A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Art History

  • Science and Art; True Science or Science Fiction? #1: Tinguely, Oliver Byrne, Vredeman de Vries and the Theatrophone

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post #79

    Blogrealtinguely
    There are encyclopedias to be written on the not-obvious in the history of science, dictionaries of “what is it”, codexes of “is that real?”, handbooks to distinguish things that look like scientific apparatus but are actually works of art, and vice versa. This is my first installment looking at the occasionally squishy visual line that distinguishes images that are “true” scientific creations from those that are not. 

    Case #1.  FALSE 
    Our first example comes from Jean Tinguely (1925 – 1991)  a Swiss painter and sculptor, best known for his Dadaist kinetic sculpture, officially known as metamechanics. This photo shows Tinguely in the midst of trying to make his self destructing sculpture, Homage to New York (1960), self destruct. His collection of wheels and cogs and connected motors and techno bric-a-brac, which in their way stood for the embarrassment of overproduction and  self-satisfaction with material goods, embarrassingly failed to self destruct during its unveiling at MOMA.

    Blogrealbyrne
    Case #2. TRUE.
    Oliver Byrne’s semi-insane but gorgeous interpretive work of the first six books of Euclid  published by William Pickering in London, is problematic.  Byrne’s use of color in place of letters in defining and explaining the propositions just doesn’t work very fluidly–it is a great, perhaps the great, example of something that is visually pleasing, beautifully rendered, and sort of functionless.

    Blogrealbyrne_tp
    Blogrealtelegraphone_2

    Case #3. TRUE
    This is the distributing board of the central London “theatrophone”, a telephone relay device that “broadcast” theatrical and symphonic productions to telephone subscribers.  The idea is base on installations of this device during the International exposition in Paris in 1881.  The article appears in Scientific American, Supplement No. 1002, March 16, 1895.  The second image is the switchboard in the central office of the Theatrophone Company.

       

    Blogrealvredmanbw_2

    Case #4, TRUE:  Hans Vredeman de Vries (1527 – c. 1607),a Dutch Renaissance architect and engineer, produced a superb book on perspective in 1604, from which this image was selected.  Of course we manipulated it a little in p-shop, dumping it into mosaic, cheating a little, but, well, there you have it. Vredeman’s production was luscious and smart, and was highly utilized and prized for hundreds of years as a
    useful tool in determining perspective.  It’s a mysterious image, bizarre, even–why, for example did the humble artist use a prone/dead/injured human there on t he floor when he could’ve selected something more benign? The odd figure entering the room through the secret door adds to the general threatening atmosphere of this interesting image.  Base line though–it is undeniably an excellent instructional on drawing with perspective.


      

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • The Nature of Things & the Display of Information: Alhazen and Optics, 1572

    Blogoptics040

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC
    Alhazen, (pseudonym of Abu
    Ali Hasan Ibn al-Haitham), born in Basra, Iraq, and who
    lived from 965-1039, was perhaps the greatest of all the great Muslim
    physicists, and was also one of the greatest physicists with an interest in
    optics of all time. Considered to be “the
    father of modern optics”, he was an original thinker and an historian, an overall
    scientist,  preserving the ancient,
    accentuating the modern and creative in his own right.

    The woodcut illustration—deceptively
    complex but rather simple once you focus– from his book
    Opticae
    thesavrvs. Alhazeni Arabis libri septem, nuncprimum editi. Eivsdem liber De
    crepvscvlis & nubium ascensionibus…
    demonstrates a number of optical principles–if
    you look hard enough. (The Opticae by the way was about the only one of his 200 or so books to have survived the destructive powers of time and neglect.)  In the foreground we see tow examples in the
    field of optics of keen interest to Alhazen. The man standing in the puddle up to his knees in water shows the
    distortion that occurs due to refraction (an area in which he greatly improved
    upon Ptolemy’s understanding) The guy to
    the right of naked knee-distorted man is probably using his mirror to keep an
    eye out on what was happening behind him (it looks as though the person he’s
    spying is not him but someone hiding behind the hillock). This small defensive use of the mirror pales
    in comparison to what was happening as a cause of mirrors directly behind
    him: the galleons are definitely being
    set ablaze by the Archimedean-like use of mirrors in the city on the far side
    of the harbor (like Syracuse), and we can see that one of the ships is already
    nearly sunken.

