A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Militaria

  • A 117×1 Mile Blanket of Planes: What 185,000 Planes Looks Like

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 289

    1ebay_sept_30185000_planes695

    This arresting cover image for The Illustrated London News of 21 February 1942 illustrates the (new) American production program for planes and tanks for 1942 and 1943 (It reminds me too of an earlier post I did with a similar cover for LIFE magazine here.) The caption reads: “185,000 planes form a mile-wide blanket of bombers under a blanket of fighters stretching 117 miles” which is actually a double blanket of planes–if they were thinned out to form one layer it would stretch one mile wide from Washington D.C. to New York City, which is quite an unimaginable ribbon.

    1ebay_sept_30185000_planes_detail69

    The reality of the situation was greater than this:  by 1945 over 300,000 planes were produced, 275,000 of them after Pearl Harbor.  And this from a combined aviation industry which before 1939 had produced fewer than 6,000 planes a year.  The war effort increased this by orders of magnitude, and by war’s end there were 81 production facilities with a combined area of 175 million feet, all bumped up within four years.   I’ve never read about it, but I have no doubt that one of the key ingredients to this sort of hyper-successful undertaking was organization–the oversight and control for this process must’ve been fast and decisive, with little room for mid-level anything.  I think that this is the only way the whole thing could’ve worked so well. 


  • Visual Display of Quantitative Data: German Losses in the Battle of Britain

    JF Ptak Science Books Post 346  (This continues a thread on The Battle of Britain and also a post on “What 185,000 Planes Looks Like”). 

    This tremendous display is half of a double-page spread that appeared in The Illustrated London News for 7 September 1940.  It was meant to bolster the civilian population of Britain during the time of the German attacks, stating that “Over one thousand Nazi aircraft (were) brought down over Great Britain in …20 Days…” The artwork, drawn by Bryan de Grineau, actually depicts 1000 planes, and accurately-depicted ones at that.   What the graphic doesn’t tally though are the airmen losses, which would be considerably more than the 1000 aircraft:  for example, of the aircraft involved in the sustain air-invasion of England, the  Dornier 215’s had a crew of four, Dornier 17’s three, Heinkel 111’s four, Messerschmitt 110’s two, and Junkers 88’s three.  Thus  there were thousands more airmen lost, a commodity that the Nazis could little afford, more so as time went on.  
    00-blog--Oct 29 battle britain Nazi planes952 The results of the battle (and if you take a look at this earlier post for the full narrative), in terms of aircraft and humans,
    were,  for England: 1,023 fighters, 376 bombers, 148 coastal command aircraft  for a total of 1,547 aircraft and  544 pilots and aircrew killed.  During this time there were 27,450
    civilians killed and 32,138 wounded.  The Nazis lost 873 fighters and 1,014
    bombers for a total of 1,887 aircraft, with  2,500 aircrew killed.

    I find this visual display of quantitative data beautiful and compelling–and overwhelming in its way.

    The Battle of Britain was fought primarily from 10 July to 31 October 1940, so by the time this image was published the Brits had been able to withstand the tide of Hitler’s plans.  (The air strikes wouldn’t really end until the Nazis turned their attention to the Soviet Union in Operation Barbarossa in May 1941.)  One of those plans, named Luftschlacht um England, was to overtake and destroy the British capacity in the air, for as long as the English had command of the airspace there would be no way that the Nazis could force an invasion by sea/land (at least in the minds of the Oberkommando der Wehrmacht and Hitler.  With no air cover Britannia’s rule of the waves could be much more effectively challenged; and should that occur, what was seen as a not very probable invasion of Great Britain by a not very substantial Nazi naval force/transports might actually come to being. 

    This was a victory for HMG, though the rising tide for the Nazis would continue to do so through about November 1942, when after integral victories had been had that Churchill could declare at the Mayor’s Luncheon (10 November 1942): “Now this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. but it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning”. 


  • UPDATE: Dropping Boxes Filled With Soldiers: a Bad Technical Idea but a Great Strategic One, 1950

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  (added content to Post for 15 September)

    00-blog--Oct 29 dropping soldiers954
    I happened on this image from the front cover of Popular Science for November 1950 and recognized the idea instantly.  I posted on an earlier version of this idea from 1928 and placed it firmly in the BAD IDEAS Department of this blog.  The update from 1950 is a little improved, but, well, not by that much.  At least this canister leaves the clutches of the plane safely, though from the look of things it seems as though it might not want to land very nicely. 

