A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Lines, History of

  • Exercise in Irony: the Usually-Invisible Chinese Rail Worker and the Highly Visible Photographer, 1869

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1903   Part of the series on the History of Blank, Empty and Missing Things:  Chinese Rail Workers, 1869. 

    Chinese promontory

    One thing that you seldom see so juxtaposed in the photographic history of the American West are the people who were so important to it placed in proximity to those who were no well disposed to recording their existence. 

    For example:  this image by J.B. Silvis, “China Section Gang Promontory”, a photograph published as a stereocard between  1869 and 1870, shows a small group of Chinese workers setting two rails in Utah–they are the ubiquitously missing elements in historical images of transcontinental railroad construction. There were many thousands of these workers who were set to notoriously difficult tasks in bad situations and under time constraints with little liberty or pay (and not well-afforded much protection under the law), and in the history of documenting the expansion of the railroad across the West these workers are very seldom seen.

    They are set incongruously in front of a photography car that so often saw through or around them.   The  car was labeled  “U.P.R.R. Photograph J.B. Silvis Stereoscopic & Landscape Views of Notable Points on line of Pacific R.R. Always on Hand”, and I found it tempting to try to see in the photograph that it was made solely for the photographer’s advertisement, but the central placement of the workers makes a good argument against this.  On the other hand, when you look at some of the other work of Silvis documenting his railway car (see here), there are a number of group images where he gathers cowboys or Indians  or makes a photo with his car in an unusual place, he is definitely using those people and locales to establish the idea of remoteness and wildness of the places in which he was working. It seems to me that in the end, he was using the Chinese laborers as a piece of his advertising ensemble more than documenting them. Again, this is very speculative.

    It is a very unusual image which I think is knee-deep in irony. 

    I should also like to point out that most of the workers have taken care to sew  large leather patches on their breeches–that to help their thighs when pulling that heavy metal lever across their bodies while setting and moving track. 

    [All images via Denver Public Library, here.]


  • Vernacular Found-Polygonism 2: Walker Evans on the Roof

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    Evans polygons

    How many polygons can you find? 

    “Walker Evans climbed to the roof of the Fisk Building on Central Park South to  photograph the web of steel struts and electric signs that were rapidly filling the skies over Manhattan. The electric signs in this photograph alternately  flashed the company’s name and the names of its two principal products. As there  were approximately a hundred million wheels rolling over America’s roads in  1928, the sale of tires quickly overtook that of rubber galoshes. The image  expresses Evans’ conviction that modern art could be timeless yet topical when  perfectly wrought of vernacular materials.”–Metropolitan Museum of Art

    This is one in a series of posts made on found geometries–here are a few others:

    Found Alphabets and Geometry in Stone.(here)

    Magritte-Like Disorienting Geometry in Found-Art Urban Design, 1925 (here)

    Sierpinski Triangles & the Empire State Building (here)

     


  • Images of Shadows in Storytelling

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1836

    ‘There is seldom in shadow a mystery less hidden”–Ombra Nichts Schatten, The Non-Mystery of the Shadow, London, 1842

    Shadows have long played havoc in the imagination, for good and for evil, for elucidation and of mystery–they have hidden nothing and everything, and displayed as little as possible and as much as can be imagined. A simple shadow in a hole had proved the circumference of the Earth twenty centuries ago, and before that the Earth’s shadow on the face of the Moon showed us to be a sphere; the shadow allowed us to measure the heights of mountains on the Moon before we could do so (accurately) on Earth; we measure shadows in X-rays, and follow the trails of subatomic particles, and on and on.  Shadows are particularly interesting in story telling, whether they be suggested  aurally or in text, or of course in illustration: 

    Chalres H. Bennet, Shadow and Substance, London 1860.

    A superior example of shadow-art is seen in Indonesian shadow puppet theatre, “Wayang Kulit”, where the shadows of Javanese-Indonesian characters are projected onto a cloth screen by a strong light from behind.

