A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: Militaria

  • A Pie Line and Sugar Angel, 1918: U.S. Troops in Paris

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 431

    0 ebay 16 pie line280

    There’s definitely an angelic figure in this photograph, an image  made showing American Doughboys lining up in front of a bakery/candy store (high-sugar delivery transport systems enhancer) in Paris in 1918.  This photograph is a News Photo Service item, produced by the Western Newspaper Union, which would send photographs (and their captions) on demand  to newspapers and magazines requesting a scene, say, of American soldiers waiting patiently in line for apple pie at a Parisian bakery.  The caption says that “America’s sons (were) grouped about the store waiting for doors to open” so that they could have at the apple pie. They are waiting for something, to be sure; it doesn’t seem quite right that a bakery would not be open during daylight hours (though the shutters on the upper floors are closed still) in the winter (I see snow), but then again I’m not an expert on the hours kept by small business in Paris during WWI. 

    I am taken with the figure of the small girl in the windowed-door of the bakery, standing there with her hands clasped, framed by the window pane, dressed in flowing white.  Is the place really closed, or did the soldiers simply have no money for these treats, the little girl standing there in the unlocked doorway wondering why all of these soldiers just don’t come inside?  Were the men paid in scrip with no value in the streets of the
    city?  The good news is that these men were alive, and it may have been
    November or December of 1918, which means that the killing of millions
    and millions of soldiers and civilians had just about come to an end,
    so they could probably stay living,  safely making their idle if not
    penniless way around the snowy streets of Paris, wanting and waiting to
    go home.

    0 ebay 16 pie line281


  • The Bombing of Britain, 1942: Visual Display of Quantitative Data

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 424

    This chart, appearing in The Illustrated London News for 19 December 1942 is in part a righteous propaganda effort, a response to a criticism evidently boiling in the United States about a “failing” in the British effort to prosecute the war.  Honestly, I was not aware of this sentiment being hosted in the U.S. in the winter of ’42.  The text accompanying this chart explains that the misunderstanding of perception is partly due to British “reticence” concerning their achievements and “an [American] opinion based on ignorance of the true situation”. 
    00-blog-Oct 27Britain 1942 graphic934

    This chart was actually a publication that was distributed “throughout the United States” to alter the public opinion there and to show “in tabular form something of the achievements–and sufferings–of Britain during three years of war.  “Those cold figures barely hint at the three years of fighting sacrifice which the British people have devoted to smashing the Axis.”

    There are some truly extraordinary figures here:  for example, in September 1940 there were 4.2 million men (and no women)  registered for national service; by September 1942 the number of men more than doubled, and there were 8.5 million women now registered. Unemployment sunk to 108k  in Sept ’42 from 1 million in Sept ’39. War damage (which I’m guessing was in the London area) is listed at 20% of all houses (!?); war deaths from the Battle of Britain and the V-1 raids fell from 42k killed and 48k wounded in the year ending Aug ’41 to 2k killed and wounded in the year  ending June ’42 (showing extreme hardship, sacrifice and progress). 

    Overall the rest of the stats speak for themselves, and I was a little surprised that the British government found it necessary to launch a propaganda effort in the U.S. a year after Pearl Harbor.  Eleanor Roosevelt said just before this brochure was issued, Britain has given ten times what we have given, because people there know what it means to be without.  There is much more equality of sacrifice in Britain than in this country”.  The article finishes: “A more forceful propaganda directed from Britain to the United States and a few more Americans speaking their minds as Mrs. Roosevelt spoke hers, would go a long way–perhaps the whole way–towards removing a possible cause of misunderstanding between the two great nations”. 


  • Bags, and Lots of Them: U.S. Navy Inspection, San Diego, 1935

    JF Ptak Science Books   Post 414

    0--ebay---dec 4 bag inspewction178

    This wonderful image is found in California and the Navy, a souvenir of America’s Exposition in San Diego for 1935.  I liked the long lines of white and the displayed sea bags.  As it turns out there are only about 200 sailors in this picture, the near horizon then being about, say, 1800 feet in the distance.  The bags, I must say, are lined up remarkably straight.

    The U.S. Naval Base in San Diego–the largest in the country nowadays–would be exceptionally busy in just eight short years from the time of this picture.  By the end of the war, in addition to all of the servicing of the American naval needs, this naval base serviced something on the order of 5,000 ships.  The story of the San Diego Naval Base during WWII was nothing short of remarkable

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • Our Kind of Reader: a Library in the Fields of War, 1918

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 412

    “Tel fruit porte l’arbe de la guerre.”  Charles the Bold, (“Such are the fruits of war”, observing the town of Montdidier set ablaze by the Burgundians in 1472.