    Blog-1-sept 15paratrooper553

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • Vegetius and the 4th Century Underwater Attack

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 342

    Blog--vegetius
    The name of Flavius Vegetius is not so much popularly known today, though his influence is felt through the hands of other, more famous, writers and thinkers.  He was seen as the most adept writer on the Roman mind in warfare, and his De re militari libri quator… was his masterpiece.  It was reprinted in 1532 by Christian Wechel from sources reaching back to the original, which was written around 390 ACE, and found a wide readership not only for its authority on all things military/Roman but also for his iconic insights and aphorisms on warfare in general.  It was Machiavelli who came under his spell and who adopted some of Vegetius, who became further disseminated through the military followers of Machiavelli, and so on.

    I came to this work much more simply than all of this – I liked this image of the underwater warrior, who was somehow able to breathe while submerged.  I get the importance of this sort of undercover, guerilla maneuver, but what I really like was the rarity of seeing a Renaissance illustration of human submarine life, which is pretty uncommon.  Also, the use of the lines to represent the underwater quality of the image—giving the woodcut an overall grey tone—is also very scarce in the history of illustration, at least before 1600.  And very neat!  One of the hallmarks of this printing of Vegetius was the liberal use of white space in many of the (119) woodcut illustrations, though it is clearly not on display in the woodcut that I’m sharing here.
    00-blog-Oct 28 vegetius939

    Of further interest are the following excerpts of Vegetius from the 1767 English translation found at the Digital Attic website. I’ve selected four interesting bits on the selection of recruits, their initial training, the size of recruits and the need of the new soldiers to learn how to swim.  I find them a fascinating insight into the appreciation of the raw military recruit from 1600 years ago. 

    The Military Institutions of the Romans (De Re Militari)

    By Flavius Vegetius Renatus

    INITIAL TRAINING

    The first thing the soldiers are to be taught is the military step, which can only be acquired by constant practice of marching quick and together. Nor is anything of more consequence either on the march or in the line than that they should keep their ranks with the greatest exactness. For troops who march in an irregular and disorderly manner are always in great danger of being defeated. They should march with the common military step twenty miles in five summer-hours, and with the full step, which is quicker, twenty-four miles in the same number of hours. If they exceed this pace, they no longer march but run, and no certain rate can be assigned.
    But the young recruits in particular must be exercised in running, in order to charge the enemy with great vigor; occupy, on occasion, an advantageous post with greater expedition, and prevent the enemy in their designs upon the same; that they may, when sent to reconnoiter, advance with speed, return with greater celerity and more easily come up with the enemy in a pursuit.


  • Blank and Disappeared Things Department: Confederate Oath of Allegiance and Loyalty

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC Post 338

    Blog--blank--confeder oath
    The hundreds of thousands of soldiers who found themselves in Confederate homespun after years of fighting against “those people” of General Lee were offered a clemency at the end of the war by Abraham Lincoln.  Or rather it was the idea of Lincoln’s that survived the war as Lincoln didn’t.  

    Actually the idea of amnesty was granted as a presidential power via the Confiscation Act of 1862, which authorized the president of the United States to pardon anyone involved in the rebellion. This was done at a time when the outcome of the war was still nebulous and far from being decided, as Lincoln was suffering a crisis in his cabinet as well as on battlefields throughout the run of the nation.  This act was followed by the Amnesty Proclamation of 8 December 1863, which basically extended a pardon to anyone who was not a war criminal, was an officer, and who would sign an oath of allegiance.  This was followed by another proclamation in 1864 extending the privilege to Southern civilians as well.  And the sentiments were extended past Lincoln’s murder via the otherwise occupied third-worst president, resulting on 25 December 1865 with the unconditional pardon to all Civil War vets except for the high-ranking and monied officers—this is something that Johnson got absolutely right, and so right, as a matter of fact that even more liberally-minded northerners thought he was giving away the store.  Johnson didn’t follow his own deepest thoughts and dark angels on this issue, either:  right after becoming president (the first VP to ascend to the office during an active administration) in April, 1865 he was noted telling an Indiana delegation that, “Treason must be made odious… traitors must be punished and impoverished … their social power must be destroyed.”

