A Daily History of Holes, Dots, Lines, Science, History, Math, Physics, Art, the Unintentional Absurd, Architecture, Maps, Data Visualization, Blank and Missing Things, and so on. |1.6 million words, 7500 images, 4.9 million hits| Press & appearances in The Times, Le Figaro, Mensa, The Economist, The Guardian, Discovery News, Slate, Le Monde, Sci American Blogs, Le Pont, and many other places… 5000+ total posts since 2008.

Category: World War I

  • The Pistol in Air-to-Air Combat (1914)

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 2588

    Air combat 1914The news of the Wright Brothers and their historic powered flight in December 1903 was a monumental deal, though the report of the success was buried in middle of the Scientific American issue that first covered it.  Eleven years later heavier-than-air powered aircraft went from being from non-existent but with potential/possibility to machines used in war.  It took eight years from the Wright plane for an aircraft to be used in combat dropping bombs on people, a role that would of course be exploded beyond all recognition just a few years later. During the first few months of WWI aircraft were used but mostly for surveillance and mapping–aerial combat existed, sort of, though without any firepower. The first air victories were results of aircraft ramming one another (the first seems to have been August 25, 1914), while the first instance of one plane shooting down another didn’t occur until the war was in its second month, a French plane shooting down a German aircraft with a machine gun and a rifle.1

    These notes are simple background for the image that I found in The Illustrated London News (September 19, 1914)  showing aerial combat between a British Bristol and a German Taube.  What is striking of course is that the Royal Flying Corps aircraft was attacking with the co-pilot firing a pistol at the German plane–a little unexpected. The description of the image identifies the pilot of the German aircraft (“Sergeant Werner, the first German to fly over Paris and drop bombs”) and that he had been on a reconnaissance flight mapping allied positions–how that information was known I do not know.  In any event the British aircraft pursued the German and nearly had it within rights–that is until German soldiers on the ground returned fire on the British aircraft, forcing it to retire.  

    Air combat 1914 b

    Luckily I own the war years for the ILN and I do believe that this was the first image in that journal showing air-to-air combat. The ILN does have earlier images showing the first bombing raids from aircraft and also of air-to-ground machine gun attacks, but at this point this may be the first of its kind. It all seems very removed–quaint,even–given how quickly things developed over the next year.  

    Notes

    1. “On October 5, 1914, Sergeant Joseph Frantz and Corporal Louis Quénault of Escadrille VB24 scored the first air-to-air kill (not involving ramming – see Pyotr Nesterov) of the war, shooting down a German Aviatik B.II with machine gun fire. Quénault fired two 48-round magazines at the Germans. The Germans returned fire with rifles. When the Frenchman’s 8 mm Hotchkiss M1909 machine gun jammed, he successfully returned fire with his rifle. Oberleutnant Fritz von Zangen and Sergeant Wilhelm Schlichting of FFA 18 fell to their deaths. This is believed to be the first air-to-air kill in any war.”–a good Wikipedia contribution on the Voisin III, here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voisin_III

  • Jane Austen and the Evasion of Submarines

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

     “The little zigzags of embarrassment.”– J. Austen Emma I. xv. 282, 1816

    Zig zag027

    Well, these be not zigzags of embarrassment, but zigzags of necessity, and the means for keeping track of them.  And too there’s nothing in Jane Austen to relate to submarines and their evasion except for an appearance of the word “zigzag”, which is actually a fairly old word in English (coming from the French “sigsak”), reaching down into the very early 18th century.  It is older than the word “submarine” as it is used to describe an underwater vessel, and curiously in light of Ms. Austen it appears in print very close to the date of Emma, in 18281. And so the course of a ship could be documented for those in control of her, keeping track of the true destination in spite of all the zigs and zgas made to confuse and elude a German sub.  This is another example of an empire controlled with string, as we have previously seen here in the use of long collections of string that kept track of the British rail. String isn’t as simple as it seems.  

    • This short article appeared in Popular Mechanics, March, 1918, page 484. 

  • WWI Project: German Poster Painters, 1917

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post 

    This is an unusual image, a behind-the-scenes, behind-the-lines, everyday domestic front scene, something showing the war going on in the trenches (so to speak) at home. It shows two civilians working on popular posters for movies (“Die Silbernen Kugeln…”) and fund raising (“Die Deutsche Kriegs Anlehe”) for the German army. The image was found in the May 1917 issue of the (Leipzig) Illustrirte Zeitung:

    WWI poster painters

     

    No doubt there was a lot of this sort of activity going on, in wartime and not, but in my 30 years of travels through the history of illustration I don’t often see these images. 