    This photograph, taken near the French town of Montdider in October 1918, reminded me straight away of a photo that my friend Andy Moursund had hanging for many years in his store, the Georgetown Bookshop (for many years one of the most literate, most-intelligently-stocked used/rare bookshops in the DC and Maryland region). Andy’s photo was of the interior of a British library, its roof lost to a Nazi V-2, with stacks of books in a smokey rubble, and with several men standing and reading atop the charred ruins.  His caption for it was “Our Kind of Reader”.  A voracious and terrific reader with tremendous insight, Andy (a Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee vet (SNCC, perhaps the leading student civil rights organizations in the 1960’s)) really, truly meant and felt the sentiment.  (Or means its and feels it, I should say.)  and here I am surprised to see something similar–let

    0--ebay---dec 5 books185 me just say that images such as these were not very commonly made or published. Different war, same sentiment. 

    This time though the location of the books is outdoors and in France.  the books were looted by the “Huns” as the caption says, and taken from the library at Montdidier.  This is one of the many towns that suffered greatly during the First World War, and especially so during the first Battle of the Somme in 1916, and then again in the battle of Noyan-Mntdidier, in 1918.

    Montdidier is very old and has been deeply scarred by wars over the last 1200 years.  The town’s name comes from the Didier, who as King of the Franks was imprisoned in this community in 774, soon to celebrate the 1,235th anniversary of the event. And on and on.

    I’d be curious to know what was in those piles under the heavy sacking, and how many of those piles there were–we can see the beginning of another just to the left.  I don’t see any thin volumes of whispy poetry or skinny wanting limpnovels. Most of them look pretty stout, three of them together seemingly as big as the soldier’s head.  I am relieved to see that the books were raised off the ground on their pallets–there was a war going on and all of that, but someone took the time and effort to get the books up and off of the ground.  That’s my kind of reader.

    I should point out that this was a News Service Photograph, this one supplied by Underwood & Underwood.  The photo would be sent to newspapers/magazines that requested, say, a photo of a soldier reading; U&U would send it on along for publication, along with mandatory caption. 


  • A Wartime Census of War Dogs: Verdun, 1916

    JF Ptak Science Books Post 405

    0--blog---dec 2 dog census172

    I wonder what the French officer sitting behind the table at the center background thought about at night, after his day was done.  I wonder what it was that went through his head, his eyes fluttering, as he slipped into sleep?  As the accompanying caption of this photo states, this was a census of dogs, a census of army dogs in the French army, taken at “the battle front” of Verdun, and dated 10 October 1918.  Did he think of his duties expended throughout the day, and weeks and months?  Counting dogs as a war effort may have been a hard thing to consume.  Perhaps this officer had already seen his share of war, perhaps he had fought from 1914 and onwards, this position being relatively benign, a reward for years of impossibly difficult service in a bloody war. Or perhaps not.

    “Taking the Census of Dogs for the Army”, an official French war photograph and copyrighted and distributed by the Western Newspaper Union (a news photo service supplying photographic images for newspapers around the country), gives us a peek at what had been an largely untold story about digs in war.  As it turns out, the French started early on in the war training and using dogs to track and aid wounded soldiers on the battlefield; the Germans did so too, their dogs rescuing some 6,000 wounded soldiers by war’s end.  And this continued a story of dogs in wars that’s at least 2,000 years old.

    0--blog---dec 2 dog census173 .  The photograph, though dated 1918, was taken in 1916, during the horrific Battle of Verdun.  IT was yet another enormous battle at Verdun, which had seen more than its fair share of military action over the centuries, owing to the city’s strategic location on the Meuse River.  The men in the photo look worn, as well they should–evidently, owing to replacements and rotation, something like 70% of the entire French army fought in this battle, with 24 French divisions fighting there.  The French lost 161,000 men dead and 101,000 missing, with 216,000 wounded; the Germans lost about 142,000 dead and another 187,000 wounded.  That’s coming up close to 3/4-million men in one battle over several months in 1916, most of which were the victim of the 30 million rounds of artillery shells.