    Within weeks his policy line had softened if not his reasoning than at least his rhetoric and action:  “I say, as to the leaders, punishment. I also say leniency, reconciliation and amnesty to the thousands whom they have misled and deceived.  These actions alienated many on all sides, but it was probably the highlight of his troubled four years or so in office, and more than likely was the only thing he got right in the Reconstruction policies through 1869. (I’d say that his allowance of the creation of Black Codes and the codification of sub-citizenship to the newly-freed slaves that created a still subjugated interior-nation for black people created more havoc and pain and discord than anything else anyone did in government in the immediate post-war period.)

    So as part of the series of blank and empty things I’d like to include this unused oath of allegiance certificate.  There were perhaps hundreds of thousands of these sorts of bills-of-freedom distributed to Confederate veterans, who–whether they agreed or not, believed or not–filled them up with their information and pledged to be true to the Union, if for no other reason than to put the war as much behind them as possible and return to what might have been their lives.  I’ve also included three examples (relating to the same person) of filled-out pledges (at bottom).

    NOTES:

    The following first section is an appraisal and summation of the amnesty program appearing in Harper’s Weekly for May 15 1865:

    PRESIDENT LINCOLN’S AMNESTY.
    By his proclamation of the 8th of December, 1863, President LINCOLN granted a full pardon —with certain exceptions which we will presently state—to all who had been in rebellion, with a full restoration of all rights of property except in slaves and in cases where the rights of third parties had intervened, and upon condition of taking and subscribing and keeping in-violate an oath to support and defend the Constitution and the Union under it, and to abide faithfully by all the laws of Congress, and by the proclamations of the President in regard to slaves, so far as they are not repealed or declared void by the Supreme Court.
    The persons excepted from this amnesty were all who are or have been civil or diplomatic officers and agents of the rebel Government—all who have left judicial stations under the United States to aid the rebellion—all who are or have been military and naval officers above the rank of colonel in the army or lieutenant in the navy —all who left seats in the United States Congress, or resigned commissions in its army or navy, and afterward aided the rebellion—and all who have treated colored or white soldiers and sailors of the United States otherwise than as prisoners of war.

    On the 26th of March, 1864, President LINCOLN by proclamation defined that the amnesty was limited to those who were not prisoners of war, but who, being free from any arrest, voluntarily took the oath.
    On the 6th of December, 1864, in his last annual Message to Congress, the President said that when he issued the amnesty he stated that the excepted classes might still be within special clemency. ” During the year,” he continued, “many availed themselves of the general provision, and many more would, only that the signs of bad faith in some” led to precautions. Special pardons had also been granted to persons of the excepted classes. ” The door has been for a full year open to all.” But he adds, ” The time may come, probably will come, when public duty shall demand that it be closed, and that, in lieu, more rigorous measures than heretofore shall be adopted

    NOTES, Part II:

    Blog--empty--oath filled out

    Image 1
    UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

    I, W.C. Harris of the County of Mobile, State of Alabama, do solemnly swear
    that I will protect and defend the Constitution and Government of the United
    States against all enemies, whether domestic or foreign; that I will bear
    true faith, allegiance, and loyalty to the same, any ordinance, resolution
    or laws of any State, Convention, or Legislature, to the contrary
    notwithstanding; and further, that I will faithfully perform all the duties
    which may be required of me by the laws of the United States; and I take
    this oath freely and voluntarily, without any mental reservation or evasion
    whatever.

    W.C.Harris

    Sunscribed and sworn to before me, this 27th day of June A.D. 1865
    A.G. Brady
    Maj. and Provost Marshall
    The above-named has light complexion, Black hair, and Blue eyes; and is 5
    feet 9 1/2 inches high.

    Image 2
    CERIFICATE OF RELEASE OF PRISONER OF WAR
    Head Quarters, Point Lookout, Md.
    Provost Marshal’s Office  June 27, 1865

    I hereby certify, that W.C. Harris , prisoner of war, having this day taken
    the Oath of Allegiance to the United States is in conformity with the
    instructions from the War Department, hereby released and discharged.

    In Witness whereof, I hereunto affix my official signature and stamp.