     The bridge (with the loitering
    elephants ?) is set to exhibit the knowledge of perspective, even though this
    is not the best example of receding background– it was through
    Alhazen
    that a very considerable part of that science found its way into Medieval and Renaissance
    culture, particularly in the artwork of  Ghiberti,
    Alberti, Leonardo, and later, Poussin.  Roger
    Bacon (13th c), Pole Witelo (Vitellio) and most of the other
    Medieval Western writers on optics based their optical work primarily on Alhazen’s
    work. ‘ (The use and choice of the
    elephant on the bridge is a mystery to me, particularly since we don’t see one
    on the other side of the bridge, which would’ve been helpful to illuminate the
    perspective bit.)  The rainbow in the background is there simply
    to remind us of the already well-known association of its formation and
    light. The
    setting sun might also hint at
    Alhazen’s discussion of the density of
    the atmosphere and the relation between it and  height—he would go on to discover that origin
    and breadth of twilight, the height of the atmosphere, and many other things
    back there one thousand years ago. This woodcut
    hints at only a few of his great achievements.

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • Visionaries: the Crowded Future of Albert Robida, the Jules Verne of SciFi Art

    JF Ptak Science Books

    Albert Robida, a fabulous visionary born in France in 1848 (dying in  1926) was an illustrator, etcher, lithographer, caricaturist, and novelist.  His greatest achievement is his futuristic trilogy, including Le Vingtième Siècle (1883), La Guerre au vingtième siècle (1887) and Le Vingtième siècle. La vie électrique (1890).  In general he has deep, realistic vision, the sort that puts him on a similar  plane as Jules Verne, but is differentiated from his  famous French compatriot, in that his creations seem more compatible with possibility, being more common, more fashioned to what the average person might come to expect of their future creature comforts.  In spite of a fantastic and perhaps unparalleled scifi imagination, Verne seems a little beyond the scope of the mortal future, maybe a little too much for their appreciation of whatever common class the future might hold room for.   

    La Sortie de l'opéra en l'an 2000

    [Source: Library of Congress]

    The future of Robida includes telephones (more in their application and use than in the invention itself, seeing far more accurately, I think, in the possible roles in society than people like Bell and Dolbear saw in their own inventions), televisions (the telephonoscope), bacterial warfare, emancipation and political empowerment of women, advanced submarines, transportation tubes, helicopters, and the like.   

    Robida La Vie Electrique

    Verne (born in 1828) had an exhaustive, exhausting, fantastically accomplished literary career—his bibliography is a sci-fi equivalent of William Shakespeare in that his accomplishments are so vast.  (Not of course actually as vast as the Bard, because Old Bill was totally impossible–an Einstein/Feynman/Newton/Chandra of literature, all rolled into one person.  For example, some of his fifty books include these recognizable nuggets: Five Weeks in a Balloon (Cinq Semaines en ballon, 1863), Journey to the Center of the Earth (Voyage au centre de la Terre, 1864), From the Earth to the Moon (De la terre à la lune, 1865), In Search of the Castaways or Captain Grant’s
    Children (Les Enfants), Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea (Vingt mille lieues sous les mers, 1869-1870), Around The Moon (Autour de la lune, a sequel to From the Earth to the Moon, 1870). A Floating City (Une ville flottante, 1871). Around the World in Eighty Days (Le Tour du Monde en quatre-vingts jours, 1873), The Mysterious Island (L’île mysterieuse, 1875), Off on a Comet (Hector Servadac, 1877)

    They are deep and far-reaching, though Verne, unfortunately, did not find an artistic muse for his visions nearly as capable as those Robida produced for himself.  For example, in 1863 Verne wrote about Paris in the 20th century on many now-familiar things that in the heights of the US Civil War seemed impossible: skyscrapers, automatic and electric calculating machines, gas-powered cars, flying machines and a worldwide information and distribution network. 

