A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Art History

  • Buckets of Missing Smiles–an Incredibly Brief Anthropology of an Expression in the Face of the Sun

    JF Ptak Science Books Post 1666

    The depiction of the anthropomorphic Sun featured with a broad toothy smile seems a commonplace fixture in modern times–at least in the very popular media–but it seems to me that the Sun was an impressively dour character in the most misty and moldy past. Its a much harder issue for me to locate a happy Sun than a phlegmatic one, as we can in the coming examples.  Here, for instance, the Sun is actually disappointed, and dark:

    av1615055pict

    [Georgette de Montenay/Anna Roemer Visscher, Cent emblemes chrestiens (c. 1615)] 

    The Sun (representative in this case of the Christian god) disavows the heavily robbed false philosopher, finding nothing but fault in the erroneous thinking and pronouncements, so much so in fact that it distances itself from the phonylogian by turning itself black and devoid of light, absenting the light that was supposed to be shone via the heretic’s teaching. 

    Feigning to be a philosopher with your long cloak
    You bring forward all false theories about the pure Sun.
    First learn to recognize what is the true light.
    The balmy day does not shine in obscure night

    Conversely, the sun would also shine to dispel the false teaching of other philosophers, as so, though this time without any face at all:

    hu1689024pict[Source: Pieter Huygen, Beginselen van Gods Koninkrijk (1689)]

    But mostly it seems the Sun appears to those who came before with a mostly blank expression:

    Blogsunfacescolor Where was the smilign Sun hundreds of years ago?  Anthropomorphic images of the Sun have appeared in books in the West for several hundred years, and in almost every case where the Sun has a face, it is usually expressionless, its mouth drawn into a mid-Western farmer/Abe Lincoln horizontal, a tightly drawn nothing.  Two thin lips, firmly repulsing all emotion.  The face of the Sun was insurmountable, a tabula rasa, showing perhaps that there was nothing there at all inhabiting this iconographic image of The Creator to give the poor observer a glimpse into the depths of the future.

    Blogsunfacesdetailtwo

    This observation  seems to stand for Sun Gods and Goddesses as well, even the ones who are being tugged or pulled or charioted a cross the vaults of the heavens—the Nordic Sól, Greek  Helios , Roman Sol Invictus, Vedic Surya and of course Elijah ascending to Heaven in a Chariot of Fire, all seem pretty intractable.  But in general images that we see of Sun deities like Apollo, Greece and Rome; Freyr, Norse; Garuda, Hindu; Huitzilopochtli (Uitzilopochtli), Aztec; Inti, Inca; Liza,West African; Lugh, Celtic and Re (Ra) and Isis, and on and on, show a small, set pair of lips, if they have a mouth at all, and this going back beyond the Sumerians (Shamash). 

    Blogsunfaces2048

    When the Sun really loses its human personae in the 17th century (the scientific sun and stars beginning much earlier, as in for example Allessandro Piccolomini’s Della Sfera del Mondo, 1552, with simple star maps unadorned by icons and written in the vernacular), it is replaced with starry images which seem to somehow have more emotional authority than the sun images with faces.  Perhaps the sun was meant to have this Delphic, blank-mirroring quality, given its importance as a giver (and taker) of things,

    Blogsunfacedetailone
     
    and that it was not within human capacity to understand it as an emotive entity, especially during bad times.  But in those times of Good and Bad it wasn’t necessary to see a frown or a smile on an image of the Sun, I guess because of the complaints of redundancy.

    Blogsunfaces047

     No matter, though, as the modern astronomical text took care of the Sun and its missing buckets of smiles in due course—until more modern times, when the Sun is made to have a matching disposition, a result of kinder modern artists. 

    Blogsunfacedetailthree  

    f16914406

    This Sun seems to rule with an ennui  Daniel de la Feuille, Devises et emblemes (1691); and then again, in the following superbly engraved work by Jacob Cats, Sinne- en minnebeelden (1627):

    beeld037

    The Sun here seems to have a knowledge-worn expression, a sense of having-seen-it-all, in this beautiful work by Georgette de Montenay/Anna Roemer Visscher, in Cent emblemes chrestiens (c. 1615)

    av1615036pict

    And again from the Montenay we see a smirking Sun (definitely not a smiling one) judging the efforts of humans once again, and finding them coming up far to short:

    av1615093pict

    I guess you could make a case for an “amused” Sun in the Montenay, though in a third-person sort of Royal way of being removedly amused.  Here–in a rare and very important work in the history of alchemy–we see a rising Sun in an amused state, welcoming the book’s author, on his alchemical pilgrimage. 

    Sun--splender solis029
    In another illustration from this book (by Salomon Trismosin, Auretum Velius oder Guldin Schatz und Kunsthkammer, printed by Georg Straub at Lake Constance in 1598/9, and also known as “Splendor Solis”) we find the following expected facial posture:

    [trismosin, salomon (?pseud., fl. 1473?). <i>aureum vellus, oder guldin schatz und kunstkammer.</i> rorschach: 'gedruckt in des f. gottshausz s. gallen reichshoff' leonhard straub, 1598-99.]

    And so on and on this continues, this presentation of the Sun as both removed and judging, until–in some cases–the business of representing the Sun anthropomorphically disappears altogether, even in allegorical representation, like so: 

    The Man in the Moon will just have to wait his turn, though I can’t resist the following couple of images, the first of which shows the Moon in a phase of nothingness and a nil expression:

    f16914302

    [Source:  Daniel de la Feuille, Devises et emblemes (1691)]

    And then this classic image from an iconic and early science fiction film:

    http://data.whicdn.com/images/17391911/moon,vintage,jules,verne,le,voyage,dans,la,lune-d0ec6d7f016fe54cb3a634c84919da1d_h_thumb.jpg

    And from the 1905 motion picture version of Jules Vernes From the Earth to the Moon called A Trip to the Moon–upon the approach, the Moon’s surface was blank, but quickly developed a face, which was sort of smiling–until struck in the eye by the Verne capsule. 

    Offhand, though, my memory doesn’t offer too many smiling-Moon expressions. 


  • Extra-Earths Department #4: Brueghel Dips into the Late Renaissance Allegorical Sky

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 1664

    See the other Extra-Earth posts:  Mondo Bizarro, Science Afflictions and the Dubious Mind—Bad Science, Part 1. NYC in Space (?!) here and Extra-Earth Humano-Alien Souls From Outer Space Repopulate Earth-Hell!!(??) here.

    0 blog feb 17 brug597

    Peter Brueghel (the elder, born ca. 1525 and dying in 1569), was the Dutch semi-discoverer and king of “normality” of Renaissance art–and by “normality” I mean that he depicted non-royal things that were generally off the palette for almost everyone else, finding subjects in peasants and small life (hunting, meals, working at agriculture, festivals, dances, and so on).  Brueghel was also perhaps the first painter to depict a landscape for  the sake of its own beauty, without being a backdrop for a religious study or building or historical scene. He was extraordinarily prolific in his skimpy 45 years, fully populating his scenes with suites of busy and evolving life.

    Browsing through some of his work, I came across the print called “Temerpance”, which in general I think was supposed to warn us against excessive pleasure, but which really just confused me a little.

      (TEMPERANTIA; and then, VIDENDVM, VT NEC VOLVPTATI DEDITI PRODIGI ET SVXVRIOSI//APPAREAMVS, NEC AVARA TENACITATI SORDIDI AVT OBSCVRI EXISTAMVS. “We must look to it that, in the devotion to sensual pleasures, we do not become wasteful and luxuriant, but also that we do not, because of miserly greed, live in filth and ignorance”.)  

    To me, it looks like people here are pretty industrious, mostly engaged in scientific or musical pursuits:  lots of books, musical instruments, people writing and reading.  But I guess that these were sensual pleasures, pleasures of the mind and heart, and not a pleasure devolved from the godhead.  Perhaps the complete opposite is true:  the print showing the triumph of the pursuit of the mind over sensual graft, lifting mankind above the filth and ignorance of the body.  Sheesh. 

    0 blog feb 17 brug man earthBut the real grit of my interest is the action lurking in the background, the man, the astronomer, making measurements in the sky, triangulating the Moon and the Sun (perhaps).  What on earth is he standing on?  He does seem to be standing on earth in the background of the earth on which thee people in the foreground are standing–which means, with a stretch, we have the fourth entry in this blog’s short “Extra Earths” category.

    0 blog feb 17 brug man math

    The more I think about it, and the more closely I look at the print, this confusion must be my own–this must be Brueghel’s way of showing the possible worlds that exist outside the sensual and self indulgent. He shows children (and adults) learning their ABC’s at the feet of teh schoolmaster at bottom right, a theatre scene at upper left, a large musical ensemble (complete with choir).  An industrious man measures his fields, while builders to his right measure their progress and trueness on a column; at bottom right we see an “accountant” of the times working his tables and figures, while another to his right works on a math problem, clutching his pot of ink.  The figure in the middle (with “temperance” written in the hem of his garment), reminds us of our mortality, with a sword in one hand and a clock on his head.  All in all, it is a delightful scene of industry and invention–and it has an extra earth. 

    Of course the extra-earth is allegorical, but, still, it is an unusal thing to see.

     


  • The History of Goodbye series: The Open Door in Eden

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1656   (Part of the History of Goodbye series)

    The idea of there being a door to Eden is an interesting one to me–not just for the view of Eden from the outside looking in, but really for the view of the Un-Eden seen through the open door, looking out. Its a curious thing to imagine what the first view of the rest of creation would have looked like–maybe curiouser to imagine why there was a door or gate there to begin with.  A door in Eden could’ve meant only one thing–the exit.  There wasn’t anyone there to enter Eden, and certainly Adam and Eve weren’t going to go out and come back, so I guess the door was the Ultimate Fail exit portal. Just waiting. (Also there doesn’t seem to be any mention of a door in Genesis, so this would just be further artistic spin on another version of the Fall of Man, a story which spins out from a place far older than the Old Testament.)

    [Image source:  Cornell University collections.]

    The door/gate doesn’t seem to appear very often (to my memory and experience, anyway) but this image–a rather famous one from the great Nuremberg Chronicle (printed in 1493 by Anton Koberger) offers us a little clue, as well as a mystery.  We see the temptation of Adam and Eve on the right, and their expulsion because of their inability to reconcile the threat of pleasure on the left.

    The open door doesn’t really reveal too much, from what I can see.  Those blobs might be smoke, or bushes, or something symbolizing The Dark and Disappointment. There are some bits of the Un-Eden looming above that could be above the walls–like the mountain that look like a person sitting back with a book with a head tilted towards the sky–making the life outside seem as though it might not be so pleasant.

    Adam and eve expulsion984
    And then there’s the mystery of the statue by the door–the statue of a figure holding a book or tablet and clothed in robes, standing on a pedestal by the door, in profile.  As Adam and Eve were the only people, its hard to imagine who that statue might represent, because all of those other people come later. 

    Perhaps it was just a little creative largess from a woodblock cutter practicing or showing of their perspective skills into a piece of the block’s image that is largely hidden.  Perhaps it was the same cutter who gave such great detail and belief to the flowing robes of the angel threatening Adam and Eve with a sword–there is certainly more skill involved there than anywhere else in the print, so much so that it makes me think that there was a truly accomplished hand brought in for that piece of flourish on the anonymously-produced image.

    In any event, a door in the walls of Eden seems to me a curious and taunting device–an exit door without an entrance.

    Here are some open-door/gate/portal examples, below, though none really show anything through the portal:


  • Finding Surrealism in Antiquity–Unintentional Bizarreness in Plato

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    I was grazing through a new find, Veterum Illustrium Philosophorum, Poetarum, Rhetorum et Oratorum Imagines …by Josseph Petri Bellorii, a lovely work illustrating great thinkers of antiquity, and printed in Rome in 1739.  And among the busts and statues of Pythagoras and Euclide and Socrates and so on, the holy thinks and philosophers and orators and poets, I found this unusual non-statue of Plato. “Marmoreus Platonis Herma Truncato Capite” reads the legend of the not-completed statue, and it describes the work on many levels.  Of course, the eye is drawn instantly to the center–and, well, there you have it.  The surviving bit, half-survived.