    A.G.Brady,
    Maj. and Provost Marshal

    Image 3
    OATH AND PAROLE

    I do solemnly swear, in presence of Almight God, that I will henceforth
    faithfully support, protect and defend the Constitution of the United
    States, and the Union of the States thereunder; and that I will in like
    manner abide by and faithfully support all acts of the Congress passed
    during the existing rebellion with reference to slaves, so long and so far
    as not repealed, modified or held void by Congress, or by decision of the
    Supreme Court; and that I will in like manner abide by and faithfully
    support all proclaimations of the President made during the existing
    rebellion, having reference to slaves, so long and so far as not modified or
    declared void by decision of the Supreme Court,— So help me God; and I
    give my solemn parole of honor (to be enforced according to military law,)
    that I will hold no correspondence with, or afford any aid or comfort to any
    enemies or opposers of the United States, save as an act of humanity, to
    administer to the necessities of individuals, who are in sickness or
    distress; and I solemnly declare that this Oath and Parole is taken and
    given freely and willingly, without any mental reservation or evasion
    whatever, and with full intention to keep the same.


  • Duelling a Female Privateer at the Battle of the Mixed Yellow Mustard; Yazoo Pass, 1863

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC Post 331

    Harry Stoneman, the commander of the U.S. naval vessel, the Gun Boat  Snake-Head, reported a battle in this broadside (found in the collection of the Library of Congress) fought between himself and a “female privateer” at the foggy Yazoo Pass in 1863.

    Blog--Snake HEad female pirate det

    I have little doubt that the battle was probably ferocious, but I do have some lingering doubt that it was more ferocious than the reporting of it.  There is much in Stoneman’s prose to suggest whistling canon balls and smoke and boardings and sinkings and such, but I have a feeling there was much fumbling between the wo ships, and that in the end, the “female privateer” surrendered.  Stoneman overtook the vessel and got so close to it that he rammed it somewhat, somehow getting  the end of his “Long Tom” into the forward port hole of the privateer.  After he repaired whatever he did to his canon (the “Long Tom” being in general the largest gun on the ship or boat, and probably mounted on a swivel or pivot, forward) fired it into the privateer, “filling up her cockpit with disabled Semen [sic]”.  There was an explosion of some sort with the privateers can–it either was fired or exploded–with the only resulting injury being to some (mixed) yellow mustard.

    Blog--Snake HEad female pirate det yellow

    But in the end all went well for the sweatty Harry Stoneman, taking the copper-bottomed enemy ship as a prize, and hustling back to whatever writing surface he had to record his victory and present it as a prize to the commodore Perrick  of the Mississippi floatilla.  Unfortunately I cannot find anything at all on the Snake-Head or Stoneman or for that matter Commodore Perrick (which is odd).  But most of all a quick search isn’t revealing anything on the most beguiling aspect of this whole story, the “female privateer”. 

    You can click on the image for a more readable version of the broadside; also, the full text of the broadside is provided below, thanks again to a terribly industrious library employee.)

    Blog--Snake HEad female pirate

    VICTORY! VICTORY! VICTORY.

    “Terrific Attack on a Private Gunboat!“

    Official Report from Capt. Stoneman, Gun-Boat “Snake-Head.”

    Yazoo Pass, Miss. March 4th, 1863.

    Sir:

    I beg to report a most terrific engagement with a female privateer,
    which happened three miles below here, on the night of the 1st inst.
    The conflict, for about half an hour, was one of great fierceness, but
    most luckily for our side no one was hurt.

    About nine o’clock on the night of the 1st inst., as I was feeling
    my way up the Yazoo, and when opposite a dense swamp, I discovered a
    mysterious craft but a very short distance ahead of me, which I soon
    discovered to be a female privateer. Putting on a full head of steam, I
    soon overhauled the craft, and finding it necessary to bring her too, I
    immediately ran out my “Long Tom,” and so close were we by this time,
    that my “Long Tom,” ran into her bow Port Hole at least six inches. I
    will here state that this craft had only two Port Holes, one in the bow
    for a Long Gun, and one in the stern for bombarding. Finding it
    impossible to become disconnected from the enemy, I soon fired the
    contents of my “Long Tom” into her bow Port Hole, which filled her cockpit with disabled Semen.— This caused her to press hard against my starboard, and for a time I had to haul off.