    Audiences were bathed in direct and brilliant light while being swamped in shadow in the early 19th century as part of an early form of non-cinema cinema, as we see here in the frontispiece from Robertson’s Mémoires récréatifs, which depicts a phantasmagoria of lantern projections:

     

    And more forthright illusions as seen in this engraving showing the spectre “Dr. Pepper’s Ghost,” from Theodor Eckardt, Die Physik in Bildern Eßlingen, 1881:

     

    The shadow may have been invented in cinema by the German Expressionists, with  Friedrich Wilhelm Murnau’s Nosferatu (1919) as a shining example:

    And of course the shadow is used with great effect in the  very black-and-white and no-gray-tones Film Noir world, particularly in the hands of a master like Mr. Welles in films like The Third Man:

    And in Fritz Lang’s diabolically-bad M, earlier, in 1931 (featuring an impossible shadow in the movie still below):

    Thank heaven for little girls... or would that be hell?

     

    Shadow has been used to given questionable dimensionality in addition to giving perspective to dimensions that we are familiar with:

     

     

    And the artificial shadow made for the geographical clock dial to tell the story of passing time:

    And also for shadow puzzle toys:

     

    And on and on, deep into the night…

     


  • An Episode in the History of Anticipation: Death at Archimedes’ Door

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1665

    Archimedes021

    Earlier in this blog there appeared an entry on the death of Archimedes–actually, it was a piece on an image depicting the killing of the great mathematician.  It is a pretty gruesome affair, even by the very early 18th century standards under which the engraving was made–gruesome still by today’s standards, what with the man’s head being cleaved laterally in two by the summoned Roman Centurion. I’m not an historian of these images of Archimedes, but I can say that for whatever I am, I have not seen anything quite so graphic dealing with the man’s death.

    The usual images of Archimedes coming to his end show him working a problem in his dust/sand/earth “chalkboard”, absorbed to such an extent in his thinking that he doesn’t hear the chaos outside his rooms, and doesn’t sense the approach of the soldier who finds Archimedes unresponsive to his calls and therefore a threat, and so kills him.

    Archimedes022[Image source:  Titus Livius, Romanae historiae principia, libri omnes.  Printed in Frankfurt by Feyerabend, 1578.]

    Looking at this image (above) brought to mind another in the history of anticipation–not knock knock knocking on Heaven’s door, but the opposite, and the opposite of that, the opposite of  knocking on Death’s door, or at Death’s door:  Death knocking at our door. 

    The title of this emblem–Cunctos mors una manet/death is all that remains–is meant to remind us

    va1612099pict

    of our common foe.  It is the work of  one of the great engravers of his time, Otto van Veen (teacher of Rubens),  and appears (along with next image and 100 others) in his Q. Horati Flacci emblemata.  Imaginibus in acs incisis notisque illustrata, printed in Amsterdam in 1607 by H. Verduss.

    –All images and most translations courtesy of the splendid work at The Emblem Project/Utrecht, here.–

    Part of the legend (which appeared in four languages) of the image leaves us with the following reminders, choice bits on the folly of forgetting our common end:

    La terre embrasse tout comme mere commune –Mother Earth embraces us all

    Moritur sutor eodem modo ac Rex.–The King died the same as the shoemaker

    Death is the thing that sucks the rivers of lives, “Del rico al pobre, del soldado al Papa”, From rich to poor, soldier of the Pope.

    and so in image and word telling us that death will seek us out, whether king or shoemaker, rich or poor–and that in the coming end the Earth will take us all.  Archimedes didn’t hear that one coming; nor did he care, I think. 

    THis last image brings to mind Archimedes’ work in the dust, though the intent of teh emblem (“Estote prudentes” //Be ye therefore wise // Be Cautious) wouold have been completely lost on him.

    The legend translates (Thanks to the Emblem Project for this):

    When the serpent sees that it is going to be attacked with,
    Lethal wound, it protects its head with artful care.
    Here lie the dwellings of the soul, the sanctuary of the truth.
    Hence comes life that is to be hoped for by every body.

    Surely Archimedes could relate to his lines and the expressions of his thought as the dwellings of his soul (if he actually believed in a soul), though I guess you could say that the artful deception of the serpent’s head finally wound up killing him via the Roman soldier.

