A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Absurdist, Unintentional

  • Found Sound: Kircher, Pythagoras, Blacksmiths & Earbones

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1358

    [Above:  a gorgeous display of ear bones of humans and animals: reading across the top:  man, cow, hors,e dog, leopard, cat, rat, pig and sheep, coming from Athanasius Kircher’s book on sound and acoustics, and about the first of its kind:  Musurgia Universalis, printed in Rome in 1650.  Image from Special Collections of the University of Glasgow library, and which is the bottom half of the engraving reproduced int he “notes” section1.]

    It seems that almost all of human history’s hearing has been impressionistic–a collection of aural landscapes that would disappear as soon as they were ended, unless of course someone was there to write down what was heard on papyrus or sand or mud or clay or paper.  Finding the sound was important because, well, it was a single-shot phenomenon, unless it was repeated by the presenter, or someone else copied the presentation, or wrote it down so that it could be read and interpreted later.  It was a phenomenal invention of Mr. Edison’s that brought the possibility capturing sound so that it could be played over and over again, the experience becoming a simple piece of technology available to anyone who could afford it.

     The odd thing now is that virtually everything is findable, recordable, archivable.  We can also hear just about anything from just about anywhere.  Before the telephone–invented by Mr. Bell only 135 years ago–in order to hear something from a distance beyond the normal auditory range, a person would’ve needed the assistance of objects such as these “propagation horns” from Kempsten’s Phonurgia nova (of 1673, pictured at left).  Sir Samuel Morland, a fantastic English polymath (1625-1695) also produced an instrument similar to this in his stentoro-phonica, constructed in the 1660’s  It is in a way similar to the giant listening devices devised and constructed by the Imperial Japanese Army in the earliest days of WWII, prior to their use of radar.   Or, if one was a monarch or other highly placed aristocratic or ruling class person, one could have used something like Kircher’s listening device, found again in his Musurgia Universalis of 1650 so that a little eavesdropping might go on from one far-placed room to the next. 
     

     

    Wheel-mounted acoustic locators for detecting enemy aircraft over Japan in the 1930s
    [Kircher’s device, below.]
    If one were to construct a monument to “found sound” certainly an important element of it would have to involve Pythagoras, who by virtue of walking past a group of blacksmiths heard something in their pounding that struck him deeply, exciting his foundational ideas about pitch.
    We see him featured prominently in the frontispiece to the Kircher work mentioned above–well, that and a lot of other symbolism as well.

    The blacksmiths are seen at middle bottom, and the man to their left is Pythagoras, pointing to them with a staff, seeming to lean on a marble pillar, but what that really is is a manuscript of his theorem regarding pitch.  reigning over all is a sun representing the Holy Trinity, its rays anointing the earth in the forms of light and angels, the world scene in the center, surrounded by the zodiac and hosting the seated Musica, all representing the ealier beliefs of mathematical/artistic/musical relational proportions, the music of the spheres. [There are other interesting appearances:  musical instruments at the feet of Pythagoras, Pegasus (perhaps?) at the top of the stairs at middle-right, mermaids in the distance, and of course the figure at right, surrounded by all sorts of musical instruments as well as a golden owl.  Of lesser importance but of high interest is the figure just to the right of Pythagoras’ elbow, a figure who seems to be singing, or yelling, or attempting to hear an echo,]
    Perhaps the most significant manufactured found sound–in the tradition of Swift and later that of Burroughs and Gysin–was Kircher’s absolutely fabulous  music-making machine, the arca musarythmica.  It was with a device such as this that any person of any (in)sensibility could compose a slightly pre-arrnaged piece of music, combining previously tranbscribed scores together at random to produce a wholly new musical composition. As described  on the Glasgow Library site, the instrument functioned so: 

     

    The arca musarythmica is a device by which a non-musician could compose a piece of four-part music using prearranged musical fragments inscribed in wands arranged in columns inside the box. Each type of wand corresponded to a particular metrical unit e.g. 4, 5, or 6 syllables, and on each wand there were examples of florid counterpoint on one side and more simple note-against-note settings on the other. Once the phrase to be set had been analyzed into its fundamental syllabic units, each of these could be set to an example taken from a wand of the appropriate type

    I don’t reckon that I’d like the music much (have there been any recordings of anything ever “composed” in this way?) but I sure would like the object. 
    Notes:

    1.

  • Baroque Weeping Baby Skeletons, the Creation of Man, Genesis and a Tiny Bit of All That.