    The last attack soon became general, and we fired load for load,
    until we both exhausted our ammunition. If any thing gives me pain, it
    is that I am forced to say, my “Long Tom” was most awfully disabled
    during this brief engagement. Seeing my enemy lying there in a
    tempting, saucy manner, I made sundry repairs to my “Long Tom,” such as
    repairing the breach, by strengthening the parts by a solution of
    starch and water, and from the appearance of the Gun Carriage, I
    concluded to resume active operations; I at once double-charged my
    “Long Tom,” and all being ready I was soon along side of her again, as
    keen as ever. I commenced the attack with great fierceness, being
    determined to open her about water-mark, if possible; at the first
    charge my “Long Tom” went home, and two balls struck her in the stern.
    I fired until I thought I had torn both of her Port Holes into one,
    when all at once her stern gun” exploded with a terrific crash,
    and almost lifted me out of the water. I was greatly excited, for we
    had got to close quarters, and on examination I found the enemy had
    sprung a leak, but yet she did not appear to be in a sinking condition.
    The scene now was truly sublime. There we lay, like two cocks silently
    contemplating each other, and each undetermined whether to renew the
    attack, but finding my “Long Tom” again in a bad condition for renewal
    of the attack, I hauled off to repair, and, if possible, ascertain the
    damage done by my “Long Tom” to this mysterious cruiser; and I soon
    discovered her damage to be very slight. The only real damage appearing
    to be an enlargement of her bow Port Hele, where my “Long Tom” had
    entered. Her stern was apparently uninjured, but in a dirty condition,
    the explosion having knocked the head out of a barrel of Mixed Yellow
    Mustard.

    Finding it impossible to make her escape from the range of my “Long
    Tom,” she surrendered, and I must confess she is a valuable prize,
    being full rigged and copper-bottomed, and being of good stuff, I would
    recommend her as your Flag ship of this squadron. She being
    copper-built, it will take the untiring efforts of her commander to
    keep her in trim. The two balls that struck her, struck just between
    wind and water, but she stood the shock nobly, and did not give an inch.

    Trusting this report may be perfectly satisfactory, and hoping ere
    long I may be able to capture another such prize, merely to keep my
    “Long Tom” in practice.

    I remain, Respectfully Yours,

    HARRY STONEMAN,

    Capt. Gun-Boat “Snake-Head.”

    To

    COMMODORE PERRICK,

    Mississippi Flotilla

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • The Department of What Things Look Like: the Casualties of the Somme, Visualized

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 323

    00blogoct_16crowds865_2I wanted to return to a post for a few days ago on what victory looks
    like in relation to the sub-war/Battle of the Somme in 1916,tying to
    relate the staggering proportions of the 1.5 million casualties from
    that action to a photograph of a group of people.  This is not terribly
    easy to do, especially without using images that are iconic standards
    of “large crowds”, or even images that can be image-googled. I have
    found two interesting images, though—one real, and the other, well, the
    other one I made.  (This is the only image of the 1200 images that I
    have posted to this site that I have altered or created, just for the
    record,)

    The first image comes from the Illustrierte Zeitung (Leipzig),
    for October 1910.  It presumably shows the 12,000 employees emerging
    from the factory of Continental Pneumatic Tires, only I make the crowd
    out to be more like 40-50,000  That means that the casualties of the
    Somme would be thirty (30) of these crowd scenes, end-to-end.  30.

    00blogoct_16crowds866

    The next image is a montaged photo, a photo of hats, taken about 12
    feet off the ground or so, but a sea of hats that attaches faces to the
    hats, unlike the sea of hats in the image above it.  This is a sea of
    faces, giving a better sense of humanity to the sea of bodies.  There
    are perhaps 500 people in this photo, meaning you’d need 300 of them to
    illustrate the Somme casualties.

    It all still pales in comparison to the actual numbers.  Victory still looks not so victorious.


  • The History of Images of Aerial Bombing–First Images

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 322

    I had written out a good, chunky post on the history of the images of aerial bombing; wrote it all down in my little notebook down at Tybee Island, and then promptly hopped into the hot tub fully clothed (for the benefit of our five-year old Tessie) and stayed there for a half-hour, with my notebook still in my pocket.  Of course once the thing sort of dried out all of the notes were just one blue stain, an Andy Warhol post.  I just can’t do the whole thing over again, but I can post about the one odd bit that was in there.  And it is this (very) minor bit that escaped Sven Lindqvist’s attention in his glorious A History of Bombing (printed in 2000 by The New Press), a book that is a chrono-intellectual historico-philosophical treatment of aerial bombing in general.

    1blog_oc_t11_robur810

    One of the earliest illustrations of bombing from an airship (at left) occurs in the incomparable Jules Verne’s Roburs the Conquerer (also known as The Flight of Engineer Roburs) in 1886.  It turns out that this floating monstrosity (the Goahead) made its way slowly over Paris, illuminating the city with powerful lights, in a helpful, positive way; on the other hand, it confronts “dark criminals” with bullets, mowing them down.  Oddly enough, the book’s opening two words are “Bang Bang”.