    Futuristic-drawing-by-albert-robida-everett

    Blogrobidahowl

    What Robida did indeed have that Verne did not was an artistic talent, and it was here that he excelled—actually no one, in my opinion, had accomplished anything nearly as close as did Robida in imaging the future; few others in the 19th century comes close.  He was a Jules Verne of scifi illustration. 

    (Hayao Miyazaki’s “Howl’s Moving Castle”, a Japanese anime film from 2004, has remarkable flying machine quite resembling Robida’s mannerism, and I think I’d be remiss for not mentioning it.)


  • Beautiful Title Pages 2—Living Skeletons and Anthropomorphic Shells

    Blogunusual_design_elements0322
    JF Ptak Science Books LLC
    The first title page here belongs to Guillio Casserio (c.1552-1616), De Vocis Auditusque Organis historia anatomica singulari fide methodo…, 1600-1601, an absolutely gorgeous illustrated monograph on the vocal organs and organs of hearing in man and animals. Casserio, a superb anatomist (and who was also signatory to William Harvey’s doctoral diploma from Padua in 1602), set the standard for accuracy and beauty in copperplate anatomical illustration just as Vesalius had set the standard for woodcut illustration.

    Casserio_1
    I cannot recall a title page illustrated with so many skeletons, especially so beautifully arranged, and posed in common, breathing, living situations.  Their placement is excellent, along with the other skull and bones—it seems to me as though they could not be re-arranged into a better assortment more pleasing to the eye, much like rearranging Joseph Cornell construction…it just cannot be done. 

    Another fine example of title page design is Filippo Buonanni’s Museum Kircherianum sive Museaeum A.P. Athanasio Kirchero…printed in Rome in 1709, and it  belongs to the first published effort to catalog the scientific and miscellaneous
    Blogunusual_design_elements031_3

    collection of the vast 17th century polymath, Athanasius Kircher; the collection assembled in the Jesuit Collegio Roman, and assembled by Alfonso Donnimo.  Buonanni  was a student  of and successor  to Kircher at the Collegio  and catalogued the specimens of natural history, scientific instruments, geological items, Egyptian antiquities, and other items brought back to the school via networks of Jesuit missionaries.  His particular strength in study was conchology, and he displayed his knowledge in this intricate arrangement of shells from the collection in the title page.

    Arcimboldovertemnus_3I cannot help but think that his artistic vision may have been  influenced by the extraordinary Giuseppe Arcimboldo (also spelled Arcimboldi; 1527-1593), who, one hundred or so years earlier, painted (in his non-conventional works) fantastic portraits and images using fruits, vegetables and other natural objects as the sole source of representation.  On the other hand his influence may not have been so very well known, as many of his works were stolen during war time in the mid-17th century, and he fell rather deeply into obscurity until being revived and resurrected by the Surrealists in the 20th century.  His work was so extraordinary–and this is true at any time in history but especially so during the time that he lived–that it would be impossible not to mention this unique talent in connection with Buonanni.


  • The History of the Future 2: Henard touches on the Future’s Future Plan, 1911

    Bloghenard029JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post #51

    This  cross section illustration (“Rue Future”/Future Street) is from E. Henard’s (1849-1923) article, “The Cities of the Future”,
    from American City, Volume 4, January, 1911. In this article Henard (architect of the city of Paris and from 1880 a life-long employee and advocate of public works in that city) looks into the future
    and sees the movement towards underground (or enclosed) vehicular traffic,
    “smart” buildings, pneumatic tubing for vacuum cleaners (“almost
    sure to come into general use”), an improvement in the system for water
    delivery and removal, replacing coal with natural gas, and more. He lays out a
    plan to implement his idea that, if implemented int he city of

    Bloghenard029_detail

    Paris, would cost $420,000,000 (or
    approximately $15 billion in 2006 money) over 100 years. [This part seems a
    little off given that the area for public roads alone in Paris at this time was 3,700 acres–nevertheless this was an interesting appearing plan, a significant
    portion of which has found its way into building and community planning albeit
    on a far smaller scale].

    Henard was also acutely interested in the future traffic problems of Paris and other major cities, proposing revolutionary radial traffic patterns for moving cars around major metropolitan areas–which was really quite visionary as the mass production of automobiles had not yet really taken place–certainly automobiles were far more common by 1911 than 1905, but their numbers would be vaulted higher int he next decade with the first true approach to assembly line production of automobiles, making them affordable to the millions.  His plan for a ring-lime system around the city of Paris was influential to some of the ideas in the early
    American planning reports for San Francisco and Chicago by the great Daniel Burnham.

    What is particularly interesting for me in the Henerad plan is the room that he left for his future’s future–he attempted to make his plan adaptable for the time when the future he was writing about was becoming the past.  And so he was leaving room in his underground plans (in particular) to accommodate some of what the future might hold in store for his city, leaving unused spaces and tunnels, so that the city planners in the future would not have to go through the enormous expense of putting these things in for themselves.  Now that is future-forward thinking. 

     

    For a good, long article on the plan see http://www.library.cornell.edu/Reps/DOCS/henard.htm

     


  • Emblems of Featureless Faces–Philibert de l’Orme’s Architecture, 1568

    Web_blogbad_builder028
    Philibert de l’Orme’s book, Le Premier Tome de l’Architecture,
    printed in Paris in 1568, contains a singular illustration. L’Orme (who lived ca. 1515-1570), was perhaps one of the first modern
    architects, not only because of his superior engineering skills, but also because
    he was a superb organizer—a superior architectural tactician.

     He worked for Henry II and Charles IX, supervising the construction
    of Fontainebleau, Saint-Germain-en-Laye—where he built the
    Château Neuf, and the other royal buildings. As well as the Tuileries,
    in collaboration with Jean Bullant.

    The text explaining the illustration reads something like “to
    guard against persons who can do nothing right, cannot see what is to be done
    well, cannot hear what should be understood…” Perhaps l’Orme was talking about people in general; or, perhaps, as I
    suspect, he was referring to someone in his own profession, a builder, an
    engineer, an architect? In any event,
    this singular image is one of the few that I can recall in which a person is
    allegorically represented without  hands,
    eyes, ears or, perhaps a nose.

    There’s quite a bit of imagery showing unusually-featured faces–and I’m talking about emblemata rather than monsters or mythological/hypothetical beings meant to go creaking into the night. I’m also excluding medical images Blogorme
    (like this for an early form of rhinoplasty) and people who have suffered injury or are differentially abled (as in this image of the great Tyhco Brahe and his silver nose).  I’m Tycho_brahe
    hard put to think of other examples of representational humans with such features existing in the technical or scientific world, though–I think that l’Orme’s designer/engineer here is a very scarce creation. 

     


  • Shaping Space and Controlling What We See—Determining What Color “Is”, Emily Vanderpoel and Pre-Kandinsky Art

    JF Ptak Science Books    Post #73

    Blogcolorvander_2poel_063
    The idea of how we put parameters to something like the visual field is a gargantuan topic—it is something that architects and geometers and physicists and mathematicians (in general) have dealt with forever.  Mapmakers have perhaps the most visualized aspect of this on paper, performing the semi-miracle of translating three dimensions into two; physicists have a more difficult time, taking the opposite approach, sort of , and translating two or three dimensional space into x-number of dimensions.  Anatomists had a difficult time of their subject until relatively recently in human history, what with the sublime religious curfews on messy knowledge and all coming into play, poking around into the heart and such as though it was an affront to the sanctity of the creator (M Servetus’ ideas on the circulation of the blood via the heart, making the heart a tool and not the brain or some odd conjunction of creative divine power, cost him his life, burning slowly alive at the stake…how mysterious the whole world of RNA Genotype-Phenotype Mapping and such would seem to him if he could have a peek into the future/present from wherever he is.)
    Blogcolorvanderpoel_062

    Color theory is old and pretty—as a matter of fact there is a very attractive gathering of color theory models (in black and white, though) displaying some two dozen or more color models from the last 400 years.  People like Della Porta (1593), our old friend and resident oddball polymath crank Kircher (1646), the smarter-than-you-could-believe Newton (1660), Waller (1686), Lambert (1772), the wide ranging and again polymathic Goethe (1792), Herschel (1817, who also ushered in our understanding of the other light-sensitive shape spacing medium of photography in 1840), the semi-forgotten Chevreul (1835), the beautiful Maxwell (1857), Wundt (1874, the early experimental psychologist who also looked for spirits/spiritmus and ghosts), von Bezold (1878), Rood (1879), Munsell (1918) Kandinsky (1914 and not decipherable by me) and Klee (1924), and so on towards the present, all tried to analyze the prospects of color.