  • A War by Many Other Names: the Japanese Invasion of China, 1931-1945; How to Trivialize 20 Million Killings Without Really Trying

    JF Ptak Science Books Post 404

    I have forced myself to contradict myself in order to avoid conforming to my own taste.
    –Marcel Duchamp

    0--blog---dec 2 china168

    I have a good number of English-language propaganda pieces published by such Hearts and Minds institutions as the Foreign Affairs Association of Japan describing, through the merriest and most defensive eyes, the Japanese viewpoint of exactly what it was that was going on in China between 1931 and 1945.  This leaflet, Why? Who? How? Questions and Answers on the Sino-Japanese Conflict (1937), is particularly worth noting because of how quickly and cleverish-cleanly the issue of the war and the fault of fighting was dispatched, and done with such astonishing condescending alacrity, and with such an enormous bodyguards of lies,as to be staggering.  I guess this is why the Duchamp quote came to me just now.  Old Marcel, the supremely gifted magician, certainly meant to be an enormous, itchy pain in the butt and a source of confusion, an artistic anarchist;  the thinking behind the quote served him well, and I think that it can be well-applied here.                             

    The first issue is in the subtitle:  the “Sino-Japanese Conflict” implies that the Chinese were at fault for having the Japanese invade Manchuria back in 1931; secondly,  the Chinese started a conflict and not a war. 

    Actually, the naming of the war there is quite an issue, and an issue still—and an issue at it most base level:  the word “war” is not generally used in Japan.  It wasn’t used in Japan during the war, or at least until the bombing of Pearl Harbor.  Until 1941, the millions of Chinese who were being killed by the Japanese armed forces were the result of a series of ”incidents”.  Even though there was a war raging from the beginning in 1931 to the start of total Japanese-Chinese war on 15 July 1937, the stuff that was happening from ’37 to ’42  was still an “incident” except for a period of 1940-ish to Pearl, when the idea of the Holy War (“Seisan”, eight corners of the world under one roof, etc.) was introduced by the Japanese Diet in 1940.  After that there was the occasional use of the “Great East Asian Conflict”, with the word “war” not being the part of any Japanese vocabulary.

    An interesting phrase that entered into the parlance though, if not “war”, was “Sanko Sakusen”, the “Three Alls”, as in KILL All, LOOT All, BURN All.  The Japanese wound up getting part of the Chinese All, eventually killing 20 million people or so in those 15 years.  But it wasn’t a war.

    This four-page document asks twenty questions, and answers them usually, emphatically, with simplicity, starkness, and with total complicity of innocence on the side of Japan.  For example, in discussing the “incident” in Beiging in 1937 which led to the total war between the two countries, asking the reader “why did the attempts to settle the incident locally at its early stage fail?,  we are told “Because the Chinese never meant to do so”.  Which of course is not the case.

    An incredible bit of thinking comes next, when the question “If Japan is on the defensive, how can the dispatch of large military and naval forces be accounted for?” Indeed!  Its hard to explain the invasion of another country as a purely defensive action. (We have seen this rather recently ourselves, the fictionalized account of terror-sponsorship in Iraq being about the only fuel necessary for a full-fledged defensive invasion and 2000-day long war.)  But the answer in 1937 was the Chinese defensive maneuver of massing troops for an impending invasion of China by Japan was then threatening Japanese interests in China, thus necessitating a defensive invasion of China which was mobilizing to defend itself from a Japanese offensive, which wouldn’t have come if the Chinese hadn’t adopted a defensive posture.  Basically, to paraphrase the immortal Mayor-for-Life of Washington, D.C, Marion S. Barry, “basically, the man dead”. (This was Barry’s response to reporters who were clamoring to find out what exactly had happened to a crazy man who climbed into a step van in a Buck Rogers suit and threatened to blow up the Washington Monument with a bucket of pee, an old rifle, and spray paint and then was shot about 200 times by cops of every shape and description. True story.)

    War_shanghai-baby_Japan_bombing_shanghai_south_station_1937 (This is a picture of a baby survivor of a Japanese bombing “incident” at  South Station, Shanghai, 1937–sometimes it is better to see what something is than have someone define it for you..)

    We further find out that the attacks on the schools and hospitals in China were carried out, somehow, by Chinese troops; that a Chinese fishing fleet that was attacked and pulverized by Japanese submarines really wasn’t, and that they just disappeared; that Japan was protecting the rights of third party powers by “removing” Chinese troops occupying foreign-owned properties; that the Japanese fight against the “Sovietization” of China would “protect” foreign democracies, and so on.  The questions hardly matter, as the answers are all sort of the same.  Japan would “reach a settlement” (the word “peace” is not used anywhere here) however, if China “realized the error if her ways”. 