    1blog_oc_t11_anti_ac813

    This may well be the first anti-aircraft (and anti-bomber) image ever printed  in England–it comes from The Illustrated London News for 16 December 1911, just six weeks after this same magazine printed the first image of an aircraft dropping a bomb on a military target. (And it seems originally to have been first published weeks earlier in the U.S in the Scientific American.)  “Airman-shooting with Springfield Rifle; Aerial Gun Practice on a United States Battle-Ship” is the sub title to “Sniping the Bomb-Dropper:  Firing at Kite-Suspended Targets” .  The kites carried the targets up to a height of about 300 feet, and the navy let loose with “one-pounders and three-pounders” as well as rifles (?!) The text to the print continues the story: “The Springfield rifle…will afford no inconsiderable defense against any aeroplane that might attempt to execute feats of ‘bomb-dropping’.” I don’t know about that, though it may have been true that this 30-caliber weapon with a muzzle velocity of 2700’/sec might’ve done some damage to a 1911 aircraft….I guess they could have tracked it too, what with the plane moving 75 miles an hour or so.

    It was just a few years earlier that in this same journal (for 4 August 1907) that the possibility of the air-ship being an instrument of peace was discussed.  It seems that this “peace” would come about in a sort-of MAD (mutually assured destruction) kind of way, stumbling its way to peace because of the difficulty in defining the terms of war–rather than obtaining a stalemate by the endgame of obliteration via inconceivable amounts of instantaneously-released energy, these folks thought that peace/stasis might come about simply because they weren’t able to fully outlaw reckless bombing because they couldn’t come to terms with what an “airship” actually *was*.    Bombing by airship was outlawed at the Hague Conference of 1899, and in 1907 it was argued that a five-year extension of that treaty should be enacted–again, mainly due to the ungentlemanly ungainliness of what it meant exactly to drop bombs from the air and what aspects of that action were illegitimate. 

    All sides would get over the definition issues pretty quickly, as 1912 comes up just a little short of the guns of November two years hence.  After all, we can’t have ill-defined terms in communication, can we?

    1blog_oct_13marconi_at_sea818


  • Food Bomb, 1942

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 285

    1ebay_sept_30food_bomb694 In an earlier post (The Most LIterary Fireworks Catalog Ever Published?  The Naming of Explosions) I wrote a little bit about names found on shells and the naming of explosions.  The chances for adding to this category are slim, given the ephemeral nature of the item of discussion–I did however stumble upon this Food Bomb, found in the 25 April 1942 issue of The Illustrated London News.  “Guten Hunger”, the inscription on this “bomb”  (basically “good appetite” or “eat well” or “down the hatch”) was actually “not a weapon of destruction, but an enormous food container” that was going to be dropped on the German soldiers on some slender part of the Eastern Front.  In April the situation was turning now away for the Germans with the Soviet counter offensive, and it was still cold. Something like 3 million German soldiers would be awarded the service medal for the Winterschlacht im Osten 1941/42–not many of them would get to look at it after 1945.   The campaign in the east against their former allies started on 7 June 1941 (and named variously die Ostfront 1941-1945, der Rußlandfeldzug 1941-1945 (Russian campaign) or der Ostfeldzug 1941-1945 (Eastern Campaign)) and lasted to mid-May, 1945, when the campaign line shrunk from as far away as Moscow back down to east Berlin. 

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • The Propaganda of Restricting Infomration: Dorothea Lange’s Photos at the Japanese “Relocation” Camp, Manzanar, 1942

    JF Ptak Science Books Post 283

    Takenjap_poster After having written a number of pots dealing with overt propaganda issues—surrender leaflets, Nazi pamphlets on the impending invasion of Germany by Poland and Czechoslovakia, American reassurances about how to survive the coming nuclear holocaust by covering yourself with table linen, British home hearts and minds campaign about how well your loved one POWs are being treated by the Germans—I thought to write a little something on the other side of propaganda, which is simply to not publish information.  One case is that of the great social photographer and one of the dozen or so mainstays of perhaps the greatest American photographic collaborative ever—Historical Section of the Farm Security administrations*–Dorothea Lange.  Lange worked for the FSA—which had begun life as the ominously-named  Resettlement Administration, the photographic section of which was to document the good that the government was doing helping the drought and depression refugees find new life and hope elsewhere in the country outside of their own money-ravaged areas—taking mostly landscape and architectural pictures through the height of the Depression.  The time that she broke character (so to speak) and made portraits produced some of the most memorable or at least famous images from this period o American history, the most outstanding of which is the five-photo series of a female bean picker and her three children who were living out of the back of their wheel-less car in a potato-less potato field in California known as the Migrant Mother.  (The making of these extraordinary images is another story for another post—suffice to say that the narrative of the history of that photograph is exceptional.)  I’ve always felt that the Roosevelt administration viewed this image as being just a little too much reality than it wanted to exhibit.