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1357

    Jean-Jacques Scheuchzer’s Physique Sacree (published 1732-1737) is an enormous, plumply illustrated thing, an extraordinarily diverse work on the Old Testament and the antique sacred and its relationship to the panoply of natural philosophy.  Its  759 illustrations are usually given overly-encrusted decorated borders by a diverse and at times bizarre selection of themes from biology, geology, astronomy, physics, chemistry, and whatever else seemed to work. It is a production of the High Baroque and high imagination, working within the very definite confines of ecclesiastical squareness and scientific roundness–and somehow the pegs all seem to fit, for Scheuchzer.

    The image that I latched onto [and which is available at 200% if you click through it]  illustrates Genesis I 26, 27:

      Baroque480

    “26: And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth.
    27: So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.”

    Indeed.  We can see the pure holly light (appreciably wide as it gets to its subject than when it started, where it is also degraded)  extending diagonally across the image to a surprised/fearful Adam, who is popped into a landscape of the newly-created.  But it is the border illustration that is most extraordinary to me–it is an 11-segment depiction of the birth process, told almost exclusively in baby skeletons.  The story begins at top-right corner, with perhaps a hint of conception, and then through  developmental stages II (embryonic) and then III/IV (taking us through the third month) and then V through VII (showing perhaps through the seventh month or so), displayed in a top- and bottom-middle display, and not in order.  I really don’t know enough of developmental anatomy to say what is depicted in images VIII through XI, except to note that–of course–they are all skeletons, and the last is weeping. 

    Spermatozoa seem to be missing in images I and II, or at least Scheuchzer didn’t make an attempt to show them at work, even though he must’ve been aware of their existence, discovered  fifty years earlier (in 1677) by Leeuwenhoeck.  But this discovery certainly didn’t get in the way of maintaining the theory and belief in the homonuclus–the tiny, preformed person carried completely within the sperm and implanted in the woman who served basically as an oven, a receptacle.  Scheuzcher believed on the other hand that the homonuclus was located in the ovaries–still part of the preformationist camp, but getting closer to elevating the importance of woman in embryological development.

     [All that said I don’t know the reason for the weeping skeleton; or, for that matter, what the things are that the two skeletons at upper left are holding.]

    The homunuclus, famously illustrated in Nicolas Hartsoeker’s Essay de Dioptrique in 1694: 

    Ovary Hartsoeker


  • The Nonsense of Strategically Meaningful Phrases–Finding Pillows in the Post-Nuclear-Attack World, 1968/9

     JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1356

    Caveat: this story is of course forever and best told by Stanley Kubrick’s Dr. Strangelove.

    Researching a study on the usefulness of the actions of Adolf Hitler amd their application to the U.S. government’s planning possibilities for post-nuclear-holocaust existence (German Wartime Industrial Controls: an Analogy to Recovery from Nuclear Attack, Stanford Research Institute, 1968, review coming soon), I came across the following related studies, all of which are available at the Storming Media website, here.

    The titles are incredible, the abstracts more so–but some phrasing in the abs were absolutely, sensationally, bad. 

    I can imagine a play, a scenario leaning heavily on Samuel Beckett’s Krapp’s Last Tape, men sitting in front of reel-to-reel tape recorders, listening to themselves describing the impossible language that they were using to transmit the ideas of surviving nuclear Armageddon–brilliantly lit from single spots directly above the seated figures and with all else absolutely black, they play these snippets, and try to explain what the language actually meant. Perhaps they try to talk over the recordings, only to have the recorded audio get a little louder, and multiply, a la Steve Reich’s Come Out.

    I understand that in order to talk about a complicated and complex landscape that you need to establish certain words and phrases to mean one thing and one thing only so that information can be transmitted and analysis with common denominators can take place.  At the same time these phrases loosen the reality of what they represented, removing the implications of fighting such a war, and thereby making the button-pushing a little easier.  Perhaps the launch business becomes more automated this way, even in considering the theoretical end of the actions of nuclear war.  Like the soldiers who were endlessly trained to turn the keys and punch the buttons at this country’s x-number of launch facilities, trained countlessly and tirelessly, so that when the real call came in they could just do the job, follow the instructions as they had 2,000 times before, and launch the missiles that would kill tomorrow.

    And so in 15 minutes I found these impressive examples of polyprhases that meant both something and nothing:

    Paper 1

    “Period of fractionation”–describing the civil circumstance directly after nuclear exchange.  Found in Scenario for Postattack Social Reorganization, : Raymond D. Gastil; William Schneider Jr; HUDSON INST INC CROTON-ON-HUDSON N Y

    This paper also provides us with “historical disasters that were somewhat comparable to nuclear war” as well as “return to normalcy” as the sixth part of a six-part post-nuclear landscape.  And this is all just in the abstract. 

    “Abstract: This approach to postattack analysis was meant to explore the possible contribution that a documented scenario could make to postattack research on organizational problems. Using knowledge of historical disasters that were somewhat comparable to nuclear war, we divided the scenario into the following periods: Pre-attack, the disaster; period of fractionation; survival and reconstruction; innovation and control; and, return to normalcy. The scenario covers a period of more than two years (1970-1972), and the attack was OCD’s CIV-LOG ’65 in which 2000 megatons were used. [Emphasis mine.] Appendices explore more analytically certain issues raised by the scenario. (Author)”

    Paper 2

    “The break in traditional economic time series…”  Meaning that there were new timetables in how things got done and how we communicate, in business, following a nuclear war.  Found in: Information Needs for Postattack Recovery Management, 1968.  {Actually the entire abstract is worth a quote.]

     

    Abstract: “The study is concerned primarily with information needed for monitoring the effects of actions taken by governmental bodies at federal, state, and local levels in a postulated postattack period and for providing business management with the overall information it needs for making business decisions in the absence of undistorted indicators of economic developments. The break in traditional economic time series and the need for drastic reorientation of industrial efforts in ..”

     Paper 3

    “interdiction of normal business channels” Found in Institutional Factors in Total Vulnerability,  1968

    and 

    “None of the problems [in surviving nuclear attack] would pose insurmountable difficulties but all would require prompt attention and appropriate resolution within the first two months after a nuclear attack”

    Authors:  Francis W. Dresch; Hazel B. Ellis; STANFORD RESEARCH INST MENLO PARK CA

    “A systems approach was used to identify institutional problems likely to be neglected in analyses of the vulnerability of physical systems at risk from nuclear attack. This report discusses six specific problems (solvency, credit, business organization and management, interdiction of normal business channels, legislative imbalance, and disruption of election machinery) and their implications for the assessment of national vulnerability. None of the problems would pose insurmountable difficulties but all would require prompt attention and appropriate resolution within the first two months after a nuclear attack.

    Paper 4

    “nature of demands for labor in a postattack world” and of course “post-attack economy” found in Preliminary Estimates for Labor Demands in a Post Attack Economy, 1968. Authors:  Stephen Baer; INSTITUTE FOR DEFENSE ANALYSES ARLINGTON VA PROGRAM ANALYSIS DIV

    “Abstract: This is an informal exploration of ways to determine the nature of demands for labor in a postattack world. An attempt is made to determine the needs for labor and the demands of consumers after a nuclear attack based on preattack patterns, community sizes and income levels. (Author)”

    Paper 5

    “using retired boxcars for simulating urban area fires” [ignited by thousands of megatons of explosives] found in Feasbilities and Representativeness of Large-Scale Boxcar Burns, 1968

    Authors:  Frederick Salzberg; IIT RESEARCH INST CHICAGO ILL ENGINEERING MECHANICS DIV

    “Abstract: the study deals with the feasibility of using retired boxcars for simulating urban area fires. Considerations are given to the representativeness of boxcars fires, development of an experimental plan, and a cost analysis. An outline is given of experimental series designed to study various aspects of urban area fires by means of boxcar fires. Included are studies of fire spread, development of group fires, and behavior of mass fires. (Author) “

    Paper 6

    “production degradation” found in Industrial recovery Model Constraints, 1969.

    “Abstract: The vulnerability of a facility to nuclear blast damage is determined by identifying the industrial facility with a structural type and the type of processing equipment contained therein. Equations are extended to estimate production degradation. Damage repair data and analysis are reviewed and a straight-line function is suggested for relating repair effort and elapsed repair time to overpressure. The functional relationships of industrial recovery are analyzed with respect to target …”

    Paper 7

    “problems of debris removal to achieve specified objectives in urban areas” found in Debris Removal in Civil Defence Operations, 1969.  Authors:  George E. Wickham; STANFORD RESEARCH INST MENLO PARK CALIF

    “Abstract: As a part of the Five-City Study, this report examines the problems of debris removal to achieve specified objectives in urban areas. It details the necessary steps for determination, and provides a quantitative value of the total resources required to accomplish clearing operations. It illustrates the application of methodology developed in research report titled ‘Debris Removal Civil Defense Operations: Volume 1’ so as to provide realistic appraisals …”

    Paper 8

    “disorganization inevitably following a nuclear war” found in Capabilities of Fire Services to Limit Damage from Nuclear Attack. Authors:  S. B. Martin; R. W. Ramstad; URS RESEARCH CO BURLINGAME CALIF

    “Abstract: The report emphasizes the dangers to eventual reconstruction that are posed by the disorganization inevitably following a nuclear war. What can go wrong in this reorganization period is examined by the use of scenarios and analogy. It is then suggested that during the crisis period preceding a nuclear war a number of useful actions enhancing the chance of postattack recovery should be undertaken as part of an emergency mobilization for …”

    These are just eight examples–the problem here is that nearly every paper I looked at on this first page of papers from Storming Media could be used as examples of massive underspeak…the real issue being that there were another 100 pages of these things. So its not as though I even cherry-picked these things–they were all in line on the front page.  That’s the scary part–to see how deep the depth was of these things, an infinite depth of finite measurement. Something in nothing. 


  • “My Zombie ‘Phone to Deadville” and Tales of the Infinite Boneyard, by Tom Edison

    This post unexpectedly but now not unexplainably appeared on my blog this morning.  It was written last night by Thomas Edison, and sent from 15 minutes in the past.  He wanted to lay to rest the idea that there is no such thing as the afterlife. This might seem paradoxical that a ghostspirit was writing from the near-past about the impossibility of communicating with the dead, but he makes a strong case.

    In his email Edison writes/wrote:  “It’s kinda like Olbers Paradox in a way:  how can you have a dark night sky when there are so many stars? Well, that’s because the universe is infinite and their light not; that’s what it is like with the dead. As it turns out–surprisingly!–living people are finite but the dead are infinite, because we’re dealing with the past possibilities and former universes.  So the dead are everywhere but just don’t have enough juice to be heard.  Unless of course they have access to the internet, which is sort of like heaven, and which is where I now live, and which also offers the possibility of being dead in the future while being still dead in the past. Its good being multi-dimenional electricity.”

    Edison concluded with a picture: “You know what electricity looks like when you’re inside it?  Here it is1“

    https://historyofideasblog.com/a/6a00d83542d51e69e2011168689fbc970c-500wi

    Thomas Edison did–once upon a time, in a land far far away–spark a world-wide semi-frenzy when he told a reporter that he was making a device that would be capable of detecting and perhaps even communicate with the dead. 

    Edison the agnostic, Edison the non-believer, Edison the anti-spiritual, was hardly poetic on topics of the soul (once referring in 1910 to the brain as a “meat mechanism”1a) and would never have wasted his time on such a thing as a device to detect the dead–unless it was all in fun, which is what this was.  The old man was having a little wicked fun with a reporter, A.F. Forbes (later the founder of Forbes Magazine and father of the father of the  failed and forever failing presidential candidate), who dutifully reported it (“Edison Working to Communicate with the Next World”) in a 1920 issue of American Magazine. He said: “…I am inclined to believe that our personality hereafter will be able to affect matter. If this reasoning be correct, then, if we can evolve an instrument so delicate as to be affected, moved, or manipulated…by our personality as it survives in the next life, such an instrument, when made available, ought to record something.”2

    The story, as they say, had “legs”, and was re-reported many times, reaching even into the Scientific American: in 1921:  “I don’t claim anything, because I don’t know anything…. for that matter, no human being knows”  Edison said.  “But I do claim that it is possible to construct an apparatus which will be so delicate that if there are personalities in another existence who wish to get in touch with us… this apparatus will at least give them a better opportunity.”

    Indeed.

    Later in 1921, A.D. Rothman for the New York Times wrote a story that had Edison constructing a machine that was sensitive enough to detect a bit of the “one hundred trillion” “life units” that pooted away from the body on death, and which evidently were (a) detectable, (b) capturable and (c) meant anything beyond being a+b. 

    I suspect that Edison (who once remarked that he didn’t know what the word “spiritual” meant) was happy with this outcome, the world looking for him to turn the afterlife inside-out, to make it observable, feasible, concretized–to show that it existed.  And who could blame them?  Edison as an inventor and as a master of a group of 50 other inventors and advanced assistants had an enormous track record of  revolutionary successes–why not this?  Some of what he brought to bear on the world–electric lighting, the phonograph, and so on–must’ve seemed almost as deeply science-fictional as weighing the dead.  Perhaps his conceit in this whole episode might’ve been in an attempt to show how similar the belief was in his “invention” to that of any (other) religion.

    ________

    1) This illustration is actually from Praxis Artolleriae Pyrotechnicae, printed in Osnabruck by Tilman Buchholtz for Johann Georg Schwaender, is one of those beautiful books of horrible things; the “arrows” on this device of ear aren’t showing the direction of rotation; they are actually spear tips looking for some flesh to tear.

    1a) In an interview with Edward Marshall in the New York Times, 1910.

    2) Beyond knowing that this was all outside of Edison’s interests, we know it was a prank because he said so, in the New York Times, in 1926: “that man came to see me on one of the coldest days of the year…his lips were blue and his teeth were chattering…I really had nothing to tell him, but I hated to disappoint him so I thought up this story about communicating with spirits, but it was all a joke.” NYT, October 15, 1926, page 11. I’d reproduce the whole thing here but ProQuest seems to be yelling at its readers not to. 

    3) Here’s a bit from Modern Mechanix (1933, two years after Edison’s death):

     


    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • Extra Earths and Manhattan Under Attack–Addition, 1939

    Notice of addition

    I’ve found another excellent New York City under attack image to complement those in an earlier post here (New York City: Attacked by Tentacled Flying Saucers, Giant Flying Snakes, Glaciers, and Mining Missile Space Aliens, 1929-1941), this time by a 3-Earth-tall Gagantua. Actually this image fits into another, smaller, even more odd sub category, Extra Earths–images showing Earth-based scenes with (somehow) the Earth in the background. 

    Giants--marvel474And the detail of the Brooklyn Bridge and what was left of the Manhattan skyline:

    Giants--marvel475

    Just for the record, here are some examples of Extra Earths which I’ve written about elsehwere on this blog):

    Blog1sept_10_floating_earthclean

    Photo


     

    0--blog---Nov 29 into this world149


  • How YOU Can be One of the 97% of Americans Who Survive Nuclear Holocaust, 1961

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1378

    Books_004

    Well, I’d think that this issue of LIFE magazine would’ve sold in the hundreds of millions with the promise it makes here–right on the front cover–that 97 out ot 100 Americans could survive a nuclear slugfest–if only they were to follow the instructions of this article.

    We only get to the marrow of the issue after wading through a few articles and ads for Hires Root Beer, Maiden bras, silk skin girdles, Bayer aspirin, Schlitz beer, Old Taylor Whiskey, Ge “telephone color” night table clocks, scotchguard raincoats, Lanolin Plus Hair Spray Net, Marja bras, Red Rose cologne, nylon carpet, Maidenform girdles, NY Life, Sealy mattresses, Metrecal, Corn Flakes, Hammond organ, John Hancock Life Insurance, Friskies dog food, Cahmpion spark plugs, Budweiser, BF Goodrich tires, Tang, RCA, Anacin, Speedstick deodorant, Castro convertibles, B+W Whiskey, Kodak and  Vista TV.  Probably I missed a few. When you get to the big ad for Royal Crown Colas with the white-hatted BBQ cook getting a kiss with a big wiener on a stick, you’ve arrived at the article on saving the life of your family and your country.

    If only we could build enough shelters–and by “we” I mean “you”, and build them properly, and outfit them, and are able to get to them in the 14 minutes that you might have to get to your destination, and you stay down long enough and the attack light enough, then probably some people will survive.  How these folks got the 97% number is an issue of faith–I think that they must’ve steeped themselves in mystical prayers to secretly reformulate the percentage “23” into “97” without actually telling anyone.  I figure that this was the key to survival.

    I’ve written many times on this theology of survivability (see the series on atomic and nuclear weapons on this blog, here) but seldom does one see such an incredible, indefensible claim such as this, and splashed across the cover of America’s most popular picture magazine, accompanied by a letter of support from Camelot.  Somehow in the great looming nuclear confrontation that actually comes to pass, somehow “only”3% of the population doesn’t make it.  Of course if there was a natural catastrophe in which 3% of the country was killed–that would be about 4.5 million in 1961 population or about 9 million in 2011–it would be an absolutely phenomenal tragedy. (Ofcourse there were many European countries that lost more than 3% of their populations during WWI and WWII, but that’s another story).  But to escape nuclear Armageddon in this country with 3% loss is much better than other government figures published around the same time that predicted casualty rates exceeding 100 million. 

    But hearts and minds are won abroad and at home, so the homefires must have been stoked to prevent a colossal depression from befalling the country, which of course goes hand-in-hand with the policy of Mutually Assured Destruction, with all policies somehow making it possible for the rush to the abyss to be the one thing that was keeping us (in a Zeno-ish paradox) from falling into it. 

    But 97%?  You can read the article here from page 95 for the full story. 

     

     


  • Baseball and the Rifle Team at the NYSE, 1927

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1377

    NYSE bb107

    Is there nothing else that shouts out $15 trillion market cap than this NYSE basketball team?  Well, probably.  These photos appear in a New York Stock Exchange personnel department publication for 1927, and as the HR -arm of the Exchange,  devoted itself to all things necessary to the average employee of the 1300-person entity.  The NYSE seemed to be fairly well involved with the health and free-time status of its workers, reporting on programs for self-betterment, general reading, health care, health insurance, savings and spending, training, “mental guidance”, retirement plan (singular), and so on.  These photos come from the “Employee and His Play” section, and discusses the achievements of the many sports teams hosted by the Exchange. 

    NYSE bb106

    NYSE bb105

    NYSE bb108
    NYSE bb104


     


  • Outrageous Analogy Dept: How Hitler Can Help in the Post-Nuclear-Attack USA, 1967

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1371

    “Understanding, n.  A cerebral secretion that enables one having it to know a house from a horse by the roof on the house.  Its nature and laws have been exhaustively expounded by Locke, who rode a house, and Kant, who lived in a horse.”  Ambrose Bierce, The Devil’s Dictionary

    “The German experience in reordering an industrial economy for total war in the midst of conflict offers insights into planning for postattack conditions”–Stanford Research Institute, 1967

    If such is the case for understanding, then I think that those responsible for the pamphlet German Wartime Industrial Controls:  an Analogy to Recovery from Nuclear Attack intended to ride their house in the Kentucky Derby and upgrade the kitchen in their horse.  After all, ideas are just connections among words, though it seems that here it might be just between words, or suggestions between letters, although the words might all be privately defined. [The original document is available form our blog bookstore, here.]

    This pamphlet is another one of those monuments of living proof showing the impossibility of defining where the “bottom” might be in the well of bad ideas–even when you strangle this Nazi business into its own, narrowly-defined category, trying to extricate the logic of its titanically bad idea, the pamphlet instantly ignites when removed from its ether-y vacuum of under- and over-think and  exposed to oxygen. 

    It was the Stanford Research Institute (Menlo Park, California) that produced this thing, carved whole and with precision from a quivering block of fat and federal dollars.  If the title doesn’t stop time, the first page will.  There we are introduced to Albert Speer (1905-1981), Minister of Armaments and War Production and architectural joyboy for Adolph Hitler.  We are told about the basis for his exceptional achievement in reordering the German economy to all-out war production thus:

        “…a vast armament production would have to be obtained through scrupulous attention to increased production efficiencies and the most effective use of fixed supplies and essential materials and skilled labor.  Speer developed a unique variant of conventional economic planning for a controlled economy and applied it successfully…” (from page 1.)

    Speer, a high-ranking Nazi party member since 1931 and intimate of Hitler, was convicted of crimes against humanity and war crimes at the Nuremberg Trials in 1946, and sentenced to 20 years at Spandau prison, not the least of which was for his broad and acknowledged use of slave labor.  The “P” in the square standing on its edge at the top of this post is the symbol worn by a Polish slave laborer–there were some 12 million people abducted/arrested/stolen by the Nazis to work on various parts of German society. 

    Buna069

    Perhaps this was part of the “scrupulous” detail and the “effective use” of fixed supplies that the author of the Stanford paper was writing about?  Surely anyone studying Speer’s methods would have known this–that the author would chose to ignore this sets every moral compass everywhere into free spin. 

    But such is the realm of the coin in the ugly, a bubbling bulk of post-attack scenario scripting done at the taxpayers’ vast expense in waging the Cold War is littered with vocabulary meant to redirect the attention, essentially to change the meaning of words in discussing the outcomes of vast nuclear war.   For example, we find the phrases “period of fractionation“, “the break in traditional economic time series” and “production degradation” in certain documents  (which I discuss in an earlier post here)  used to describe the breakdown of the American social and  industrial base following a nuclear war.. These are just three of thousands of such examples, not the least of which is nuclear “exchange”, which is a conceit suggesting something less than the U.S. and the Soviet Union blasting away at one another with spectacularly deadly weapons. (Perhaps the thinking is that such a situation wouldn’t necessarily be a “war”, and so it is something less than that, like the Korean War really wasn’t one but a U.N. policing action.)

    But enough of this, were not even a full page into the report, which I remind you tells us we can find useful lessons in Hitler’s monstrosity, particularly about war production–that is producing materials post-attack so that we can either defend ourselves or attack again, all by taking a look at Germany, and particularly  “the improvisation by gifted industrialists driven to the limits of their power and imagination” (page 12 of the report).  It is difficult to want to read this report because everywhere I look there are Orwellian Ghosts–half-referenced facts wrapped in Newspeak, available at random.  For example, on page 31, in discussing oil and rubber production, I find:”The output of the new synthetic Buna-s rubber was increased to 22,000 tons in 1939 and to 69,000 tons ion 1942 by accelerated production of new plant.”  The “new plant” is the think tank version of “new plants” (the plural is left off of many things for unknown reasons but I guess mostly for a form that seems to have more economo-cache than the simple English expedient), which is a very simplistic way of telling of the enormous production battles in Germany to come up with their own, home-brewed (and not foreign-dependent) rubber (the super-necessity of all things military).1 The other part not mentioned here in what seems to be a disingenuous appraisal of Nazi rubber production is the increase in 1943/1944, particularly from the “new plant” at Monowitz, which was also known as the Buna Works, and better known yet at Auschwitz III, where slave laborers were put into work-or-die situations producing Buna-s as part of the overall Auschwitz complex of forty camps and subsidiaries. 

    Here’s another example, tying Hiter and (Fritz) Todt and Speer together–Todt was “one of Hitler’s most important administrators”, who would be replaced by Speer “who had been an assistant to Todt”–though not mentioning that Todt had used millions of slave laborers (Zwangsarbeiter) in doing his “administrating”.  Speer would do the same.  

    ANd so on and on this paper crawls until it reaches its end, which is published on detachable sheets on pages one through three, pullaways for the executive summary so that the text and subsequent documentation and analysis could be discarded.  It seems to have been a waste of detachable paper when the whole thing could be thrown away at once.  The author makes a case for studying the Nazi situation because it was the closest thing in modern times to use as an analogy to the possible scenario in America after nuclear war, and then launches into an analysis of Nazi “competitiveness”.  The author never comes close to making a compelling argument for the closeness of fit for its major assumption, though, and as far as I can tell the logic of it just doesn’t work,which makes the rest of what follows unnecessary.  I guess they could’ve kept their federal grant by identifying ideas that wouldn’t work as America post-attack analogies–which is also useful–and could’ve easily used what they had here for that purpose.   But at that point I’m not sure what is the more ridiculously-titled idea–I couldn’t imagine someone reading the report on why Nazi industrial controls weren’t a good analogy, because it seems tautological and unnecessary; and yet the opposite is what gets thought about and published, in all of its error and omission, swimming in its own turgid muck.  This is what people were thinking about in 1967 when, evidently, houses didn’t have roofs. 

    ______

    1.  Germans were forbidden to import chemicals and food from 1933-1937, forcing Germany industry to come up with their own versions of things like rubber, meaning that there were many new places in which Buna-s (BUtdiane & NAtrium) was produced.  That rubber production increased so much was a function also of not being able to import the stuff. 

     

     

     

     


  • What Free Things Cost–The Washington Times and the Eugenics Society

    Years ago when I lived in DC a new, upstart newspaper, The Washington Times (a conservative, Sun Yung Moon Unification Church organization-owned entity that is painful to italicize) spent years trying to establish a toehold in the area readership.  For years they spent a dollar per daily reader trying to get their message out–the cult leader himself, Rev. Moon, has stated that the paper has cost over a billion dollars to keep “competitive”. Since its founding in 1982 the paper has always lost money but has kept its focus on target–recently though there have been breaks in its rigid far-right exterior, changing some of its rhetoric to be more accommodating, like for example in 2009 deciding to use the word “gay” rather than “homosexual”.  The paper was owned by New World Communications–a branch of the Unification Church–from 1982 to 2010, when the paper was sold directly back to Moon for $1.  The paper is still in publication a,most 30 years later.  And even though the Unification Church says that the paper is independent from editorial control, former editors of the thing have said otherwise.  [New World Communications owns UPI by the way. Happy Happy World World]

    Eugenics soc316

    For several years running as a matter of fact the Washington Times threw their newspaper onto my lawn, a freebie, news gratis–they just kept coming, day after day, even after I called them requesting that they stop the free delivery.  They didn’t.  I simply didn’t want to be included as a statistic as a “reader”, because grass-reading was evidently a statistic they could deal with. Had I been a lawyer I think I would’ve sued them for littering, as that was about the extent of the value of their newspaper, to me.  I guess if you give something away long enough, people get used to it, and then, after many years, they are guilt ridden to buy, or–like a phantom song from the radio that you’ve heard so many times that you know it by heart even though you don’t like it–it becomes part of your routine.

    That’s what I thought of when I saw this circular slide out of one of the volumes in the warehouse of the Journal of the Eugenics Society.  It warned librarians that the free ride their library had been given by the society was about to end–maybe–and that if the institution wanted to receive any further issues, they would need to buy them.

    Unlike  the Washington Times–still in business today–the Eugenics society didn’t make it.  It died decades ago. Died a death long overdue, died in its seventh decade.  Pieces of it lived from ancient times, famously with Plato, developing in more modern times into a societal, philosophical, scrapingly biological branch of pseudoscience, aimed generally at improving the human population through a more-or-less longitudinally dreamed belief system.  It was squared away and rounded up with social stats of Karl Pearson and number crunching of Francis Galton (who misunderstood the writing of his cousin, the beautiful Charles Darwin). And in spite of coming into a sort of Renaissance in the early twentieth century, it was mostly put away by Nazi monsters, who broke whatever basis in reality that eugenics had, almost entirely dealing the belief system a mortal blow.  Some people still felt comfortable with it enough to use it to continue a practice of population control by sterilizing anti0social elements–including prostitutes and drug addicts, and people of low IQ, but mostly, almost entirely, poor people–up until the 1970’s. 

    It looks like a desperate thing to me, this flyer (available from our blog bookstore, here).  It may well have been real, it may have been the case that it wasn’t this piece of propaganda that I see  it as to help sell a fatal science…but I don’t think so.  It looks pathetic, paper collar and starched shirt and doctorates and cufflinks and privileges notwithstanding.  And it reminds me of the desperate attempts of propaganda machines like The Washington Times to get its message across–even when it is very clear that there are not nearly enough people to fund it, a message machine in desperate search of an audience.


  • A Short Note on the History of Indoor Stink: Buffalo Flaps vs. Perfume

    JF Ptak Science Books   Lucky Post 1313    

    For sweetest things turn sourest by their deeds, Lilies that fester smell far worse than weeds–Wm Shakespeare

    In the long history of indoor stink,  few things have succeeded (prior say to the year 1800) in eliminating odor like a piece or  two of Buffalo hide.  Actually its a piece of metal tubing that probably gets top billing for stink-eliminator, but that’s getting ahead of the story.

    And the story is an easy one:  people for thousands of years have been living indoors, and in climates where you need to keep warm in the winter, and to be able to see stuff in the dark, people have needed to burn things for their heat/light sources that basically emit rotten odors.  This is a gross generalization*, but there have been many nomadic cultures whose housing consisted on things like tents and yurts, simple structures with people living inside and burning a fire with nowhere for the smoke to exist. Tens of  millions of people–maybe hundreds of millions–have lived this way, in a small, contained space, living with their sooty smoky fire, and the rancid fat or whatever that was burning in their lamps, all of which was mixed with cooking and living smells, all heated up and kept in the small space.  Like an oven of sorts.  (Dante commented frequently on the smell of Hell in the Inferno, and it wasn’t a pretty thing, what with the heat and the decay.  I don’t think he had much to say about the ‘taste” of place, but definitely had other things to say about how they felt, and looked, and sounded. Probably people coul drelate quite closely to the smells portion.) 

    I’m not saying that this is a global assertion, but it certainly applied to a lot fo people. Some of this unpleasant odor was masked with perfume, but I would say that this was probably not terribly effective, especially when compared to the methods that were effective. 

    Many Indian tribes in the North American Plains had tepees that were vented, holes in the tepee skin that were covered with Buffalo hide (or some sort of leather) that would allow smoke to escape; also there would be lower vents to allow air to come in.  Fires in enclosed spaces do consume oxygen, just like people, and so at some point the fire and the people would compete for O2.

    Kivas in New Mexico also were vented , and many would also have an under-the-structure tunnel devised to allow air to come and feed the fire from underneath.  Great, workable ideas that were healthy, not to mention very effective in combating stink. 

    Perfumes and scents, herbs and the like just didn’t stand a chance against the overwhelming odors that were produced by internal fires and lamps, but it really wasn’t until the invention of the proper (and lined) chimney that relief was found.  Well, that and the Franklin Stove–it was Benjamin Franklin’s idea to have an iron stove with a roaring fire, the smoke being captured in pipe above the heating element and vented immediately outdoors.  That was really one of the earliest methods by which nominally-monied people could afford to heat their environment in a healthy way, removing smoke form the environment as well as other nasties that were the direct consequence of unvented and tight indoor living.(“fish and visitors smell after three days”)

    _____

    *really, this is a roomy approximation.  Romans (with the hypocaust), Chinese, and Koreans, among others, used  sophisticated systems in antiquity.  This is just a general conversation.