    Not in this list is the very highly problematic Emily Vanderpoel, who in 1901 and 1903 produced (in two editions) a lovely but mysterious book called Color Problems for the Layman, in which she sought not so much to analyze the components of color itself, but rather to quantify the overall interpretative effect of color on the imagination.  I know this sounds begging and vague, but I really haven’t been able to make much headway in the work.

    Blogvanderpoel_1057
    I’m attracted to this effort because of its attempt at quantifying such abstract thoughts.

    By virtue of this effort, though, Vanderpoel had produced a strikingly illustrated book, with 118 color plates, all very intense, and beautiful, and in its way exceptional—unique perhaps.  Had the book been written thirty years or so hence we’d call it some sort of constructivist/constructionist artform.  But since the artwork in the book comes a decade before the first non-representational artwork in human history (or so), I don’t know exactly what to call it. 
    Blogvanderpoel_2058

    I really don’t know what it is, but I know that it is not entirely accidental, this pre-non-representational artform, because controlled geometrical color art is not accidental. 

    In trying to quantify the color images of the objects in her study, Vanderpoel establishes a 10×10 square grid, dividing all of the color in that object into individual units numbering to 100.  Then, somehow, she identifies the major colors and places them according to a system that I cannot understand within the grid.

    Blogvanderpoel_3059

    The net effect is glorious.  I just don’t know how she got there—which isn’t normally a consideration in art, except that this work is an instructional on how to understand color in art and nature, and the explanation of the procedure is ethereal.  Vanderpoel was and remains a respected author on porcelains and other applied and plastic arts.  In this work she looked at her fair share of porcelain, limogues, clay pots, burial urns, glass shards, and the like; she also analyzed clouds, mummy cloths (and casings), dew on morning grass, brocade, the eye of a blue jay, feathers, and another hundred or so poetic arragenments of the stuff of teh world.  I still do not know what this book is trying to tell me, but I do know that it is remarkable.   

    Blogvanderpoel_4060  

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • The Mathematical Garden—Alexander Pope and the Geometry of Natural Experience

    Blogdesirepope

    While sitting at the edge of a stream in a flowing dress and shading herself with a yellow parasol, my wife and  the jewel in the crown, the brilliant Patti Digh, wrote a superb essay on following the paths less marked. (Maybe I’m making up the parasol bit. And the stream. And flowing dress.) I’ve always been a happy observer of found geometries, and her essay heightened my awareness to them, along with the conscious efforts that we may daily make to enforce these lines or follow a new, multi-dimensional geometric path. 

    So when I stumbled across this map of Alexander Pope’s garden and noticed the odd paths  winding their way through it, and  how much in contrast this was to the very sniffy upper  crust English garden of the 18th century, Patti’s essay  lit instantly to mind—and also because in addition to being a geometer of emotion and thought she was in a past life a U VA English Master. 

    Pope’s garden was an irregular path in an irregular garden, that garden being his leased property at Twickenham, where he came to live in 1717, along with his mother and his boyhood nurse, Mary Beach, and his dog Bounce. 

    Pope’s garden was an irregular path in an irregular garden, that garden being his leased property at Twickenham, where he came to live in 1717, along with his mother and his boyhood nurse, Mary Beach, and his dog Bounce.  (Actually that would be a series of dogs as he named them all “Bounce”.)  Pope was a poet and satirist and
    critic and general taste-maker-the social influence extending even to garden-making, as his was famous even during his lifetime, and not for the reasons that most English gardens were famous.