    Blogmigrant_mother

     

    This was positively the case with Lange’s photographs of the Japanese at the Manzanar concentration camp (relocation camp) in   where more than 10,000 American citizens of Japanese heritage were forced to live between 1942 and 1945.  This was one of  camps that were established by virtue  Franklin Roosevelt’s  February 1942 Executive Order 9066** to imprison more than 100,000 American (70,000 of whom were U.S. citizens, including children) for the duration of the war (compared to a  few camps that were designated to hold white American citizen of the other countries that were fighting, mainly of German and Italian descent, 1,500 and 300 of whom were actually imprisoned, respectively). It was a grave, undistinguished, embarrassing  move brought on by the hyper hysteria in the months following Pearl Harbor.

     
    The Japanese at the Manzanar concentration camp were from the west coast who were bused away from their homes and lives and businesses with extremely limited notice, and who were forced to sell nearly all possessions (including lands and businesses) at what were less than fire sale prices.  They were made to board buses and trains and were shipped to locations (mainly in California) where they were processed and sent further and deeper into the trying hinterlands of the west for their final destinations until the war was won.  (One of the processing centers was the Santa Anita racetrack, where thousands of Japanese were sent to live for periods in converted, just-painted horse stalls.)  Manzanar itself is well enough out there—removed, trying, desolate, difficult.  Beautiful, too , if you weren’t in prison there.  It was a high desert plateau with the snow-capped sierras, ringing the place; no grass, barely a tree, with extreme temperatures and a tough wind that was freezing in the winter and blew hot in the summer…tough enough to make it hard to keep the tar paper on the roof and sides of the thinly constructed barracks that held these people.  While every other relocation camp had barbed wire and guard towers, Manzanar had none—its location was so remote and difficult that it made the construction of these inferior barriers unnecessary. 

    ManzanarlangeslauteManzanarlangeposter

    As difficult was life was at Manzanar, and having being completely torn off of the American map and their way of life, the Japanese at the camp established irrigation systems and gardens, made their own furniture from bits and scraps, established a newspaper, created a government,  schools, police, and so on, making their life as orderly and hospitable as possible.  Dorothea Lange was allowed, after repeated requests to the US Army, to enter the facility and make a photographic record of what she saw.  And what she saw and photographed was the courage and dignity of the people that she find there in the mists of deprivation and devastation—her photos were remarkable for their sincerity and insight.

    And it was for precisely this reason that almost know of them were ever seen.  Bits and piece emerged here and there—four in Survey Graphic in 1942 (Vol. 31, No. 9, Sept. 1942), two others here, two others there—but they were almost entirely restricted.  As a matter of fact they were stamped “Impounded”, and relegated to the future.

    The FSA became the Office of War Information in 1942 as well, which might explain why this propagandistic move dismissing their existence for want of fairer reception of the American war effort at home..  It wasn’t until 1972 that 27 more of them were released and received a public showing at the Whitney in NYC in a show called Executive Order 9066, and which were reviewed in the NY Times by A.D. Coleman as  “documents of such a high order that they convey the feelings of the victims as well as the facts of the crime.”

    Lange wasn’t the only big-name photographer zipping around Manzanar–Ansel Adams was there, too, as a friend of the camp administrator.  Adams had free access to the camp, and could basically come and go as he pleased, which didn’t sit well with Lange, who had a hard go of her permissions with the Army.  It was also something that she never let go of, either, as the Adams photos really didn’t get into the Being of the place like Lange’s did.  Actually, one of the great, iconic images made by Adams comes from this period, and as it turns out, its one of those odd sorts of photos that turns in the opposite direction of what the photographer was there “for”.  Mount Williamson is just a drop-dead shot to be sure.  It is also an image of what the Japanese in the concentration camp were looking out at.  Adams turns his camera around, around from the disgrace, and takes one of his greatest images. (I’ve listened to my wife Patti Digh, who is an (excellent) photographer, talk about photographers “making” photographs; I’m sure that before her I used “taking” and “making” photographs interchangeably.  But “making” it should be, as you’re not owning or lifting the image away.)   In this case, however, as monumental as Adams was or is, he definitely “took” this one.  Stole it. 

