course is the ouroboros on its side.  (Wallis it should be noticed was also among the earliest people to put into print the symbol for pi, as well.)

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — — — —

  • The Dance of Work: Satires and Grotesques of the Professions, 1700.

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1754

     

    Nicolas de Larmessin (1640-1725) was an enormously creative and productive artist, and in his way created a genre similar to the great and ancient Dance of Death/.Danse Macabre/Totentanz--though his was the Dance of Life. Or perhaps it was something less political and  philosophical, simply showing itself as a Dance of Work,  A Satire of Occupation.  (In the earlier, 14 & 15th century printed version of the Dance of Death, which shows death coming to people of different professions, that the earliest meetings between death and its intended depict death done only in bones, and is relatively scary; later on, moving into the 17 and 18th centuries, death occasionally wears some elements of the profession of the person whom he seeks, giving the expedition a little share of irony or dark comedic relief.  In general, though I find the Wolgement, Holbein, Durer varieties of death-hungry Death to be fairly well off-putting; those later on less so.)

    About 100 of these images from de Larmessin were published over a period of time and in variously-titled works, appearing as Les costumes grotesques et les métiers, and Costumes grotesques and Habits des métiers et professions–maybe they were more grotesques than anything else, or satires.  Nicolas was part of a long family history of the de Larmessin (also L’Armessin) family,  a famous series of generational  engravers and  printers, who worked and functioned in the 17th and 18th centuries.

    To me the devil of his work is in fact in the details, and their accumulations. There very well may be a lot to study in the minutiae of what each profession has hanging to the ends of their clothing–or at least it seems possible that some previously overlooked widget gets a little public airing in one of these images…

    Some of the alphabet of professions treated by de Larmessin include:  Baker, (Boulanger), Basket maker (Vannier), Blacksmith (Ma Brick Mason (Masson), Butcher (Boucher), Chef (Cuisinier), Chest and Box maker (Malletier-Coffretier), Clock maker (Corlogeur), Clothes seller (Fripier), Coffee merchant (Caffetier), Comb and brush seller (Peigné), Comedian (Comédien), Dairy & cheese maker (Laitier), Farm laborer (Labourer), Fisherman (Pescheur), Furier (Foureur), Gardener (Jardinier), Hat maker (Chapellier), Hosier (Bonnetier), Knife and Sissor Sharpener (Remouleur), Locksmith (Serrurier), Leather worker (Ceinturier), Miller (Meusnier), Money changer (Monnoyer), Maker of table games (Tabletier), Perfume maker/seller (Parfumeur), Playing Card printer (Cartier), Plume and feather seller (Plumassier), Plumber (Plombier), Printer (Imprimeur), reschal), Saddle maker (Sellier), Second-hand Shoe maker (Sauetier), Tailor (Tailleur), Wheel wright (Charron), Wild Game chef/seller (Rotisseur), Wild Game chef/seller (Rotisseur),Wine merchant (Cabaretier), Wine maker (Vigneron).

    Source for all following images:  Live Journal

    But before proceeding any further, I must at least make reference to another master in this field, an earlier, perhaps revolutionary figure, Arcimboldo (1527-1593), who produced royal portraits composed entirely of fruits and vegetables, as so:

    http://www.lessing-photo.com/p2/400706/40070643.jpg

    The people and professions portrayed by de Larmessin are “people” underneath it all; with Arcimboldo its fruit and veggies all the way down, just like with the Dance of Death, there’s nothing beyond the bone but disappeared bone.  


  • A Temple of Bricks: London, 1872

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    There is almost nothing in this image except for bricks–a few people are in their tiny gardens, and there’s a tiny bit of sky visible just above the train on the railway bridge.  But the medium of the image is brick. And smoke,  and soot.  Sooty red bricks rendered in black-and-white in this homage to the working classes of London, a temple of bricks for the second-generation members and cogs of the industrial revolution, packed together in a neat and orderly and tight way.  By this point, in 1872, there were strong differentiations between the lower middle class and the working poor, and these people below–with their own houses and yards–are the lower middle class and the very backbone of the British Empire.

    This is the work of Gustave Dore from 1872, “Over London by Rail”, as it appeared in Blanchard Jerrold’s London, a Pilgrimage (1872).  It seems that in this collaborative expedition into the city of London that the Frenchman-_Dore–gives us the best view of what life was like then.  The pair set out to document, to record, to observe–Blanchard provides the text, and he does a very good job at seeing and responding to it,m doing so with almost no interior thoughts about causes or reasons.  Dore responds with pictures, and for the most part is a devastating chronicler. 

    Some of the 180 illustrations can be seen here.