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • The History of Sleep: Tough Going in the Trenches, 1916

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post
     
                  “What hath night to do with sleep?” John Milton, Paradise Lost
     
    Sleeping during front line duty in WWI was a mixed affair, at best–there could be weeks of tedium (even in the Spring) while a soldier’s front line tour extended over four to eight weeks (with about the same amount of time in the other lines of battlefield defense), followed by days or weeks of firing and fighting. In the bad times sleep would come when available, and convenience didn’t necessarily have anything to do with it, as we can tell in this photograph.  Here the soldiers are crammed into any little indentation in the walls of the trench, any little bit that would keep them from being underfoot should anyone need to walk the trench line. It was not only the sound of battle and the struggle to stay alive–sleep was assaulted by many other things, even in times of the space-in-between-the-fighting: there was a significant rat issue, there was a potential cascading problem of what to do with human waste, bugs, the wet, the cold (and the wet and the cold), the heat, stench, humidity, and then just general discomfort. 
     
    Needless to say that in general, sleep was difficult on the front. 
     
     

    WWI Sleep

     
    Source: Imperial War Museum. “Soldiers of ‘A’ Company, 11th Battalion, the Cheshire Regiment, occupy a captured German trench. Q 3990 This photograph shows an infantryman on sentry duty, whilst some of his comrades snatch a few moments of sleep behind him. They are in what was previously a German trench at Ovillers-la-Boisselle on the Somme, July 1916.”
     
     
     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • The Canadian “College of Arms and Legs” for the Maimed Soldier (1917)

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    I’m reprinting this rare broadside in the interest of the medical history of WWI.  It seems not to be anywhere (I can only find one copy in WorldCat, at the Countway Library at Harvard University) and I’m not finding any references to it, offhand.  It is interesting and appealing, a no-nonsense approach to provoking necessary attention to creating and securing artificial limbs for wounded Canadian solders.

    Canada of course joined the war effort against Germany on the same day as Great Britain, about two and a half years before the U.S. declared war. In all more than 61,000 Canadian soldiers were killed during the war, as well as 172,000 wounded–the U.S. in contrast lost 126,000 killed and 204,000 wounded.  Similar numbers, in a way, except that the U.S. had more than ten times the population, 92 million versus 7.2 mullion in Canada.  The 172k wounded coming home in Canada would’ve been like 2.3 million returning to the U.S. (a number larger than the 2.09 million returning wounded in all of the British Empire). All that said: 230,000 killed and wounded in a population of 7/2 million is considerable. 

    This broadside discusses the Military Hospital Commission and the Orthopedic Hospital, and how its address (Yonge Street) could be renamed “Crutched Soldiers”, and that “was a title of honor, not reproach” and a “spur to bravery”. There is a discussion of Canadian legs versus English legs, leg weights, and such. Of high interest for me, though was the discussion of “two kinds of motorist”–one who always stops and gives a ride to a wounded soldier in the vicinity of the hospital, and the other, who doesn’t. The writer of the broadside clearly has no use for the later.

    The report, in full (it is more legible expanded):

    College Arms and Legs c full

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:

    —

  • British Jackies and Bruegel in Russia (1918)

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post 

    “Complexity” is an interesting word with far-ranging roots and applications, and even though the may be a long trail of definitions for it, a person can generally recognize it when they see it. That word can certainly be used to describe the situation in Russia at the end of WWI, and in a way the least of it may have been when the Allies intervened there (with a large physical presence in an action was known as the North Russia Intervention/Northern Russian Expedition/Archangel Campaign) in support of the White Army/Guard in their struggle and fight against the Communist Red Army during the period when Alexander Kerensky’s Russian Provincial Government fought the Germans on the Eastern Front during the Russian Civil War (1917-1923). The Allies stayed from 1918 until 1920, mostly fighting in defensive roles for White Army pullbacks.

    And somewhere in that mix of complexities came moments captured by this image below–it comes from the closing weeks of WWI and shows a group of “British Jackies” readying a portion of the River Dwina at Archangel (Archangelsk) as a skating rink. Evidently there was scraping and sweeping and the use of hot water from the British ship to help smooth the ice.  

    The contrast in the many figures against the wide river reminded me of the very-populated scenes created by Peter Bruegel (1525-1569) the Elder, the Brabant-born master of the social scene of the Northern Renaissance.  Bruegel painted the lives of common folks at work, children playing, and in general portrayed people at all manner of activities and celebrations, including dozens or hundreds in his social-scapes. That is what immediately came to mind seeing this photograph:

    WWI  Skating Brits087

    One of the many long-perspective, highly-populated scenes by Bruegel–it might take a little squinting, but this is what that photograph reminded me of:

    Bruegel populations

     

    [298 images by Bruegel are available at Pieter Bruegel the Elder.org:  http://www.pieter-bruegel-the-elder.org/the-complete-works.html]

     

     

     

     

     

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • Summertime Victory: Soldiers Bathing in the Marne, 1918

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    Here’s an interesting and terribly human image of WWI, made deep inside the war, nearly at the war’s end, and which was distributed beginning 17 September 1918 by the Western Newspaper Union, and a French Official war photograph.  It is a celebration of sorts–a short one–following the Second Battle of the Marne, which was the last German offensive on the Western Front, and which ended on August 6, five weeks before this photo was released and 100 or so days before the end of the war. The battle spelled the end for Germany in the war (costing a total of more than 270,000 killed or wounded) and began the steady march to Versailles.  After three weeks of terrible fighting, the relief to the soldiers in the photo must have been extraordinary–it is certainly palpable in the image.

    WWI   Bathing Marne086

    [Source: The History of Ideas Blog WWI Photo Collection, details:  https://historyofideasblog.com/world_war_i_photography/]

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • Early Approach to Anti-Aircraft, 1917

    JF Ptak Science Books   Quick Post

    WWI SAlonica AA rifles

    [Source: Illustrirte Zeitung, March 17, 1917.]

    This is an odd image–or at least at first glance it looks odd–showing Turkish soldiers at “Salonikifront’/Salonica, Thessalonia practicing at anti-aircraft fire and enemy plane control.  The thing is that in order to have an sort of effectiveness in bombing or strafing the aircraft would have to be relatively low and slow, even for those times. It is possible that they could be shooting at aircraft traveling at 80mph and low enough to be reachable by rifle fire.  With this many rifles, the idea may have been workable.  

    ·Posted by :

    ·in:


  • When a Little Bit of the Future Got To WWI

    JF Ptak Science Books  Post 2600

    The hope for technological advancement to hasten the end of the war were much discussed during WWI–the dreams and aspirations sometimes winding up in a serialized fashion in magazines such as l’Heure, seen below.  The promise of the magazine “The Hour” was to reveal the nature of a machine discovered that would bring an end to the war.  It was highly fanciful, this machine, and highly effective, as we can see by the large field littered with German soldiers, done in by a death ray/spray of some sort. The whole of it looks more like a Wells’ Martian creation than anything else. 

    WWI IWM future war

    [Image source: Imperial War Museum, http://www.iwm.org.uk/collections/item/object/19414]

    And long as I am here and the reference is at hand, I  would like to point out this terrific link to the very interesting La Guerre Infernale by Pierre Giffard, and with illustrations by the iconic A. Robida:

    Rhobida guerre infernal

    [Source, with a set of all of the illustrations is found here:  http://www.merveilleuxscientifique.fr/auteurs/robida-alfred-la-guerre-infernale/]

    But what I really wanted to talk about was on the much smaller and real level, particularly this exploration of battlefield lighting, found in the August 1916 issue of Popular Mechanics Magazine.  It was one of the technological advances in this war that brought something that worked better and much more simple than that displayed in the magazine–the “simple” flare gun, also known in England as the Very pistol. It was new to war (along with such things as the tank, military applications of barbed wire, depth charges, flamethrowers, and such) and it was of course very effective. And deadly. And protective. It illuminated a field of battle, particularly Dead Man’s Land, that stretch of land between the two offensive lines that was a meeting place of death, cluttered with bodies, spoiled earth, water-filled craters, barbed wire, waste, and so on–and it was sometimes into this sort of field that an attack would be made under cover of darkness, and it was the Very pistol that would be fired to illuminate the attackers, who would suffer greatly from it.  In any event, it was a far better response to a need than the aerial torpedo torch.  

     

    Aerial torpedo torch067

     

     


  • What the Sound of the End of War Looked Like, 11/11/1918

    JF Ptak Science Books  Quick Post

    What the end of the war sounded like was, well, nothing–it was the absence of something, and no doubt for all of those involved it was the absence of the Everything that was manufactured to take away their lives.  This photograph of the display of recorded sound at the battlefield  shows the moment the war ended, at 11 o’clock on the 11th day of the 11th month, 1918.  

     November 11th  what peace sounded like

    [Source: http://www.newsweek.com/2014/11/14/amazing-photo-shows-moment-guns-fell-silent-282453.html]

    Attack, by Siegfried Sassoon (1917)

    At dawn the ridge emerges massed and dun 
    In the wild purple of the glow’ring sun, 
    Smouldering through spouts of drifting smoke that shroud 
    The menacing scarred slope; and, one by one, 
    Tanks creep and topple forward to the wire. 
    The barrage roars and lifts. Then, clumsily bowed 
    With bombs and guns and shovels and battle-gear, 
    Men jostle and climb to, meet the bristling fire. 
    Lines of grey, muttering faces, masked with fear, 
    They leave their trenches, going over the top, 
    While time ticks blank and busy on their wrists, 
    And hope, with furtive eyes and grappling fists, 
    Flounders in mud. O Jesus, make it stop!