    Blogdesiregeometrical_4

    His was not the planned regularity of the gentility (and far of course  from the suffocating, critically flawed gardens at places like Versailles,  “Is there anything more shocking than the regularity of a planned  garden?” asks Batty Langley in his New Principles of the Gardening… 1728), and were removed from the “normal”, more articulated garden.  I’ve never really understood the formal garden, especially as it relates  to the ancient analogies of gardens and paradise-the Garden of Eden, Pliny’s Garden of Venus, Lucretius’ Earthly Paradise, seem as though  they might be some sort of paradisical thing (though we won’t address  Bosch’s Garden of Earthly Delights) , but the formal gardens and its  paradise relationship seems odd, what with the removal of nature’s “chaos” and all, unless that was indeed the Master Plan.

    But the mathematical garden was a desirous thing—still is—and none  other than Christopher Wren wrote that it was “naturally more beautiful than any irregular figure” (1750).  There were some critics of the math garden, like Mr. Langley, but most garden  designers wrote and argued in favor of it, coming to the similar  conclusion of John Dennis, in that the Universe, being “regular in all its parts”  would dictate that its beauty be found as regular  in other things too,  “and it  is that exact regularity that [the mathematical garden] owes its admirable beauty” (1704). 
    Pope didn’t seem to address (in print) the garden idea formally except for a few places–  Pope praised ‘the amiable simplicity of unadorned Nature’ in a famous essay, published  in The Guardian in 1713, and then again in his message to Burlinton in 1731.

    Blogdesirepopedetail_3

    The plan of Pope’s garden was somewhat irregular, but to me the  most appealing aspect was  the irregularity of the paths that curled and snaked their way through the garden. 
    And particularly,  what about the lower part  of the path along the bottom of J. Serle’s 1725 engraving?  What was that path in Pope’s garden  leading to, or from?  Was there a particularly nice tree there, a  favorite spot, a cool shade, an odd bit of sunshine at sundown?  Or was this  wall-clinging path just the workman’s route? 

    Perhaps these weren’t Pope’s principal desire lines in the garden—in fact, the garden desire lines  weren’t the garden at all— they might’ve been under it.  Pope’s famous grotto at Twickenham  may be better known than his garden-it certainly sounds  much more interesting. Followed his  own desire line, underground, in his famous grotto, which he began to build shortly after arriving at  Twickenham, and which was still under construction at the time of his death. 

    The unseen desire lines of  Alexander Pope seem more fitting to me, more poetic, what with  Pope needing to dig out the earth in order to find what  he was looking for, rather than a more  simple wandering around his fine, rustic garden. 

    Have a look at the materials house in the grotto/cabinet of curiosity here, along with a  commendable plan of the grotto itself.

    Blogdesirecircular


  • Original Reflections: unique experiences with mirrors: Van Eyck & Brunellesci

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    I was thinking about writing a short post on van Eyck and settled on his painting of this newly married couple–The Arnolfini Marriage, painted in 1434, depicting the union of Giovanni Arnolfini and Giovanna Cenami, who married in Bruges in that year–and the very unusual image of the scene as reflected in the convex mirror directly behind the couple. It is a wonderful painting of course, lusciously and richly colored–the observer, though, is brought instantly to the mirror. And in that reflection is what is seen from behind the couple as well as what the couple is seeing–in a sense, a 180-degree view of the room (if we considered the painter’s perspective towards the couple as 90-degrees). It is one of the first times that a mirror is used in this fashion and is also offers a great instruction on the newly-rediscovered perspective. (The inscription above the mirror, which is surrounded by ten scenes from the life of Christ, reads “Jan van Eyck was present”–and probably was literal, as we see the painter himself reflected in a tiny portrait…along with another man, who may also have been involved with the wedding).

    Vna_eyck_mirror_big

    As a matter of fact, it is just 30 years earlier that Filippo di  Ser Brunellesci (1377-1446) used mirrors as a tool in “creating” the first paintings in linear perspective in modern times–and he uses the mirrors in such a way as to compare what he was seeing in front of him, rather than using them to gain a sight-line for things that he couldn’t see. But they did in a way do just that. Brunellesci set his position inside the unfinished Santa Maria del Fiore (Florence), and used the apparatus (pictured here from the linked website) to record the facade of San Giovanni de Firenze (better known by its subsequent name, the Florentine Baptitstry, as all Florentine Catholics
     were Baptized there well into the 19th century) which was opposite his position across the Piazza del Duomo. He effort was a panel which was finished between 1407 and 1410, and which is now lost to time and space.