    Letali serpens cùm se videt esse petendum
    Vulnere, sollicita contegit arte caput.
    Hîc animæ sedes positæ, verique recessus: (here placed the seat of the soul, in artful covering…)
    Hinc spiranda omni corpore vita venit

    av1615040pict


  • History of Lines: Clouds

     JF Ptak Science Books  Post 1629  (On Clouds and Not-Clouds, Part I)

    “…and they drew all manner if things–everything that begins with an M—‘

        ‘Why with an M?’ said Alice

       ‘Why not?’, said the March Hare.” –Lewis Carroll,  from “A Mad Tea Party”, in Alice’s Adventures in   Wonderland.

    Why not, indeed?  I’ve long had an interest in clouds, and since this blog is ostensibly on the surfacing or definition of Cloud Bones, I though to spend a little time on the origins of the depictions of printed clouds in art. Not being an expert by any means on the history of art, it just seems to me that after long exposure clouds are not well-represented in woodcuts, wood engravings and other early engravings, or at least not so well depicted as their landsmen in paintings.  There seems to be no shortage of effort to reveal gorgeous clouds  through the early Renaissance–but the doesn’t seem to apply very often to their representation in prints.

    And that of course is when the detail of the sky is depicted at all. It seems that more often than not, in woodcuts printed from say 1460 through 1550, that the sky is left blank, like this image from Ovid (Accipe Studiose Lector P. Ouidij Metamorphosin...printed in Venice in 1509:

    Clouds no couds livy913

    “You could not see a cloud, because
    No cloud was in the sky:
    No birds were flying overhead —
    There were no birds to fly”.–Lewis Carroll, Through the Looking Glass. 

    I could go on with many examples of the blank sky–the white, blank, settled nothingness–but exhibiting variations of nothing at this point isn’t necessary.  But illustrating clouds is.

    And for the most part, clouds don’t look very much like themselves in prints, not really, not for more than a hundred years.  For example, Martin Schoengauer‘s spectacular  The Temptation of St. Anthony, which was printed in 1470/5, has a beautiful, fluid circularity to it, full of an earthy roundness even as the saint is pursued by demons.  But the sky in the background is populated with nothing but dashes to suggest clouds. 

    http://thewholegardenwillbow.files.wordpress.com/2008/11/schongauer-martin-anthony103.jpg

    Perhaps clouds would have taken away from the moment; but if that were the case, why bother with the dashes?

    There are considerable exceptions to this practice, with Durer and Altdorfer coming quickly to mind–but in my experience, the oddly-formed cloud seems to be the majority rule in the woodcut.  

    At this time there were of course many depictions of skies with no clouds in paintings, bare suggestions of themselves, even in some of the most famous works–Botticelli’s Birth of Venus and Michelangelo’s Fall of Man in the Sistine Chapel are fair examples.  But once you move away from the golden Sienese skies of the14th century1, clouds are given full and beautiful shapes from early periods. (Giotto’s Christ’s Entering Jerusalem, 1305/6; Simone Martin The Road to Calvary, 1340; Duccio’s Christ Entering Jerusalem, 1308-1311; Fra Angelico’s The Dposition, 1436; Masaccio’s The Tribute Money, 1424; Lippi’s Annunciation, a perfect cloud treatise, 1442, and on and on. Other examples are found in continued reading below.)

    Clouds in prints are a different matter–I’m not sure if it was just too technically difficult to create clouds in wood, or if there was some sort of languishing Byzantine sensibility inherent in woodblocks that was not so in oil. I’m really not so sure about this, and as much as anything else I’m thinking out loud about this lack of cloud definition.  I don’t have an answer for it.  But I do want to share the beginning of a timeline for undefined clouds as they appeared (or not) over the course of about one hundred years,  from 1485 to about the end of the 16th century.   As I mentioned clouds appeared beautifully in paintings from earlier periods, and there doesn’t really seem to be a substandard-cloud complement in the painting world as there was in the print world.  Of course, in western philosophy and science, clouds were pretty much left alone from inquiry, even by a series of the great natural history classifiers–they wouldn’t really be given a fully taxonomic appreciation until 1803 by Luke Howard (which I wrote about in this blog earlier, here).

    A Timeline of Clouds in Prints, 1485-1596

    Franciscus de Retza, De Generatione Christi, sive Defensorium Castiatis Beatae Virginis Mariae, a beautiful work in Gothic type–a picture book, really, with two illustrations of magnets.  Printed in 1485, this image depicts Isidorus in a magnetic coffin which is floating in the air:

    Clouds 1485908

    “The Adoration of the Magi”, from Legenda Sanctorum Trium Regum, printed in Modena in 1490:

    Clouds 1490 adoration magi912
    The Triumph of Love, 1492/3:

    Clouds 1492 triumph love911


  • History of Lines: Looking Straight Down from Straight Up, 1786

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1581

    Looking down656
    I was struck by the mosaic possibilities of the image (below) found in Thomas Baldwin’s Airopaidia (printed in 1786) and so made it into one.  But what the engraving is,m really, is a view from a balloon, looking straight down.

    Looking down655

    We’re looking straight down, through the clouds, seeing two towns (at bottom-left and top-center)–why the rivers are red, I don’t know.

    There are other posts on this blog on looking straight down, which is an attractive subject–to me, at least. First-hand images of looking straight down fro a balloon are rare things, even through the early 19th century, and offer a prospective seldom seen in human history.

    Another view from this work attempts to show some depth:

    http://vintageprintable.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/Science-Flight-View-from-Balloon-18thC.jpg

    Here’s another view of that same image from the Baldwin experience, reprinted around 1810, and left in black-and-white:”

    Looking str8t Diwn-balloom det220

     Halton Tuner makes these observations on Baldwin’s flight in his iconic Astra Castra: Experiments and adventures in the atmosphere 1(published in 1864 in London): 


  • History of Lines: the Desire Lines of William Blake

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1578    [Part of this blog’s History of Lines series}

     The post dedicated to Patti Digh, brilliant writer and birthday girl, who wrote a lovely, image-filled  essay on Desire Lines back in December 2005 on her award-winning blog, 37days. I think the idea of Desire Lines is one of her favorites, and so I tried to imagine my own in her honor, a small Festschrift for the birthday girl.  Happy Birthday, P.D.!

    ‘I want! I want!’ (1793) by William Blake Alastair Sooke examines Blake’s endearing engraving documenting the stages of man’s life This sweet engraving by William Blake is a vision of rudimentary space travel created centuries before Neil Armstrong was even a twinkle in his father’s eye. It isn’t hard to imagine the mystical poet and artist in his Lambeth garden, gazing at the starry sky and dreaming of a slender ladder propped up against the moon. A memorable image of aspirational zeal, I want! I want! is one of 18 tiny engravings, measuring 6cm x 5cm, that document the different stages of man’s life, published together as For Children: The Gates of Paradise in 1793. It is on show at Compton Verney in Warwickshire, part of an idiosyncratic exhibition which examines the ways in which Western artists have grappled with the cosmos since the days of Galileo. The astronomer’s Sidereus Nuncius (The Starry Messenger), published in 1610 and on loan from Corpus Christi College, Oxford, gives the exhibition its name, and can be seen alongside work by contemporary artists such as Glenn Brown, Steve McQueen and Wolfgang Tillmans.

     William Blake had a hard time of things, what with being thought of in unflattering terms of crazy vs. insane by many people rather than, say, being though of as “creative”.  He led a good and relatively long life (1757-1827), and by his artistic and poetic creations inspired generations of other creatives, though he was very little recognized during his lifetime.  He was a seeker, and was somehow able to do his art and printmaking and poetry without a substantial income, living mostly on adequate income and patrons, slowly advancing to semi-poverty as he aged , but dying without a debt to his name.

    The “line” that I site above to his unusual work, The Gates of Paradise–not the Baptistery doors by Ghiberti–, was actually a ladder and a collection of lines, but with the application of perspective becomes one combined line quicker and longer than it could ever be a ladder.   Blake’s character, as with Blake himself, wants whatever it is that he can have, conceivable or not; and som, if he wants the Moon, he just goes to get it.  This version of The Gates of Paradise, which is largely a story of pictures and a few words as legend, was intended for children, perhaps–or at least that’s what the title says.  In any event, its an interesting message to send to children whether it was actually intended for children of the chronological age, or not.  The “I Want, I Want” legend really wasn’t necessary, as the image stands on its own.

    Blake liked to tell a story with lines like this, as we see in this famous image of Newton:

    File:Newton-WilliamBlake.jpg

    Blake was an impossible anti-Newtonian–at least in my limited reading of the man–making a career of being a spectacular and beautiful anti-rationalist,  a weaver of smoke, playing with and distorting images like a theramin player of words, using language to produce dichotomies in even the most standard of sensate ideas.  Blake was the poster child for thing anti-tech, an anti-scientist out to save the world from its scientific self,  the rationalist world set to destroy imagination, the “Antichrist science” hell bent on destroying the soul of art and religion. 

    “Art is the tree of life; Science is the tree of death” wrote Blake, and so he chose the “Athesistic”  Sir Isaac to stand for the beast, depicting him in art as a naked geometer intent on subjugating the world with a compass and a keen brain, reducing glory to quantification, the work of Satan..  For most of my life I thought that this image by Blake was celebrating Newton—I knew little of the poet/artist/poet, and thought the painting a reverence.  When I understood Blake a little,  I saw that the image was intended as a mockery of Newton and the idea of science—this was an unusual sensation, because absent the unspoken intention of the artist,  you could still take the subject matter of the artwork two ways. 

    And of course the Creator:

    http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/a/ae/Blake_ancient_of_days.jpg

     

    God is presented as the Great Geometer, the creative power of the universe issuing forth with compass/dividers, was perhaps a kind of Greek conception of the rule of the universe and its interaction with all things on Earth. 

    But it is interesting that in the end, Blake displays the sublime reasoning powers of Heaven and Earth, in the forms of God and Newton, both with desire lines.  I think he enjoyed doing that. 

    The Series “For Children” of 1793:

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • History of Lines–a Note on the First Appearance of the Addition (“+”) Sign

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 1575  [Part of the History of Lines series]

    Lines--addition sign 3 Widman det644
    The history of lines is full and rich with symbols, some of which have absolutely nothing to do with the extension of trust and belief and hope and fear–unless you’re a young student studying math or chemistry or physics.  One symbol in the maths that seems to have no exact age except to say that it is semi-ancient is the addition sign.  (It will be interesting in this series on the history of lines to address the origins of  other symbols like the sign for pi, division. multiplication, percent, inequality,  equality and so on.)

    Lines--addition sign Widman642
    I say “semi-ancient” because the symbol for addition is a hieratic form of the Egyptian hieroglyphic, looking like a capital “A” in a way, without the horizontal crossbar.  The earliest appearance of a symbol for addition in Europe was in the 13th century, with the letter “p“, appearing in various forms, as well as the word “plus”, “used in connection with the Rule of False Position”1.  The concept also appears as the word itself, as “et”, or “and”, which just so happens to closely resemble the symbol that the concept would become a few centuries later.  The earliest appearance of the symbol we would recognize instantly today as an addition sign came in the 1489 book by Wideman, the Behenunde und kuepsche Rechnung (seen above in detail and in full, from the 1532 edition of the work), while the first time the “+” appears in an algebraic equation for the first time 25 years later, in a work by Vander Hoecke.  

    It is interesting to think of the life of these symbols before they became themselves. 

    I am not certain of this, but it seems that the first “+” printed in the United States did not occur until the 20th edition of James Hodder’s2 Arithmetic3 was printed in Boston in 1719, and this at the press of James Franklin (1697-1735), the fourth child of ten in the Franklin family that included Benjamin (1706-1790).  So it is entirely possible that 13-year-old Ben helped his older brother print the first addition sign in the British Colonies. 

    Notes:

    1. D.E. Smith, The History of Mathematics, volume II, p. 397

    2. Hodder in 1672 wrote “note that a + (plus) sign doth signifie Addition, and two lines thus = Equality, or Equation, but a X thus, Multiplication,” no other symbols being used.”  (Smith p395)

    3.  In his introduction, Hodder says:


  • History of Lines–Measuring Things with People, 1522

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post (Edited-and-added version of Post 1019)

      0 blog feb 20 line611det

     “My car gets forty rods to the hogshead, and that’s the way I likes it!”–Grandpa (Abe) Simpson, from The Simpsons  (That’s about 500 gallons to the mile.)

    A line, a connection of two points in space, is about as basic an imaginary thing as we have here on earth.  Humans have used these creations to build all sorts of straight things, from roads to building to ships to literature to mathematics and on and on.  What doesn’t happen very often, at least not in Western art in the last 500 years or so, is for people to be represented in art in a straight line that is not a processional (including military, religious, political venues), or that is not along a bench next to a table, or not supported by another artificial structure like a fortress wall (to give their waiting or standing a form to accommodate).   That weakens the line field considerably–after all, what else is there to line up for?  They’re not queuing up for a sale at Gimbels, and they’re not waiting patiently for a place on the bus.  There’s just not that much to form a line for, evidently. 

    0 blog feb 20 line611 There is, on the other hand, this (above and below), what I take to be rare representation of my odd requirements:  a delightful woodcut from Jacob Koebel’s 1522 Von Ursprung der Teilung, Mass und Messung dess Ertrichs, der Ecker, Wyngarten, Krautgarten und anderer Velder…, an early surveying handbook (probably the first ever printed in Germany) that could be used to measure and set out (as stated in its title) herb gardens, vineyards, farms and the like.

    I’m not 100% sure of this, but I think what is going oin in this image is the measruing of a rod (or “rute” in German), which is about 5.5 meters or 16 feet; and what we have in the picture is 16 men being positioned over a measuring device and beign overseen by the powers that be, at rear. On the other hand, maybe not:  the English rod was 16.5 feet, while the rod measurement for Saxony, Rhineland, Bavaria and Baden were different as well; Sweden also came in at 16 feet to the rod.  The other big question was:  how long was a “foot”? Since that measure also chnaged (varing between 23.51 cm in Wesel and 40.83 cm in Trier and  31.387 cm up north in the Rhineland)  the measurement of anything with variable units of measure seems to have been problematic, or at least in a post-facto measure.  [The whole issue of “absolute” units of measurement is another post for another time (and a much bigger and moire compelx story).] For right now I’m content to have found this pretty image, which in the end was probably the work of the author Koebel (1470-1533), who seems to have been a jack-of-all-trades; and while he was concerned with property and measurement, he also showed his flair with charm, as this group of men atest. 


  • History of Lines–Where is “there”? The Medieval T-O World Map

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post  

    Lines--t map639

    This woodcut cosmological illustration from a 1526 Bible is a subtle and very late printed rendition of a great and classic Medieval idea.  At the center(or thereabouts)  of the globe of the Earth there is a seeming confluence of two great rivers, but what it reminds me more of is the T-O map, the orbis  terrarum, the direct descendant of the

    Lines--t map638

    Greco-Roman map making.  The T-O map makes distant and deep calls into the past, finding a home in Macrobius (around 400 CE) and Orosius (5th century )and more famously with Isidore of Seville (ca.  600), a work known to most folks today because of its appearance in Seville’s Etymologarum of 1472, which is also the first map printed in Europe (pictured below). (Why is took almost 20 years after Gutenberg to print a map is mysterious to me.)

    Generally Jerusalem would appear at the center of this sort of map, which would have appealed to the necessary people that the publication needed to have the appeal of.  The Mediterranean would separate Europe and Africa from Asia, while all of the land masses (the stuff outside of the “T” structure” were surrounded by the great “O”, the ocean(s).

    Sixteen years later a remarkable map of the world would appear in Ptolemy’s Geographia, an Ulm-printed masterpiece that appeared in 1486. 

    . Ptolemy's world map (around 140 CE);copy Ulm edition of 1486.
    But I think that the crossed lines from the Luther Bible of 1526 was really just a suggestion of the past, not meaning to lean on the Medieval world at all.  Still, though there they are.