    Word do control mental images, and the further you get away from the situation described the more powerful the words become.  Somehow the Korean Conflict seems less so than a war because it wasn’t “legally” so; it was a “police action”.  And the Japan-China War isn’t a “war” in name in most Japanese histories of the period.  I think you can dissolve things with loose undefined language to such a point that the thing itself no longer exists; the only stuff that survives are the words used to hide it. 

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • History’s Heaviest Bad Idea: Maginot, the Million Ton Line in the Sand

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 396

    Poor Andre Maginot–his is the name behind what must be the heaviest bad idea in history–or at least among bad ideas that can have weight.  The Ligne Maginot, or Maginot Line, was probably better referenced as the Maginot Hole, as once the advance came from the East, the “Line” was completely and totally ineffectual, and the soldiers in the miles of tunnels and fortifications became, simply, men in a hole.  The thing about the Maginot Line was that it pointed to exactly the spot where the French Army could be found; therefore, the Germans avoided it. 

    0--blog---Nov 24-maginot111 

    It is difficult to believe that when all of this concrete was being poured and tunnels being dug along the German border between Switzerland and Luxembourg between 1929 and 1936 that someone, somewhere in France wasn’t reading the Illustrirte Zeitung, watching the growth of the Luftwaffe. 

    0--blog---Nov 24-maginot112

    However, as much as that should’ve stopped this massive and insane project, it was not the airplane that buried the buried defenses–it was indeed the feared tanks.  But the Panzers of Heinz Guderin and Erwin Rommel didn’t go through the Maginot Line, they went around it, passing through the supposedly impassible  Ardennes.  Case closed.  Paris gone.

    At least someone in France should’ve been reading their Clausewitz: “If you entrench yourself behind strong fortifications you compel your enemy to seek a solution elsewhere.”

    0--blog---Nov 24-maginot109

    But the drawings are pretty.  And if you moved everything back in time 30 years the idea would’ve made more sense. 

    0--blog---Nov 24-maginot108

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    — —

  • Swimming Soviets and the Great Patriotic War, 1939

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 395

    0--blog---Nov 26 soviet swimming134

     

    This image of swimming Soviet sailors of the Baltic Fleet is from The Illustrated London News for August, 1939.  The sailors were “celebrating”  the first Navy Day for the Soviet Navy, and no other way was better to do this than to swim 400 meters in formation and fully clothes–with rifles on their backs with no water protection whatsoever.  Perhaps this group was just standing in 5 feet of water near the shore–I suspect not, though, because a bunch of these guys look as though they’re really struggling.  We’re about a month away from the German invasion of Poland and the official start to the bigger part of the war that went global:  Czechoslovakia and China had already experienced war for some time now. 

    0--blog---Nov 26 soviet swimming133 On November 30 the Soviets would launch their own hideous offensive, though against Finland:  the Winter War would bring international condemnation of the Soviet Union and give their new ally in Nazi Germany considerable pause.  The Red Army was decimated by the wicked Stalinist purges of the late 1930’s–as much as 50% of the senior military cadre were disappeared and executed–and the army as a whole suffered.  The early result of this action was that the Finns, though vastly out-manned and out-teched  (the Soviet forces had four times as many soldiers as the Finns, 30 times as many aircraft and 200 times as many tanks), were able to last against the Red war machine until March.  An end to hostilities agreement was reached in which Finland maintain its sovereignty and gave away 20% of its industrial base and 9% of its territory.  The Soviets achieved a phyrric victory, the Finns achieved a major success, and the Nazis figured out that perhaps rather than keep the Soviets as a weak ally they might be able to make them into a dead -state enemy (turning against them with  Operation Barbarossa).

    In any event by 1945 my suspicion is that most of these men would be dead.

    Most of the Great Patriotic War of the Soviet Union would take place on land, with Russian military war dead amounting to a staggering 65% of all Allied deaths, with something like 13 to 15 % of the entire population (totaling 168 million) of the Soviet Union being killed during the conflict.  The Soviet sailors would’ve had a better chance of survival, but not by much.

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • On Becoming Nothing: French Collaborators in World War II

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 391

    0--blog---Nov 25 french auto125This curious pamphlet surfaced today—an “expose” on the post-war automobile industry in France; I was curious to see how soon after the war this was published, and then was momentarily shocked to see that it was published in 1943, while France was still heavily occupied by the Nazis.  And then of course I knew why there was any possibility of publishing something like this concerning a huge industry during a time of occupation (when things are normally ground to a halt):  that the French people concerned with this effort had to have been at least part of the puppet Vichy government of Marshall Petain or were  (also) Nazi collaborators.  My vote would have been both.  The author, Francois Lehideux, who died ten years ago at age 94 (1904-1998), was the head of the French automobile organization and working at the pleasure of the onerous Petain, and was in fact arrested in 1945 as a Nazi collaborator once the real French were back in power.  (Lehideux was released a year later for lack of evidence, or something along those lines, though I am sure, like O.J., that everyone knew the true story. Petain, a glorious and important military leader of WWI, a heroic and towering figure, died in senility and was buried on the prison island he was sent to after his death sentence for his traitorous behavior was commuted.  He lived to be 95.)   Lehideux lived a long and trying and no doubt prosperous life.  He was CEO of Renault (having married the founder’s niece in 1934), and then “worked” for the Vichy government (for which he received the meritorious  Order of the Francisque, as did Francois Mitterand), was imprisoned, and then when he was released went to work for another organization comfortable with the Nazis, Ford Motor Corp.  Maybe it was just old Henry–who was a fantastically bad anti-Semite and who received the highest civilian decorator from Adolf Hitler (an award he held on to)—and not the Company that was bad.  Certainly Ford was not the morally-abusive capitalist who behaved intolerably during the war, as there were plenty of those:  Occidental Petroleum, Brown Brothers Harriman (run in part by Prescott Bush (yes), who was convicted and fined under the Trading with the Enemy Act in 1943), Chase Bank, and many others.

    As Lehideux slipped closer to the grave he headed an organization that tried to rehabilitate the image of Petain; long story short, Lehideux could not leave his own sordid past alone, and while trying to cleanse himself by scrubbing up the traitorous and offal-stained Petain, was embroiled in and won a freedom-of-speech lawsuit regarding his adoration for the old dead meat-puppety pisspot. His “victory” was certainly odd and I’m sure that in his own mind his life during the war was vindicated, his role reversed to having helped France arise from the ashes.  But all that happened really was that he was told that he could write what he thought, and nothing more.  In effect he created a fourth referential gender category (as in der/die/das etc): zed.  Nothing.  I think he just became nothing in his victory.  Or nothing until he was dead, and then he was at least that, which is a step-up from nothingness; but while he lived, the man was nothing.  Except of course to the people in France who were injured or killed as a result of his compliances with the Nazis, and then he was less than nothing and should’ve become dead sooner.  But I think he made himself into less and less until he finally achieved nothingness. 


    Finding and paying attention to extremely ephemeral and dead pamphlets like this can be very stimulating, and rewarding; they can make you aware of points of view and thought that you never knew existed, and can hold nuggets to odd pathways of thinking that can only be excited by something similarly odd.  Sometimes all you need is a little piece of exposed ephemeral thread; and then all you have to do is pull it.  

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • Trenching Out in Downtown London

    JF Ptak Science Books LLC  Post 384

    This set of drawings displaying a plan for the protection of the people of London is simple, elegant and brilliant–accessible without speaking down to the readership, complimentary from one image to the next, cohesive, and pretty.  The series was put together for The Illustrated London News for 9 April 1938 in anticipation of bombing that was sure to come, the war clear and visible on the horizon.  (Hitler was in his fifth histrionic year in power,The Berlin Agreement that sacrificed the  Seudetanland to the Nazis would come in September, Hermann Goering calling the Czechs a “miserable pygmy race” who are “harassing the human race.” , Kristallnacht was not far behind.) So.  The wonderful G.H. Davies, the prolific graphic designer (for decades) at the ILN, produced this work, showing the available acreage for digging trenches in and around London.  There wasn’t much outdoor space, as he takes great pains to show, but there was enough to hide and protect tens of thousands of citizens for bombs that would come in 18 months.  Davies also points out the relevant parts of the protective structures–issues that could be found and understood by anyone should the average person decide to build a shelter for themselves.

    000-ebay--Nov 8 london trenches026

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    000-ebay--Nov 8 london trenches027

    000-ebay--Nov 8 london trenches028

    000-ebay--Nov 8 london trenches029