    Lato968

    Decapitated, indeed.  There’s a lot that could be done with “Herma”, but I think the best is to take it for the root of hermeneutics–the study of the theory of interpretation–which comes from the god Hermes1, the messenger to the mortals and inventor of fire.  Certainly the statue as it stands is open to discussion.

    As it turns out fully 10% of the images in this book were like this one, which means I guess that finding fitfully/partially-completed statues like this of Plato was much more common than I realized. Or imagined. 

    I wonder what Plato would’ve done with this one.

    Notes:

    1.  Hermes also had a son, Hermaphroditius, with Aphrodite, a person created with a nymph, Salmacis, creating a person endowed with the traits of both sexes. 


  • When Data was Dada: Max Ernst, Dada, Graphs, and the Display of Non-Existent Information

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post  (Part of the series on the History of Blank, Empty and Missing Things.)

    This quasi/faux statistical/graphical modern art image by Max Ernst is found in the journal Mecano (issue no. 3 “Rouge”), which was the principal Dada publication vehicle, and issued by the artist Theo van Doesburg (in the Netherlands).  It arrived in 1922, just 10 years after the publication of Marinetti’s “Manifesto tecnico dellBlogernst030a letteratura futurista” and a year before Marcel Duchamp retired from painting, and just another two years before Andre Breton nailed down the meaning of Surrealisme (and again like a particle collision changed the direction of some of modern art). 

    The Dada Movement is generally thought to have started by WWI escapes in the neutral haven of Zurich (where the war was escapable for the duration), at the Cafe Voltaire, in 1916, the word “dada” being found as is generally believed by Tristan Tzara.)   I am trying hard to form some sort of memory for other Dadist, Futurist, Symbolist or other modern movements from the ‘teens and ‘twenties to use a graph such as this in the artwork but I cannot think of any.

    (By the way, also appearing in this issue of Mecano were Man Ray, R. Hausmann, Hans Arp, Kurt Schwitters, and others.) 


  • Geometrical Design in 1930’s Soviet Book Dustjacket Design

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    Russian dj art

    [Kuznetsov, E. Tsirk. [Circus.] Moscow: Academia, 1931; Cover design by N. Akimov.; 8 v., [655] leaves of plates : col. ill. ; 32 x 57 cm.]

    I found this dustjacket art of Soviet-era books (all from the 1930’s save one)  in the New York Public Library collections (here) and was struck by the geometrical objects in many of the designs. They have a sense of warmth to me, somehow, like softer work coming from the tail end of the Constructivist period, having elements of Dada but really just having some of the hard edge of Constructivism without the scorching/awakening images that might have been embedded in the geometrical design. 

    Russian dj triangle

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • Classifying Human Failures, 1487

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    Penitence hell c

    This image was one of the promises to the readers of the Eruditorum Poenitentiale (printed in Paris by Antoine Cailhaut in 1487), a book of penitence, a manual for seeking forgiveness and avoiding sin, showing what end awaited those who would disappoint the Creator.  The work was a devotional of frailty, a register of sin, an insistent call to the things that could and will go wrong throughout the course of a human life, and what the costs of those shortcomings would be.  [Images from Bibliotechque St.Genevieve, here.]
    Penitence926

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • History of Lines: Clouds

     JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1629  (On Clouds and Not-Clouds, Part I)

    “…and they drew all manner if things–everything that begins with an M—‘

        ‘Why with an M?’ said Alice

       ‘Why not?’, said the March Hare.” –Lewis Carroll,  from “A Mad Tea Party”, in Alice’s Adventures in   Wonderland.

    Why not, indeed?  I’ve long had an interest in clouds, and since this blog is ostensibly on the surfacing or definition of Cloud Bones, I though to spend a little time on the origins of the depictions of printed clouds in art. Not being an expert by any means on the history of art, it just seems to me that after long exposure clouds are not well-represented in woodcuts, wood engravings and other early engravings, or at least not so well depicted as their landsmen in paintings.  There seems to be no shortage of effort to reveal gorgeous clouds  through the early Renaissance–but the doesn’t seem to apply very often to their representation in prints.

    And that of course is when the detail of the sky is depicted at all. It seems that more often than not, in woodcuts printed from say 1460 through 1550, that the sky is left blank, like this image from Ovid (Accipe Studiose Lector P. Ouidij Metamorphosin...printed in Venice in 1509:

    Clouds no couds livy913

    “You could not see a cloud, because
    No cloud was in the sky:
    No birds were flying overhead —
    There were no birds to fly”.–Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass. 

    I could go on with many examples of the blank sky–the white, blank, settled nothingness–but exhibiting variations of nothing at this point isn’t necessary.  But illustrating clouds is.

    And for the most part, clouds don’t look very much like themselves in prints, not really, not for more than a hundred years.  For example, Martin Schoengauer‘s spectacular  The Temptation of St. Anthony, which was printed in 1470/5, has a beautiful, fluid circularity to it, full of an earthy roundness even as the saint is pursued by demons.  But the sky in the background is populated with nothing but dashes to suggest clouds. 

    http://thewholegardenwillbow.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/schongauer-martin-anthony103.jpg

    Perhaps clouds would have taken away from the moment; but if that were the case, why bother with the dashes?

    There are considerable exceptions to this practice, with Durer and Altdorfer coming quickly to mind–but in my experience, the oddly-formed cloud seems to be the majority rule in the woodcut.  

    At this time there were of course many depictions of skies with no clouds in paintings, bare suggestions of themselves, even in some of the most famous works–Botticelli’s Birth of Venus and Michelangelo’s Fall of Man in the Sistine Chapel are fair examples.  But once you move away from the golden Sienese skies of the14th century1, clouds are given full and beautiful shapes from early periods. (Giotto’s Christ’s Entering Jerusalem, 1305/6; Simone Martin The Road to Calvary, 1340; Duccio’s Christ Entering Jerusalem, 1308-1311; Fra Angelico’s The Dposition, 1436; Masaccio’s The Tribute Money, 1424; Lippi’s Annunciation, a perfect cloud treatise, 1442, and on and on. Other examples are found in continued reading below.)

    Clouds in prints are a different matter–I’m not sure if it was just too technically difficult to create clouds in wood, or if there was some sort of languishing Byzantine sensibility inherent in woodblocks that was not so in oil. I’m really not so sure about this, and as much as anything else I’m thinking out loud about this lack of cloud definition.  I don’t have an answer for it.  But I do want to share the beginning of a timeline for undefined clouds as they appeared (or not) over the course of about one hundred years,  from 1485 to about the end of the 16th century.   As I mentioned clouds appeared beautifully in paintings from earlier periods, and there doesn’t really seem to be a substandard-cloud complement in the painting world as there was in the print world.  Of course, in western philosophy and science, clouds were pretty much left alone from inquiry, even by a series of the great natural history classifiers–they wouldn’t really be given a fully taxonomic appreciation until 1803 by Luke Howard (which I wrote about in this blog earlier, here).

    A Timeline of Clouds in Prints, 1485-1596

    Franciscus de Retza, De Generatione Christi, sive Defensorium Castiatis Beatae Virginis Mariae, a beautiful work in Gothic type–a picture book, really, with two illustrations of magnets.  Printed in 1485, this image depicts Isidorus in a magnetic coffin which is floating in the air:

    Clouds 1485908

    “The Adoration of the Magi”, from Legenda Sanctorum Trium Regum, printed in Modena in 1490:

    Clouds 1490 adoration magi912
    The Triumph of Love, 1492/3:

    Clouds 1492 triumph love911


  • The Call of the Book: Antoine Verard and Illustration, ca. 1500

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    Vereard885
    M. Verard was a very active bookseller, printer and publisher, operating in Paris between about 1485 and 1512.  He produced a catalog of his printed works that was very extensive, containing more than 100 works.  One of them, a Bible published in 1502, contained this spectacular woodcut, “The Root of all Evil”, showing Adam and Eve at the crucial moment, a very considerable man-serpent completely engulfing the fruit tree, winning the confidence and trust of Eve.  And above it all grows the tree of humanity its roots firmly in place along the sphere of the fall of man.  

    I also quite like the portrait of Verard, shown offering one of his books to King Charles VII, hoping for his approval:

    Verard book


  • The History of Blank, Empty & Missing Things–When Everything was Missing

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1624   (Part of the series on the History of Blank, Empty and Missing Things.)

    Koberger bw884

    Perhaps “everything” wasn’t missing, but almost everything was.  Certainly the ancients and even the more-moderns, even the scientists of the 16th and into the 17th centuries (until von Guericke in 1672), could not abide the idea of the existence of nothing.  The vacuum, a space in which there was nothing at all, was seen to be an anathema to the creations of the great creator, that the vacuum was antithetical to what was understood to be the nature of nature. (I wrote a post here earlier on when nothing was almost something.)

    But what we see here, above, is the third day of creation as presented in one of the most significant books printed in the 15th century, and it is somewhat problematic, because it depicts almost-northing.  That, or almost-everything. 

    The book was written in Latin by Hartmann Schedel (1444-1514, with the German translation by Georg Alt) , with the illustrations under the control of Michael Wohlgemut (1434-1519) and his stepson Wilhelm Pleydenwurff (c. 1450-1494), .and was published in Nuremberg in 1493 by Anton Koberger as Liber Chronicarum–known best to English-pseaking readers as the Nuremberg Chronicles (and to Germans as Die Schedelsche Weltchronik).  It is perhaps one of the greatest illustrated works in the first half-century of movable type printing, using more than 1800 woodcuts to tell the story of the world–according to the Bible, mostly.  (The book deals with the history of world in its seven ages–the first five of which deal with cumuulative history to the birth of Jesus Christ, while the sixth ages handles the history from Christ to the present day, and teh seventh carries along the future history of the world to the Last Judgment.  Not much then is devoted to the 1500 years preceding the publication of Koberger’s book. The author, Schedel, was a very religious man, and considered the work of teh Bible to come from the hand of god and therefore was infallible; on the other hand (so to speak), everything written outside of the Bible was that of humans, and so fallible, and therefore open to interpretation.)

    Here is a colored version of the third day in the creation cycle mythology, which opens itself to much more visual congruence. (“On the third day God gathered together unto one place the waters under the firmament; and the dry land appeared. And God called the dry land Earth; and the gathering together of the waters he called Seas; and God saw that it was good, and said, Let the earth bring forth the green grass, the herb yielding seed, and the fruit trees yielding fruit after their kind.[Genesis 1:9-13.]”)

    Koberger color

    Koberger color b

    And the uncolored version, third day:

    Koberger bw det

    This sort of “nothingness” is not unique, as we can see in this example from the Mantegna Tarocchi, showing the creator as Primum Mobile, the First Mover, holding what may well be our universe in its hands (and standing on another sphere of nothing, god knows what that might be):


    https://historyofideasblog.com/a/6a00d83542d51e69e20133f47ca205970b-piPerhaps I’m missing the larger picture, and that the circles/spheres are the things created, and that they are contained in the square surrounding them; and that the boundaries marked by the circular lines are not necessarily empty, and that it is the suggested of the circles that is the stuff created, placeholders, contained within the square of the creator’s domain.  Or maybe not. Perhaps the circles are signifiers for the elements–earth at the center, surrounded by water/air/fire. Perhaps the woodcut was just waiting for some color. 

    Notes:

    The English translation of the Nuremberg chronicle used here is from Beloit College (here) which also has a very lovely scholarly treatment of their copy of the Nuremberg Chronicle (here).

    Here’s the rest of the cycle, in color:

    “For he spoke and they were made: He commanded and they were created”  (Psalm 33)., so says the legend (IPSE DIXIT ET FACTA SUNT; IPSE MANDAVIT ET CREATA SUNT Psalm 32) which floats above god enthroned–but it is difficult to see the progress in the un-colored version of day three.  

    http://www.beloit.edu/nuremberg/graphics/Layout%20and%20Design-Full%20Page_lg.jpg

    The first day:

    Korberger 1st day real