    Van_eyck_mirror_2

    It should be noted that the Baptistry, an 8-sided figure (with another, triangular, form added later; and 8-sided to represent the octava dies, the “eighth day,” the day of the risen Christ, which would be outside the scope of time and measurement) was decorated with colossal, fantastically beautiful doors, some of which were created by none other than Ghiberti, another (slightly later) master of linear perspective.

    Van_eyek_brun

    (The image above is taken from the very useful site which goes into good detail about the Brunellesci pin/peephole experiment.)

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • The Solids in Uccello

    JF Ptak Science Books

    Blogsan_romano
    My ueber-brilliant wife, Patti Digh, has for decades been fascinated by the monstrous-great William Gaddis, and in particular, by his novel The Recognitions.  It is a difficult book to feel at home in—it took me four tries to feel comfortable in this complex wristbender, but once in, the water was fine, and I finished it during a boring and largely vacant astronomy meeting in Pittsburgh years ago.  It is perhaps one of the best books written by an American in the 20th century, and among the many threads that wind their way through the 950 pages, one involves
    the gorgeous 15th century painter, Paolo Uccello.   Uccello, in short, was one of the first Renaissance painters to (re)discover and paint using perspective, and did so magnificently.  Gaddis refers cryptically, however, to the “solids in Uccello”. 
    Dsc04733
    Books on perspective are some of the most beautifully illustrated works ever printed. They are full of insight and detail—a detail, the seeing of which, is a mystery (and to Uccello, mystical) beauty, a submerged, geological magnificence that is also an extraordinarily powerful tool.

    I wrote two posts or so ago about the importance of Leonardo’s illustrations to Pacioli’s work on perspective, and how this was really about the first time that geometrical figures were illustrated , published, for the first time, in perspective.  And of course the images were drop-dead gorgeous. 

    Vredeman de Vries (Perspectiva) was a 17th century Dutchman who is perhaps one of my favorites—shown here is his projection for an open loggia in which an illusionary ceiling could be painted (in the manner of Andrea Pozzo’s The Transmisson of the Divine Spirit (1688-1694) , an extraordinary painting of tremendous depth on the curved vault of S. Ignazzio in Rome).   (Another example of de Vries at bottom is a simple perspective of diverse architectural forms.) 

    Dsc04734 Wenzel Jamnitzer’s Perspectiva corporum regularium (1568) is a somewhat earlier work of great depth and beauty—this image is again just a “simple” arrangement of geometrical objects, but there’s really nothing very “simple” about it.  The forms are difficult and arranged in a difficult presentation, and rendering them in perspective was a great achievement, and I think a wonder for the mid-16thc mind to see. 

    Brook Taylor’s simple, clean lines and presentation of these architectural forms from his New Principles of Linear Perspective (2nd edition, London, 1719) is another perspective miracle of the 18th century.  To me the lines of perspective showing the view of the objections connected to the spare presentation of the objects themselves look completely modern to me rather than being a technical treatise from 289 years ago.Dsc04729 ,

    Uccello understood all of this, and painted using these techniques with enormous power.  The “solids’ recognized by Gaddis (and not really discussed) are incredible to me.  Looking at his painting Battle of San Romano  (1457) we see Perspective in her place; when we look at, say, the rumps of the horses, we see almost no detail, just a mass of color, a solid, with spectacular plainness. What in the world was he thinking?  He could certainly have painted the horse and the other solids with texture and detail, but he didn’t, and to me it seems antithetical to the painting.  What in the name of all motherly things was he thinking?  And who else on earth was using such huge amounts of plain solids in their paintings?  I’m not aware that anyone else was, and I am relatively clueless as to why he did it, abandoning Blogsan_romano_rump as it were the potentials of the beauty of excruciating detail that we see in these other works. 

    I would love to know what Uccello was thinking when he decided to create that mass of color, that solid, when there was no one else doing exactly that.  But my major thanks go to Patti Digh for loving that, and to Mr. Gaddis for creating the question.

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —