A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Perception

  • First Printed Views of America: Columbus in Print in 1493

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

     Christopher Columbus was born in 1451, and born sometime over a three-month period that no one seems to be able to button down.  He (known as Christophorus Columbus in Latin, and Cristoforo Colombo in Italian and Cristobal Colon in Spanish)  and in an audacious dash to shortcut European rivals in trade with the East became one of the first Europeans to explore the Americas.  In his first of four voyages to what would be called “the New World”, he landed in the Bahama archipelago, and in time explored the Greater and Lesser Antilles, Central America, and the Caribbean coast of Venezula, claiming all for the Spanish Kingdom. 

    The first images of his adventures appeared in Oceanica Classis, printed by Johann Bergmann de Olpe, in Basle, in 1493–the first, below, showing an imaginary view of the Island of Hispanola.  In the image of Insula Hyspania, below, we see Native peoples running from the approaching ship and long boat–they of course did not run far enough. (By the end of the 1620’s, something like 75% of the indigenous population in contact with Europeans (or in contact with people in contact with them) were dead, mostly from epidemics and diseases and lesser illness for which they had no immune systems.)

    Columbus933

    Four (of the other eight, two of which were repeated)  images from this fantastic work can be seen below:


  • Polling for Opinions on the Japanese, 1944

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1627

    I uncovered a few interesting documents this morning from The American Council, Institute of Pacific Relations (in 1944 at the address 744 Jackson Place, N.W., D.C.) relating to collecting opinions on Japan and the Japanese, right at the height of the war.   And this is what the American Council was doing–prep work to assess the extent of public opinion on the treatment of Japan post-war, which entailed reviewing existing polling data (from Gallup) was well as conducting their own original research. [These documents are available from our blog bookstore, here.]

    Japan Public Opinion treatment after891
    The “first” issue (so far as I can determine)  was perhaps the most aggressive:

    Is Japan incurably warlike?

    The question was asked of an undefined group over three periods of time  (February 1942 to June 1943) for both Japan and Germany, the statements the respondents having to choose from being: “always want war”, “too easily led” and “do not like war” at three different times, from February 1942 to June 1943.  From Feb ’42 to June ’43, people’s opinions that the Japanese “always want war” went up from 48% to 62%, while for the same time the same question regarding the Germans stayed about the same, 22%.  The Gallup Poll for June 1943 reported that for 75% of the respondents only 8% of the folks thought that “we can get along” with the Japanese, while 67% favored our chances with the Germans. 

    Get along with them or not, or feeling that they are war-like or not, had little to do with the opinions of people (reported by the National Opinion research Center, August 1942) who thought that reparations should be paid, and paid hard, by the Axis powers across the board, “as much as it is possible to get out of the Axis countries, even if it breaks them”.

    Japan Public Opinion treatment after892

    The following two papers came a little later, closer to the realization that victory was coming, that the war would be over, that victory would be taken–probably at the end of 1944 or the beginning of 1945, when position statements were more circumspect than the earlier public opinions.  “Expert Opinion on Post-War Treatment of Japan”  was more understanding when speaking to the post-war existence of Japan, stating in a number of different ways that “there should be no attempt to keep Japan permanently repressed” and “the Japanese people must work out their own political salvation”.  Also that there would be no “continuing burden of reparations payments…as done with Germany after the last war”. 

    Japan Public Opinion889
    The overall feeling of this and the following document (“The Treatment of Japan”) can be found in the section “Teaching Japan a Lesson”:  “United Nations effort should be directed toward demonstrating to the people of Japan the advantages of making peace rather than the penalties of losing a war”.  The issue regarding the Emperor and whether or not he should or could stay–an issue that would stay with high command right through the second week of August 1945. 

    Japan Public Opinion890

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • The Great Farm Security Administration (FSA) Photography Series, in Color: Japanese Internment Camps

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    The following images were made by Farm Security Administration/Office of War Information photographers during World War II and are part of the famous FSA photography series that I  have written about here.  The color photographs–which were made in the first decade or so of the use of this new medium–represented only about 1,600 of the collection of 160,000 images in the FSA archive, and are far less known than their black-and-white complements, many of which are new iconic symbols for this period.  The color images are beautiful works, and somehow seem to bring these historic images a little closer to the present.

    This series are some of the few color images made of daily life in the Japanese Relocation Camp at Tule Lake in 1942/3.  The internment (“relocation”) of American citizens of Japanese heritage in “reservations” is a result of Executive Order 9066, signed into power by Franklin Roosevelt on 19 February 1942.  I’ve written about this episode in several places on this blog, including here. 

    Japanese-American camp, war emergency evacuation,[Tule Lake Relocation Center, Newell, Calif.] 1942 or 1943.

    http://memory.loc.gov/service/pnp/fsac/1a35000/1a35000/1a35014v.jpg

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • Signs of Discrimination: Photographs from the Library of Congress FSA Collections

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    Negro drinking at "Colored" water cooler in streetcar terminal, Oklahoma City, Oklahoma

    All of the photographic material below comes from the U.S. Library of Congress website for its prints and photographs division, and is a very small sample of what is offered from its online holdings of Farm Security Administration/Office of War Information (FSA and OWI) photographs. It is not ancient history–most of the images are 75 years old or so, a part of our near-past which still shadows our near-future.

    “Photographers working for the Farm Security Administration Historical Section (later transferred to the Office of War Information) were encouraged to document continuity and change in many aspects of life in America during the years the unit was in operation. They were particularly encouraged to photograph billboards and signs as one indicator of such developments. Although no documentation has been found to indicate that photographers were explicitly encouraged to photograph racial discrimination signs, the collection includes a significant number of this type of image, which is rarely found in other Prints and Photographs Division collections.”

    Beale Street, Memphis, Tennessee

    On of the great innovations in a sea of great things accomplished during the Franklin Roosevelt administrations was the formation of the FSA, a division of the government established to help farmers through the devastating Dust Bowl and Great Depression.  A subset of the FSA was a photographic unit which was set up to document the progress made by the FSA (and provide, I am sure, for some much-needed good news, a hearts-and-minds campaign).  This division was headed by Roy Emerson Stryker, who wound up hiring a collection of dream-team photographers unlike any ever assembled for a single purpose.  Esther Bubley, Marjory Collins, Mary Post Wolcott, Arthur Rothstein, Walker Evans, Russell Lee, Jack Delano, Gordon Parks, Charlotte Brooks, John Vachon, Carl Mydans, Dorothea Lange and Ben Shahn were sent out all across the country and wound up with the greatest and most beautiful photographic history ever assembled.  There were about 77,000 images made, and I recall reading (somewhere) that the total budget for the Stryker group for the years 1936-19421 was about $100,000, meaning that each completed image cost just over a dollar apiece.

    Rex Theatre for colored people. Leland, Mississippi Delta

    1) Bethlehem-Fairield shipyards, Baltimore, Maryland.
    May 1943.
    Arthur Siegel, photographer.
    “A drinking fountain.” [Sign: “White.”]
    Location: D-90666
    Reproduction Number: LC-USW3-26442-E
    [view catalog record]

     

    A drinking fountain labeled with a sign 'White.'
    1
    2) Memphis, Tennessee. October 1939.
    Marion Post Wolcott, photographer.
    “Secondhand clothing stores and pawn shop on Beale Street.”
    [Sign: “Hotel Clark, The Best Service for Colored Only.”]
    Location: E-2185
    Reproduction Number: LC-USF33-30637-M3
    [view catalog record]
    Secondhand clothing stores and pawn shop on Beale Street labeled with a sign: 'Hotel Clark, The Best Service for Colored Only.'
    2

    3) Durham, North Carolina. May 1940.
    Jack Delano, photographer.
    “A street scene near the bus station.”
    Location: E-255
    Reproduction Number: LC-USF33-20522-M5
    [view catalog record]

    A street scene near the bus station.
    3
    4) Durham, North Carolina. May 1940.
    Jack Delano, photographer.
    “At the bus station.”
    Location: E-5153
    Reproduction Number: LC-USF33-20522-M2
    [view catalog record]

     

    At the bus station.
    4

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — — —

  • Two Gloriously Famous Bugs

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1605

    September 9, 1947, is a big day in the page of The Big Book of Famous Bugs. This one found by Admiral Grace Murray Hopper in relay #70 of panel F of Harvard’s MARK II computer.  It was a 5 cm moth, actually, that was gumming up the works.  Hopper–an integral part of several teams  working on programming the earliest computers–witnessed the event, recorded the finding of the insect, and coined the word “debugging”.  She was an important figure in the history of computation, though Dr. Hopper is remembered by the general audience more for the bug than anything else.

    Grace Hopper Bug

     [Image source: https://yalealumnimagazine.com/articles/2633/you-can-quote-them]

    The other famous bug, perhaps the most famous in the history of science, belonged to Robert Hooke.

    Hooke--flea

    I’ve written elsewhere in this blog about Robert Hooke, and how, if there had somehow and impossibly been no Newton, he might’ve taken Sir Isaac’s place in the popular mind.  He was a tireless, relentless observer and experimenter, who lost little effort in a stranded idea and pursued interesting and problematic questions relentlessly.  More than others too he chased his won glory—minor but long and insistent—the years of which wore thin on many people in the scientific community.  But there were many characteristics of the man that made him not quite so lovable and endearing—not that Newton was any of those things, as he was not, but if you are going to be a secondary luminary to a super nova you’ve got to have something else going for you that the other man doesn’t have—sharing, helpful, greatly generous—to get you into the long pre-dusty pages of history. Also it would’ve helped if Hooke chose his battles with a little more aplomb and ingenuity—the war which began in 1672 with Newton went very badly for Hooke and followed him to the grave (and far beyond). 

    What I’d like to talk about right now, though, of the many things to talk about concerning Robert Hooke, is the most iconographic image he ever produced, and perhaps one of the most famous scientific images of the 17th century—the flea. 

    The 28-year old Hooke published the results in a gorgeous and revolutionary book, Micrographia (a lovely e-text edition appears at Gutenberg, here) in 1665, which became an instant best seller and highly praised and valued. (Samuel Pepys, perhaps among the shiniest stars whose imprimatur was like a royal blessing, said the book (was) “the most ingenious book that I ever read in my life.”) There is no telling what the people of the mid-17th century thought of seeing such incredible discoveries in the little semi-invisible stuff that made up their normal, daily lives.  The only thing that somewhat equates to this would be if the first images of the Hubble were those of Earth-bound objects whose detail had previously been unknown.  Hooke’s observations and drawings of things like the common flea were just an astonishment—that such a creature of “low order” could have such intricate detail and design was a complete revelation.  The drawings of the fly’s eye, too, was an inescapable wonder, an incredible object to consider as having any detail pre-microscope, and then revealed to have unimaginable design and elegance.

    And so the famous second bug.

    …”it is my hope, as well as belief, that these my Labours will be no more comparable to the Productions of many other Natural Philosophers, who are now every where busie about greater things; then my little Objects are to be compar’d to the greater and more beautiful Works of Nature, A Flea, a Mite, a Gnat, to an Horse, an Elephant, or a Lyon.”—Robert Hooke at the end of his 28-page preface to Micrographia (1665)


  • Deceptive Perception: Giant Super Women of Pulpdom and High Art

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1617

    Sometimes things are just not what they seem to be.  Sometimes they are deceptive and uncommon and somewhat hidden–and sometimes deceptive even to themselves. Sometimes the deception is intentional, and sometimes it is just a mistake, but a deceptive one. In the following cases, the deceptive elements are relating to size–kike the example below, in the cover illustration for the campy (“Southern” with names like those?) troubles of mid-1950’s “girls awakening into womanhood”:

    photo
    If you take a closer look at the reclining figure just abpve the word “giant”, you can see that she is one, unintentionally.  She’s just badly drawn, or something, a victim of foreshortening–we can see that her leg from her knee to her foot is as long as an entire keg of her companions, making this person about eight feet tall.
    On the heels of the eight-foot-tall woman comes one who is far more famous, ultra-famous, really.
    Le Dejeuner was a scandal when it was exhibited in 1863—Manet painted what he wanted to, unbound by perspective, by color, by composition, and on and on. The folks in the painting were not connected to anything, really, and were unconnected to each other, no one paying any of the others any mind, even when the women were naked.  Nothing seems to be going on—the people are just simply there. 
    Blog--march 7--manet bathers
    This is in itself was a disconnect from previous practices, the vision in painting was about something, and was directed.  Light seems to be coming from a number of different places, and the shadows from the trees reflect this, simultaneously stretched towards and away from the light sources.  The bathing woman in the background, or what used to be background, had she been drawn using proper perspective, would’ve been about nine feet tall.  But what happens here is that there is no foreground or background in this painting, just middle.  It was this collection of abandonments, starting here in the Le Dejeuner in 1863, that ushered in the modern in art. 
    Then there’s the fifty-foot-tall woman who really isn’t that tall in relation to the people around here. 
    There are times when even things that are made to look extraordinary and plainly, outrageously identifiable as what they are, simply aren’t–and sometimes they’re not even close.  For example, this cover of Fantastic Novels (1921?) seems to tell a straightforward story, but as it turns out the giant is giant but one living within a world in an atom of a gold wedding ring.  (I told a fuller version of the story of thiis here.)  So this giant is a giant but only so in her own world. 
    Man throwing

    Rabelais’ Gargantua and Pantagruel, Hobbes’ Leviathan, the Buddha at Yungang (Shanxi) and Melville’s whale were all pushed to their competitive monsterous edges in the 1950’s, when you were more likely to think of The Bomb and creeping Communism before thinking back to any of these great representations.  And it is also my general impression, having been paging through Life magazine for the 1950’s, that there are some other major, lesser heralds of gigantism, especially if you paid attention only to the advertisements. There were 1950’s colossal characters who were pale imitators of their earlier counterparts–the Amazing Colossal Man and Colossal Woman being two minor mirrors of older ideas–but they hardly contained the colossal ideas that were resident in the earlier creations. (Perhaps part of that is due to having just witnessed the demise of two enoromities in Hitler  Stalin.) But this woman seems to be the largest of the lot–I make her to be about 100 feet tall.  There’s really nothing deceptive about her, except of course that this giant is only a head. 

    Monumental television theatre446


  • Looking at Things Straight Down: Streets and Sunspots, 1868

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1608

    “Vision:  a device that belongs to those who have it. Far-reaching and fore-shortened, it is something that works best when used closely, loosely, finely and not at all. A gift-and-a-half and a half-a-bother.”  
    The imagined Devil’s Dictionary of Not Ambrose Bierce

    Straight down861

    In the many years that I have been looking at antiquarian prints, I must say that in the hundreds of thousands of them that it is very rare to see an image that looks straight down from a height upon its subject.  And that is exactly what struck me about this print in the 22 August 1868 issue of Punch, or the London Charivari magazine.  Straight down ti is that we’re looking, straight onto a busy city street, presented here as though it were the face of the sun, the hansom cabs and people in the thoroughfare being sunspots.

    [I’ve written earlier here on this and related topics, including:  Rare Antique Visions of Looking Straight Down at Things; Looking Straight Up, Down, Across and Through; Points of View, Outside-Looking-In and Inside-Looking-Out; and Looking Straight DOwn at Things as Found-Dadaist Objects.]

    The sunspot were in the mind of Mr. Punch the very life of the sun, and so too for the bits of humanity filling the streets.

    At first I wasn’t sure that “sunspots” were chosen for this cartoon for any particular part of their history in 1868–that is, if 1868 wasn’t a particularly big year for sunspots.  In general they were certainly known by this point for more than a thousand years, though the greatest recent attention with optical instruments occurred with Thomas Harriot, Johannes & David Fabricus and Christoph Scheiner all around 1610-1612, and then most famously with  Galileo who recorded them in 1612 in his Istoria e Dimostrazioni Intorno Alle Macchie Solari e Loro Accidenti Rome (or History and Demonstrations Concerning Sunspots and their Properties, published 1613).  And closer to this time (among other things) Heinrich Scwabe had published (in 1843) a major advance on the cycle of sunspots.  But as it turns out, though, the word “sunspot” had just entered the language in 1868, according to the Oxford English Dictionary, coming via Sir Norman Lockyer’s Elementary Astronomy (1868), arriving as “sun-spot”.  High delightful!  Punch was really quite on its toes on this one, employing a brand new word for a well-established astronomical phenomena to a rare view of looking straight down at a bustling street, cycles and all.  (Another sort of cycle would soon come to be applied in the next few years in the pages of Nature to sunspots from the brilliant logician (and other things) William Stanley Jevons–this bit of thinking done in trying to correlate sunspots and economic depressions.  This one wouldn’t hold, though it was a very interesting idea.)


  • Man is But a Worm–Darwin and Redon, 1881-1883

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1589

    http://cdn2-b.examiner.com/sites/default/files/styles/image_full_width/hash/b2/77/b277d4d3e88c41151d8a3c709696c8c8.jpg

    In the last tow years of his life Charles Darwin enjoyed some critical and popular success  with the publication of his The formation of vegetable mold, through the action of worms,  which was published by the steadfast John Murray in London in October of 1881.  It sold at a better clip even than On the Origin of Species, which had sold very well 22 years earlier.  By the time the cartoon (above) appeared in print by the relatively mid-brow Punch magazine (by Linley Sambourne, 6 December 1881) Darwin’s book sold about 7,000 copies, which for the time would make it a pretty good seller.

    Darwin only had a few months left to live at the time of the Punch publication (12 February 1809 – 19 April 1882), and I’m not too sure about what the old man would’ve felt in seeing it.  Actually, the Old Man wasn’t all that old, but at 73 and with a belly full of worms or whatever and a lifelong list of complaints real and imagined, Darwin was older than jis years.  After everything had been said and doen, and the tons of complaints heaped upon him from all quarters, I suspect that the cartoon would mean nothing to him.

    {Just for the record, we follow the evolution of worm-to-man in a trip one and a quarter times around the clock, starting with a big old (flat?)worm at bottom left, which develops counter-clockwised into a chimp-worm, then into a monkey-thing, then into a sort of comic-relief Darwin-ape-man, winding its course into Charles Darwin himself.  Not flattering to the man or the idea.]

    It would on the other hand be a curious thing to imagine Darwin meeting for a chat with the expansive evocateur Odilon Redon, who created some of the earliest (non-confrontational editorial) art based on Darwin’s Origin.  Redon (April 20, 1840 – July 6, 1916) published eight lithographs based on Darwin’s work in  Les Origine (Paris,  Lemercier and Cie), and they were unlike anything that I’ve ever seen regarding evolution–as a matter of fact (perhaps), Redon’s artwork in general was unlike most anything else that existed.  (Redon acknowledged this, of course, saying  “My drawings inspire, and are not to be defined. They place us, as does music, in the ambiguous realm of the undetermined.”)

    http://www.19thcenturypost.com/The%20Misshapen%20Polyp%20Floated%20on%20the%20Shores,%20a%20Sort%20of%20Smiling%20and%20Hideous%20Cyclops,%20Plate%203%20from%20Les%20Origines,%201883,%20by%20Odilon%20Redon,%20Museum%20of%20Fine%20Arts,%20Boston.jpg

     “The Misshapen Polp Floated on the Shores, a Sort of Smiling and Hideous Cyclops”, plate 3, 1883.

    But I don’t see that much being said between the two men, across a small table having tea–though I don’t have any hesitation saying that Redon would’ve had a lot of questions for Darwin.  My feeling is that Darwin wouldn’t have that many coming back. 

     


     


  • The Heaven of Disappeared Details

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1528   Part of this blog’s Blank, Empty & Missing Things series.

    What is the opposite of “the Devil is in the details”, without getting too terribly religious? Expressing detail in the history of art has been a progressive process, and perhaps in some sense that is what art was all about–adding detail, becoming more representational, more life-like, more expressive of the world and nature.   Perhaps that is what one essential element of art was all about for hundreds, or thousands, of years–a progression that marched its way through time with greater effectiveness and representation, for the most part, until relatively recently, when–in the early part of the 20th century–details began to disappear, until in some cases there were no details at all.  Or at least the details that people had been comfortable with for so long, like folds in dresses, or lustre in eyes, or thinness in clouds, or even the correct perspective in the re-invention of three-dimensional representation. 

    http://www.moma.org/collection_images/resized/042/w155h170crop/CRI_211042.jpg

    Detail changed with the  Romantics, and then definitely with the Impressionists, and then on into the the Cubists and the Abstract,  until the detail of what we would recognize as elemental objects would disappear altogether.  Corot, Cezanne, Gauguin, Whistler,  Seurat, Van Gogh, Picasso, Braque, Duchamp.  And then everything goes away with Kandinsky.  1911.  Details of references to the physical world slipping away into general sense impressions.

    It would probably make more sense to look at the Kandinsky at this point–I’d rather look at the Pierre Bonnard (1867-1947) and his La petite blanchisseuse (Roger-Marx 42, also known as the Small Washerwoman).  The wide expanse of her black working gown is a primary link to solid blankness, without detail of nearly any sort, missing parts of reality, allowed to go to Disappeared Detail Heaven.

    Photo

    The occupants of the Heaven was begun centuries ago, though the details banned there on purpose really only begins in earnest with the missing details of the solids in (Paolo)1 Uccello.  This great master (dissed terribly by Bernard Berenson I don’t know why) was one of the very few exceptions of artists who purposefully banned details from his work, just as the reality of the world crept deeper into the works of the late Siennese masters pointing out the details of their rediscovery of perspective. 

    There would be a long period in between Uccello and the other detail disappearers. 

    _____________

    1.  The phrase “the solids in Uccello” comes of course from the Great American Novel, William Gaddis’ The Recognitions, discovered and shared to my by the lovely Patti Digh. In some of his enomrous cnvases it is quite easy to find wide expaneses of nthing where detail should be…


  • Shooting Dodos, Square Holes/Round Bits, the non-Future of Movies, and the Race Where Everyone Wins

    JF Science Books   Post 1519

    In a world where everyone wins and no one loses, why can’t we cut a square hole with a round bit.  Or vice versa? Well, we can of course, its all just a matter of perspective.  The image (below) that started this thought thread down the rabbit hole is of a member of Great Britain’s ruling class, Sir William Houghton, appeared in Punch magazine in 1890 as an illustration in a debate over hunting rights for hares and other small critters, in what seems to have been an attempt to further control the access of the wide working class to certain freedoms.  To be honest I  haven’t looked at this debate, and I’m not sure why the liberal Sir William is shooting Dodos as rabbits, but the image–independent of what it was intended to represent–seems to be the inside-out, or the reverse-inside-out of what had been the situation with the bird. It would look “wrong” even if you didn’t know the history of the flightless and basically defenseless creature being hunted to extinction, standing in the place of the rabbit. It has an oddness to it, like a very high-pitched tone that floats above a piece of music, a slightly pungent odor coming from a nicely-executed painting. Perhaps it is the  the sense of expectation being thrown off just a bit with something like the unexpected-expected. 

    And then of course there’s the rabbit hole connection.  And Alice.  And the Dodo.


    From Report of Debate on Hares Preservation Bill, June 26.—”They (the other Members of Parliament) could not go out and kill 300 Dodos,”—but evidently he (Sir W.V. HARCOURT) could, and here he is—caught in the act…  [He reminds me of a peeing stallion–one of the most majestic poses a horse can strike]

    Lewis Carroll’s Alice gets right down to business in her adventures in Wonderland, right from chapter one (“Down the Rabbit Hole”), only a few hundred words into the story1–down she goes.  In one very memorable scene (in a book composed of memorable scenes) Alice meets a Dodo bird (which scholars say is a play on the stuttering Carroll’s real name, Dodgson, or Do-do-ogson), and <things happen> after which the Dodo suggests a “Caucus Race”, being a play on the legislative process in which the Dodo-shooting Sir William participated above. 

    File:De Alice's Abenteuer im Wunderland Carroll pic 10.jpgThe deal with the Caucus Race was that there was no set course, necessarily, for any one racer–everyone would run their own course as they chose; so in a self-defined course with no competitors and no rules, racing a race that the race liked, it would be hard to lose. Carroll writes:

    “First it marked out a race-course, in a sort of circle, (`the exact shape doesn’t matter,’ it said,) and then all the party were placed along the course, here and there. There was no `One, two, three, and away,’ but they began running when they liked, and left off when they liked, so that it was not easy to know when the race was over. However, when they had been running half an hour or so, and were quite dry again, the Dodo suddenly called out `The race is over!’ and they all crowded round it, panting, and asking, `But who has won?’

    “This question the Dodo could not answer without a great deal of thought, and it sat for a long time with one finger pressed upon its forehead (the position in which you usually see Shakespeare, in the pictures of him), while the rest waited in silence. At last the Dodo said, `EVERYBODY has won, and all must have prizes.”

    The rabbit hole was made by the cylindrically-gifted rabbit, though in Carroll’s world the rabbit could’ve been a square, a cube or cube2-something.  Or of course the rabbit could’ve made a square hole, or square-squared hole, which probably would’ve been more to Carroll’s taste, approaching a very early thought on square2.  But people in the three-dimensional world had been working on making square holes with round bits, though coming  a bit after Carroll’s time, as in this example:

    The device at the bottom of the drill was made to follow and then restrict its cutting motion to that of a square, the device (considerably less wide than the diameter of the bit) cutting and scraping the round hole into a square.  Which in its own way reminds me of a motion picture depicted on a polygon, in a movie theatre for example, which began in a somewhat different way, filmed on a circular surface, or at least in one aspect of it. Auguste and Louis Lumiere began the new mass-medium, illustrated here from their Nouvel Appareil Photographique Panoramique Reversible le Photorama (which was printed in Lyon in 1895/6)

    Lumiere544

    The Lumieres claim for “first” as cinematographers is better understood in terms of the motion pictures being a new mass medium.  Whereas other inventors and experimenters were earlier–like chronophotography devices constructed by  Eadweard Muybridge, Étienne-Jules Marey and Ottomar Anschütz, which all produced forms of moving pictures in the decade prior to the Lumieres, but were decidedly not for public consumption.  The work of these men, as with that of Thomas Edison’s Kinetoscope (1891), was intended for scientific and academic consumption; or with the case for Edison, at least, for the amusement of the wealthy classes, as well as for educating the children of the rich. There were certainly others who worked in this area in the 1890’s, but none really fashioned an interest to their invention for the use of one-and-all as did the Lumieres.

    Which gets us back to our square rabbit hole.  Soon after the Lumiere’s introduced their fabulous new invention, they decided that there was no future whatsoever in the motion picture as a new medium, and abandoned it.  They undoubtedly felt a little bit like the square peg in the round hole of the needs of art, and moved on. 

    ___________

    Notes:

    1. “There was nothing so very remarkable in that; nor did Alice think it so very much out of the way to hear the Rabbit say to itself, `Oh dear! Oh dear! I shall be late!’ (when she thought it over afterwards, it occurred to her that she ought to have wondered at this, but at the time it all seemed quite natural); but when the Rabbit actually took a watch out of its waistcoat- pocket, and looked at it, and then hurried on, Alice started to her feet, for it flashed across her mind that she had never before seen a rabbit with either a waistcoat-pocket, or a watch to take out of it, and burning with curiosity, she ran across the field after it, and fortunately was just in time to see it pop down a large rabbit-hole under the hedge.”–Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, Lewis Carroll.

    It is highly probable that no artist who ever depicted a Dodo actually saw one.