     An excellent book on these photos is found in Linda Gordon and Gary Okihiro, Impounded, Dorothea Lange and the Censored Images of Japanese American Internment (W.W. Norton, 2006). 

     Blogadams_manzanar

     

    *This incredible group included: Arthur Rothstein, Carl Mydans (up to the summer of 1936), Walker Evans (up to September 1937) Ben Shahn, Dorothea Lange (with interruptions up to 1942). Russell Lee, Marion Post Wolcott, John Vachon, Jack Delano, John Collier. This group produced upwards of 270,000 negatives, with 77,000 or so prints available at the Prints and Photographs room of the Library of Congress in a row of double-backed file cabinets.  Many thousands are available online at loc.gov  I am told by a reliable historian that I am wrong in thinking that Lange was fired because of her too-intolerably human photos, but for budgetary problems. 
    .
    **The following is the text of 9066, which basically authorized a 60-mile swath of the Pacific Coast as a military zone subject to national defense requirements, the principal object of which was to remove all Japanese residents from the area for fear of them being enemy agents and saboteurs.  To accompany this I mad a WORDLE text map of the document, just to see what popped up. 

    Wordleexecutive_9066 Executive Order No. 9066
    The President, Executive Order
    Authorizing the Secretary of War to Prescribe Military Areas

    Whereas the successful prosecution of the war requires every possible protection against espionage and against sabotage to national-defense material, national-defense premises, and national-defense utilities as defined in Section 4, Act of April 20, 1918, 40 Stat. 533, as amended by the Act of November 30, 1940, 54 Stat. 1220, and the Act of August 21, 1941, 55 Stat. 655 (U.S.C., Title 50, Sec. 104);

    Now, therefore, by virtue of the authority vested in me as President of the United States, and Commander in Chief of the Army and Navy, I hereby authorize and direct the Secretary of War, and the Military Commanders whom he may from time to time designate, whenever he or any designated Commander deems such action necessary or desirable, to prescribe military areas in such places and of such extent as he or the appropriate Military Commander may determine, from which any or all persons may be excluded, and with respect to which, the right of any person to enter, remain in, or leave shall be subject to whatever restrictions the Secretary of War or the appropriate Military Commander may impose in his discretion. The Secretary of War is hereby authorized to provide for residents of any such area who are excluded there from, such transportation, food, shelter, and other accommodations as may be necessary, in the judgment of the Secretary of War or the said Military Commander, and until other arrangements are made, to accomplish the purpose of this order. The designation of military areas in any region or locality shall supersede designations of prohibited and restricted areas by the Attorney General under the Proclamations of December 7 and 8, 1941, and shall supersede the responsibility and authority of the Attorney General under the said Proclamations in respect of such prohibited and restricted areas.

    I hereby further authorize and direct the Secretary of War and the said Military Commanders to take such other steps as he or the appropriate Military Commander may deem advisable to enforce compliance with the restrictions applicable to each Military area hereinabove authorized to be designated, including the use of Federal troops and other Federal Agencies, with authority to accept assistance of state and local agencies.
    I hereby further authorize and direct all Executive Departments, independent establishments and other Federal Agencies, to assist the Secretary of War or the said Military Commanders in carrying out this Executive Order, including the furnishing of medical aid, hospitalization, food, clothing, transportation, use of land, shelter, and other supplies, equipment, utilities, facilities, and services.

    This order shall not be construed as modifying or limiting in any way the authority heretofore granted under Executive Order No. 8972, dated December 12, 1941, nor shall it be construed as limiting or modifying the duty and responsibility of the Federal Bureau of Investigation, with respect to the investigation of alleged acts of sabotage or the duty and responsibility of the Attorney General and the Department of Justice under the Proclamations of December 7 and 8, 1941, prescribing regulations for the conduct and control of alien enemies, except as such duty and responsibility is superseded by the designation of military areas hereunder.

    Franklin D. Roosevelt
    The White House,
    February 19, 1942.

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —